Hermetica.info
home page
Save as "Page Source"
for a desktop html copy
Yijing Hexagram Names and Core Meanings
易經卦名和中義
Yìjīng guàmíng hé zhōngyì
© Bradford Hatcher, 2011, Version 12.1
|
720 Cell
Preface
Since this is primarily a reference work,
the introductory material has been placed at
the end, to facilitate scrolling through the
64 tables below.
These tables offer
what a large number of different translators
and authors have used for Hexagram Names
(Gua Ming) and/or major Core Meanings (Zhong
Yi) for the 64 Gua. (The eight Bagua and
other symbols are already covered in my Book of
Changes, Vol. 1, Xiao Xiang
chapter). Multiple listings in these tables
should absolutely not be regarded as a poll
or a vote. The Wilhelm-Baynes Gua Ming,
while at least adequate more often than not,
has exerted a huge and, in many cases, undue
influence on other authors. A number of
authors have been omitted because they
simply copied Wilhelm's names. Other writers
seem to have groped about for synonyms to
Wilhelm's names and substituted these with
little or no insight into the Core Meanings.
Of particular importance is the last entry
in the tables, which comes from the Shi Yi,
the Ten Wings or Appendices of the Yijing
itself, added to the Zhouyi during the
Han Dynasty. Although written six or more
centuries after the Zhouyi, many of these
glosses have had a dominant or even absolute
influence over how the Gua Ming have come to
be understood. The bulk of these come from
the Tuan Zhuan, or Commentary on the
Judgment. In many cases, these are the only
significant or meaningful contribution that
the Tuan Zhuan makes. In some places I have
instead given glosses from other Wings: the
Da Xiang, the Xu Gua or the Za Gua.
The Key Words section
is from my Book of Changes, Vol. 1.
These represent a partial scoping of Core
Meanings. The Glossary section is from my Book of
Changes, Vol. 2. These list the
possible translations of the Chinese names,
but without strict regard to meanings
attested for the Early Zhou. Finally, in the
Notes section, I try to make relevant
comments on some of the Names used in the
tables and point out problems with some of
the conventional names.
|
|
01
乾 Qián
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Creative
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Jian4, The Key,
Note, Linch-pin
|
Albertson
|
The Creative
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
鍵 #1, The Key
|
Balkin |
The Dynamic |
Meyer |
Fulfilled
Promise
|
Barrett
|
Creative Force
|
Needham |
Donator,
Originator, Ordering, Paternal
|
Blofeld
|
The Creative
Principle |
Ni |
Positiveness, The
Creative
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Creative
|
Palmer |
The Origin
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Assertive
|
Pattee |
The Creative
|
Chang
|
Heaven
|
Peden |
The Creative
|
Chu
|
Creative
(Innovatory) Action |
Perrottet |
The Creative
|
Chung Wu
|
The Originator
|
Powell |
The Creative
Principle |
Clark
|
Creative Force in
Action
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Self-Expression,
The Creative
|
Cleary |
Heaven, The
Creative |
Reifler |
Yang
|
Coates
|
The Creative Force
|
Richmond |
Responses to
Creative potential
|
Collins
|
The Firm
|
Richter |
Heaven
|
Crouch
|
Spirit
|
Riseman |
The Creative
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Creative
(Talent) |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Force, Persisting
|
Dening
|
The Creative Force
|
Rutt |
Active
|
Dhiegh
|
The Originating,
Projective, The Creative |
Seabrook |
Originality
|
Douglas
|
Creativity
|
Secter |
Substantive,
Originating, Impartial
|
Feng
|
Creative, Sunshine
|
Shaughnessy |
The Heavenly
Principle, Vigor, Vigorous
|
Fu Youde |
Heaven
|
Shchutskii |
Creation
|
Graeme
|
The Creative
|
Siu |
Creativity |
Hacker
|
Heaven
|
Sneddon |
Creative |
Hatcher
|
Creating
|
Sorrell |
Cause, Power,
Creativity |
Heyboer
|
The Directing Power
of Heaven
|
Stackhouse
|
Vital Spirit
|
Hoefler
|
The Creative Power
|
Stein |
The Creative
Universe/Intelligence |
Huang, Alfred
|
Initiating
|
Sterling |
Creative
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Heaven
|
Sung |
Firmness symbolizes
Heaven
|
Javary
|
Absolute Yang
Energy
|
Toropov |
The Creative
|
Jou
|
The Heaven
|
Walker, Barbara |
Heaven, Air, Sky,
Authority
|
Judge
|
Creativity
|
Wallace |
Heaven, Initiating
|
Karcher
|
Force, Persisting
|
Wei, Henry |
Creativity
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Heaven
|
West |
Creativity
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Active
|
Whincup |
Strong Action
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Heaven, Pure Yang,
The Creative Principle
|
Wilhelm |
The Creative |
Kunst |
Vigorous Appearance
|
Wing |
Creative Power |
Legge
|
Active, Vigilant,
Heaven
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Heaven, Male, The
Creative
|
Leichtman
|
Power to Overcome,
New Life Energy
|
Wu, Yi |
Pure Light Enrergy
|
Liu, Da, Da
|
The Creative |
Wu Wei |
Creating
|
Lynn
|
Pure Yang
|
Wu Weifarer |
Yang
|
Machovec
|
Strength of the
Dragon
|
Young |
Creation |
Market
|
The Male Principle
|
Yu, Titus |
Enflaming
Inspiration |
Marshall, Chris
|
The Creative
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Heaven
|
十翼 Shi Yi
|
健 Jian4, Lasting
Vigor, Strong, Healthy
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cel
720 Cell
720 Ce
720 Cell
01.M,
Key Words
Higher purpose, self-actualizing drives, autonomy,
calling, vocation, star quality
Sovereignty, command, self-mastery, dragonhood,
genius, authority, cogency
Diligence, drive, lasting energy, enduring vigor,
persistence or duration in time
Higher orders, design, innovation; co-authoring
with the infinite, dynamic life
Positing, originality, initiative; sublimation,
sunlight transforming water to vapor
Perspective from outside of humanity, attunement
to higher rhythms & purposes
01.G, From the
Glossary
Qian2 (to
be) creative, vigorous, energetic, potent,
dynamic, constant, enduring,
lasting; dry, clean;
exhausted; heavenly; (a, the) creation,
initiative, authority,
sovereignty, design,
cogency, autonomy, command, energy, diligence,
persistence, endurance, mastery, genius, higher
order, higher purpose, calling, vocation,
enduring activity, lasting vigor, dynamic living,
dragonhood; heaven; warmth of
the sun; vigorous
appearance; (a, the) male, gang or yang principle;
(to) create,
initiate, design, author, master,
persist, endure (s, ed, ing); creation’s,
creativity’s;
gan, (to be) dry, dried
Notes:
On Heaven: I have argued
elsewhere that one of the great mistakes of the
social sciences in studying the past is in making
sweeping generalizations about cultural norms
which are more usefully considered as broad
spectra. It shouldn't need saying that the
Christian and Muslim notions of Heaven have no
place here. While Heaven is indeed sacred in most
Chinese traditions, it is not a deity. On the
average, it is the grand order of things, the
natural law, the clockworks, the self-organizing
power that drives the heavens. This warrants great
respect, even reverence, at least as an
alternative to self-destruction. There is still a
broad range in this comprehension on the
secular-religious axis and even the range from
king to king could well have been quite dramatic,
even though the king was at the very head of the
popular religion. The transition from Shang to
Zhou represented a movement towards the secular
side, but a great many, no doubt, maintained a
belief that the spirit resided in Heaven after
death, and many of those, under the care of Shang
Di, the Highest Divinity. The Zhouyi tends towards
the secular. Even though there are plenty of
snapshots of both the king and the people doing
religious practices and sacrifices, the study is
always of the human behavior and its attitudes in
performing these acts. It never once proposes or
supports a religious or metaphysical idea.
To be sure, a lot of metaphysics was added to the
Yi in the Han Dynasty, with the canonization of
the Yijing's Ten Wings, but this is not our
concern here. Heaven, then, is best understood
here as the motive power of the cosmos, highly
structured but not likely sentient. Maybe the
bottom line is this: if you can discover what
Heaven "will" do, and take this to be Heaven's
Will, and somehow align your objectives in this
direction, then you will have the assistance of
Heaven, along with an infinite reserve of inertia
and power.
|
|
02
坤 Kūn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Receptive |
MWD - Hatcher |
Chuan1, River,
Stream, Current, Flow
|
Albertson
|
The Receptive |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
川 #33, The Flow
|
Balkin |
The Receptive |
Meyer |
Raw
Material
|
Barrett
|
Earth
|
Needham |
Receptor,
Supporting
|
Blofeld
|
The Passive
Principle
|
Ni |
Receptiveness
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Receptive
|
Palmer |
Success
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Inner Strength
|
Pattee |
The Receptive |
Chang
|
Earth
|
Peden |
The Receptive |
Chu
|
Receptiveness,
Responsiveness
|
Perrottet |
The Receptive |
Chung Wu
|
The Bearer
|
Powell |
The Passive
Principle
|
Clark
|
Nurturing
Receptivity
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Direction of Self
|
Cleary |
Earth, The
Receptive |
Reifler |
Yin
|
Coates
|
The Devoted
Subordinate
|
Richmond |
Choices Amongst
Activity
|
Collins
|
The Yielding
|
Richter |
Earth
|
Crouch
|
Soil
|
Riseman |
The Receptive |
Damian-Knight
|
The Receptive, Care
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Force, Yielding
|
Dening
|
Responsiveness
|
Rutt |
Earth
|
Dhiegh
|
The Receptive, The
Womb, The Doer
|
Seabrook |
Fulfilling Destiny
|
Douglas
|
Quiescence
|
Secter |
Fruition,
Nurturing, Fulfillment
|
Feng
|
Earthy, Home Land
|
Shaughnessy |
The Earthly
Principle, Compliant 順
|
Fu Youde |
Earth
|
Shchutskii |
Fulfillment
|
Graeme
|
The Receptive
|
Siu |
Responsive Service
|
Hacker
|
Earth
|
Sneddon |
Receptive |
Hatcher
|
Accepting
|
Sorrell |
Relaxing,
Following, Responsive |
Heyboer
|
The Energy of Earth
|
Stackhouse
|
Multiplicity of
Things
|
Hoefler
|
The Receiving
|
Stein |
The Receptive Earth
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Responding
|
Sterling |
Receptive
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Earth
|
Sung |
Submission
symbolizes Earth
|
Javary
|
Absolute Yin Energy
|
Toropov |
The Receptive |
Jou
|
The Earth
|
Walker, Barbara |
Nature, Earth,
Creation
|
Judge
|
Receptivity
|
Wallace |
Earth, Responding
|
Karcher
|
Field, Yielding
|
Wei, Henry |
Receptivity |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Earth
|
West |
Receptiveness
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Receptive
|
Whincup |
Acquiescence
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Earth, Pure Yin,
Passive, Receptive
|
Wilhelm |
The Receptive
|
Kunst |
<None>
|
Wing |
Natural Response
|
Legge
|
Subordination,
Docility
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Receptivity, Earth,
Female, The Receptive |
Leichtman
|
The Right Response,
Responsiveness
|
Wu, Yi |
Pure Dark Energy
|
Liu, Da
|
The Receptive |
Wu Wei |
Open, Receptive,
Yielding, Willing to Follow
|
Lynn
|
Pure Yin
|
Wu Weifarer |
Yin
|
Machovec
|
Loving Service of
the Earth Mother
|
Young |
Fulfillment
|
Market
|
The Female
Principle
|
Yu, Titus |
Earth's Fecundity
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Receptive
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Earth |
十翼 Shi Yi |
順 Shun4,
Acceptance, Compliance
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cel<br> <br> <br> <br>
720 Cell
720 Cell
02.M, Key Words
Receiving,
tolerance, gentleness, patience, openness,
accommodation, gratitude
Assent, contentment, comprehension,
understanding, embrace, room, allowance
Endurance, perseverance, acquiescence,
compliance, groundedness, support, care
Potential, capacity, raw material, substance,
suchness, realism, consent, upholding
Simplicity, naturalness, surety; latitude,
range, breadth, largesse, fields of options
Power of possibility, first accept givens;
absorbing, learning, growing, accessing
02.G, From the
Glossary
Kun1 (to)
receive, accept, support, absorb, substantiate,
realize (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
receiving,
acceptance, compliance, substance, matter,
material, field (of options),
potential, basis,
support, ground, capacity, earth; (to be)
subordinate, humble(r),
passive, accepting,
compliant; the earth; (a, the) female, rou, or
yin principle
Notes:
On Yin: The Zhouyi was written long before there
was a metaphysics of Yin and Yang. The authors
did have a strong concept of the interplay of
opposites, but this was still more of a
description of the Way the world behaved than a
cosmology of two ultimate and universal forces.
The contrast of Qian and Kun, Gua 01 and 02,
along with other pairs, notably 11-12, 41-42 and
63-64 could perhaps be regarded as early
prototypes of the Taijitu and the Yin-Yang idea,
but they simply did not have the more complex
reasoning that came with the Yinyang Jia or
School of Yin-Yang philosophy. For purposes
here, then, Heaven-Earth, Creating-Creation or
even Energy-Mass are less anachronistic names
than Yang-Yin.
|
|
03
屯 Zhūn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Initial Difficulty
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text
|
Albertson
|
Initial Obstacles |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #23 |
Balkin |
Difficulty in the
Beginning |
Meyer |
Hard
Start
|
Barrett
|
Sprouting
|
Needham |
Factors Slowing the
Onset of a Process
|
Blofeld
|
Difficulty
|
Ni |
To Be Stationed, To
Assemble
|
Bonnershaw
|
Obstacle
|
Palmer |
Birth Pangs
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Difficulty
|
Pattee |
Difficulty at the
Beginning |
Chang
|
Beginning and
Enterprise
|
Peden |
Difficulty at the
Beginning |
Chu
|
Difficulty in
Infancy
|
Perrottet |
Initial Difficulty
|
Chung Wu
|
Distress
|
Powell |
Initial
Difficulties
|
Clark
|
Incubation
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Ordering
|
Cleary |
Difficulty |
Reifler |
Growing Pains
|
Coates
|
Initial
Difficulties
|
Richmond |
Difficulties in
Beginnings |
Collins
|
Beginning
Difficulties |
Richter |
Difficulty
|
Crouch
|
Gathering
|
Riseman |
Difficulty in the
Beginning |
Damian-Knight
|
Difficult
Beginnings |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Sprouting
|
Dening
|
Difficulty at the
Beginning |
Rutt |
Massed
|
Dhiegh
|
Avaricious,
Difficulty at the Beginning |
Seabrook |
Difficult
Beginnings
|
Douglas
|
Birth Pangs
|
Secter |
Initial Difficulty,
Struggle
|
Feng
|
Sprouting
|
Shaughnessy |
Hoarding
|
Fu Youde |
Difficulty
|
Shchutskii |
Initial Difficulty
|
Graeme
|
The Beginning
|
Siu |
Organizational
Growth Pains
|
Hacker
|
Sprouting
|
Sneddon |
Initial Difficulty
|
Hatcher
|
Rallying
|
Sorrell |
Planning,
Organizing, Problem Solving |
Heyboer
|
The Spark of Life
|
Stackhouse |
The Difficulties of
Getting Started
|
Hoefler
|
Difficulty Starting
|
Stein |
Beginnings
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Beginning
|
Sterling |
Difficulties at the
Beginning
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Retrenchment
|
Sung |
Bursting
|
Javary
|
Hindering at the
Beginning
|
Toropov |
Adversity at the
Beginning
|
Jou
|
First Difficulty
|
Walker, Barbara |
Difficulty
|
Judge
|
Initial Difficulty
|
Wallace |
Difficulty
|
Karcher
|
Sprouting
|
Wei, Henry |
Initial Difficulty
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Difficulties of
Beginning
|
West |
Initial Difficulty
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Initial
Difficulties
|
Whincup |
Gathering Support
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Difficulty at First
|
Wilhelm |
Difficulty at the
Beginning |
Kunst |
Bunched, To Hoard
|
Wing |
Difficult
Beginnings
|
Legge
|
Distressed,
Struggle
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Sprouting
|
Leichtman
|
Starting Over,
Before the Beginning
|
Wu, Yi |
Initial Difficulty
|
Liu, Da
|
Difficulty in the
Beginning |
Wu Wei |
Difficulty and
Danger at the Beginning
|
Lynn
|
Birth Throes
|
Wu Weifarer |
Giving Birth
|
Machovec
|
Growth
|
Young |
Initial Difficulty
|
Market
|
Difficult First
Steps
|
Yu, Titus |
Sprouting
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Difficult Start
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Initial
Difficulties |
十翼 Shi Yi |
難生 Nan2 Sheng1,
Difficult Birth
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
03.M, Key Words
Struggle, difficult beginning,
birth/growth/early/first trials, frustration,
confusion
Needing assistance, reinforcement, concentration,
coherence, pulling (it) together
Fallback, triage, retrenchment, regrouping,
muster; to minimize loss, hold/bear up
Prioritizing, consolidating a position, using
reserves; the write off, the rainy day
Courtship metaphor for confusion, frustration and
turmoil; young sprout as Zhen
Frustrated anticipation, the loss of unhatched
chickens, the linearity of expectation
03.G, From the
Glossary
Zhun1 (to)
rally, muster, collect (together), store up,
bank (up), assemble, accumulate, pull together,
bring together, summon (help), congregate,
secure; need help,
need assistance, struggle,
sprout, start (out) small (s, ed, ing); (to be)
in difficulty,
in need of (help, assistance),
sparing, hard, difficult; (a, the) village,
congregation,
camp, rally, initial difficulty,
difficult start, birth pains, early trials,
rites of pas-
sage; a single blade of grass,
bending and twisting; (to consolidate gains
while
cutting losses); to garrison or station
soldiers; also pronounced Tun2.
Notes:
The link between Sprout and Difficult Beginnings
is the image of the freshly sprouted plant
emerging from the Earth into a storm, with no
alternative but to call upon or rally all of its
resources. The ability to secure whatever
resources and help it requires will be its
answer to evolution's selection process.
|
|
04
蒙 Méng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Youthful
Inexperience |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Inexperienced Youth
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #13 |
Balkin |
Youthful
Inexperience |
Meyer |
Lack
of Experience
|
Barrett
|
Not Knowing
|
Needham |
Early Stages of
Development
|
Blofeld
|
Immaturity,
Uncultivated Growth
|
Ni |
The Undeveloped One
|
Bonnershaw
|
Childishness
|
Palmer |
Rebellious Youth
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Wild Grass, The
Undisciplined
|
Pattee |
Immaturity
|
Chang
|
Education
|
Peden |
Inexperience |
Chu
|
Immaturity
|
Perrottet |
Youthful Folly
|
Chung Wu
|
Ignorance (N)
|
Powell |
Youthful
Inexperience |
Clark
|
Inexperience
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Formulization
|
Cleary |
Darkness, Innocence
(25)
|
Reifler |
Youthful Ignorance
|
Coates
|
Youthful
Indiscretion
|
Richmond |
Out of Young
Ignorance
|
Collins
|
Advising the Youth
|
Richter |
Ignorance
|
Crouch
|
Strangleweed
|
Riseman |
Youth
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Inexperience of
the Young, The Student
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Enveloping
|
Dening
|
Inexperience
|
Rutt |
Dodder
|
Dhiegh
|
Youthful Folly,
Innocence (25) |
Seabrook |
Inexperience |
Douglas
|
Inexperience |
Secter |
Inexperienced,
Ignorant, Uninformed |
Feng
|
Ignorance
|
Shaughnessy |
Folly
|
Fu Youde |
Immaturity
|
Shchutskii |
Immaturity
|
Graeme
|
Youth, Inexperience
|
Siu |
Acquiring
Experience |
Hacker
|
The Young Shoot
|
Sneddon |
Youthful
Inexperience |
Hatcher
|
Inexperience
|
Sorrell |
Learning, Beginner,
Unknowing |
Heyboer
|
Not Knowing
|
Stackhouse |
Getting Caught Up
(In Your Own Thing)
|
Hoefler
|
Inexperience |
Stein |
Youthful Folly |
Huang, Alfred
|
Childhood
|
Sterling |
The Folly of Youth
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Blindness
|
Sung |
Covering
|
Javary
|
Learning How to
Learn
|
Toropov |
Youthful Folly |
Jou
|
Underdeveloped
|
Walker, Barbara |
Immaturity,
Ignorance, Inexperience
|
Judge
|
Inexperience
|
Wallace |
Ignorance
|
Karcher
|
Enveloping
|
Wei, Henry |
Ignorance
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Immaturity
|
West |
Inexperience
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Immaturity
|
Whincup |
The Young Shoot
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Novice
|
Wilhelm |
Youthful Folly
|
Kunst |
Cover, Dodder
|
Wing |
Inexperience |
Legge
|
Ignorance N,
Without Experience
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Covering, A Callow
Youth
|
Leichtman
|
Blind Spots,
Indiscretion
|
Wu, Yi |
Ignorance
|
Liu, Da
|
Youth
|
Wu Wei |
Inexperience |
Lynn
|
Juvenile Ignorance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Youth
|
Machovec
|
Learning
|
Young |
Youthful Ignorance
|
Market
|
Learning and
Teaching
|
Yu, Titus |
The Neophyte
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Youthful Folly |
|
|
McCarver
|
Youthful
Inexperience |
十翼 Shi Yi |
蒙童 Tong2 Meng2,
Youthful Inexperience |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
04.M, Key Words
Early development, education, guidance;
differentiating, specifying, personalizing
Inquiry, questioning, questing, discovery;
fulfilling potentials, talents, aptitudes
Foolishness, folly, ignorance; a childlike hunger
to know, untrained green vines
To be covered, blinded, immature, obscure,
obtuse, uncultivated, inexperienced
Making connections and pruning, learning and
unlearning, training the mind
Educate as to lead out; instruction; importance of
questions in framing answers
04.G, From the
Glossary
Meng2 (a,
the) inexperience, immaturity, innocence,
darkness, obscurity, cover,
ignorance,
insensibility, foolishness, deception, folly,
stupidity, fool, halfwit,
(tangled, untrained)
green vines; (to) cover, conceal, hide, cheat,
dupe, deceive,
darken, stun, receive, suffer,
undergo (s, ed, ing); (to be) inexperienced,
uncultivated, rudimentary, rude, crude; passive,
subjected to; entangled, obscure, immature,
young, ignorant, foolish, dull, green, blind, in
the dark, darkened, enveloped, uninformed,
shrouded, unenlightened, unconscious,
insensible, foolish;
the small of a thing; go
with covered eyes
Notes:
The continuum here is is from Ignoring,
willfully or stubbornly failing to consider new
experience, to the more innocent kind of
Ignorance, not yet having had the opportunity to
learn. Ignorance, then, when purely pejorative
and not used in fun, is not the best Gua Ming.
|
|
05
需 Xū
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Waiting |
MWD - Hatcher |
Ru2, Short Coat,
maybe u.f. m3149, Wet
|
Albertson
|
Waiting |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
襦 #18, Short Coat,
Moistened
|
Balkin |
Waiting |
Meyer |
Time
Out
|
Barrett
|
Waiting
|
Needham |
Stopping, Waiting |
Blofeld
|
Calculated Inaction
|
Ni |
Waiting,
Stagnation, Hesitation |
Bonnershaw
|
Postponement
|
Palmer |
Patience
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Waiting
|
Pattee |
Waiting |
Chang
|
Deadlock
|
Peden |
Waiting |
Chu
|
Waiting |
Perrottet |
Waiting |
Chung Wu
|
Waiting
|
Powell |
Patient
Anticipation
|
Clark
|
Waiting
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Fixed Rhythms
|
Cleary |
Waiting |
Reifler |
Waiting |
Coates
|
Waiting Patiently
|
Richmond |
Lack of a Path
|
Collins
|
Waiting |
Richter |
Waiting
|
Crouch
|
In the Rain (N)
|
Riseman |
Contemplation (20),
Nourishment
|
Damian-Knight
|
Patience
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Attending
|
Dening
|
Waiting
|
Rutt |
Waiting
|
Dhiegh
|
Waiting, Calculated
Inaction, Need |
Seabrook |
Waiting
|
Douglas
|
Biding One's Time
|
Secter |
Pausing, Deliberate
Waiting, Biding Time |
Feng
|
Recess
|
Shaughnessy |
To Await
|
Fu Youde |
Waiting
|
Shchutskii |
Necessity of
Waiting |
Graeme
|
Waiting for
Nourishment, Anticipating
|
Siu |
Biding One's Time
|
Hacker
|
Getting Wet N
|
Sneddon |
Waiting |
Hatcher
|
Anticipation
|
Sorrell |
Waiting, Pausing,
Anticipation |
Heyboer
|
Waiting for a Break
in the Weather
|
Stackhouse |
Waiting, then
Receiving what one Needs
|
Hoefler
|
Considered Waiting
|
Stein |
Waiting Nourishment
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Needing
|
Sterling |
Waiting |
Huang, Kerson
|
Waiting |
Sung |
Waiting
|
Javary
|
Making the Most of
Waiting √
|
Toropov |
Waiting
(Sustenance)
|
Jou
|
Waiting
|
Walker, Barbara |
Waiting, Calculated
Inaction
|
Judge
|
Waiting
|
Wallace |
Anticipating
|
Karcher
|
Attending
|
Wei, Henry |
Waiting |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Waiting
|
West |
Waiting
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Waiting Patiently
|
Whincup |
Getting Wet N
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Calculated Waiting,
Remaining Inactive
|
Wilhelm |
Waiting
(Nourishment) |
Kunst |
Get Wet N, Wait
|
Wing |
Calculated Waiting
|
Legge
|
Waiting
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Stopped by Rain N,
Waiting |
Leichtman
|
Patience
|
Wu, Yi |
Waiting
|
Liu, Da
|
Waiting
(Nourishment) |
Wu Wei |
Waiting in the Face
of Danger
|
Lynn
|
Waiting
|
Wu Weifarer |
Waiting
|
Machovec
|
Watchful Waiting |
Young |
Waiting |
Market
|
Waiting |
Yu, Titus |
Impending Relief
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Waiting |
|
|
McCarver
|
Delaying |
十翼 Shi Yi |
須 Xu1, Necessity,
Essentials, To Wait
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
05.M, Key Words
Waiting, awaiting, readying, earliness, suspense,
calculated inaction, patience
Gratification deferred involuntarily,
satisfaction postponed, delays, deprivation
Presence of mind, window of opportunity, being
properly ready, providing for
Nourishment, necessities, essentials, prospects,
hunger and thirst, prerequisites
Doing without, biding time, working on worthiness,
maximizing the meanwhile
Making the most of emptiness & want; getting
ready, invocation; looking out for
05.G, From the
Glossary
Xu1 (to be)
essential, needful, necessary, insufficient,
tantalized, suspended; (a,
the) anticipation,
suspense, expectation, desire, demand, need,
duty, obligation,
necessity, requirement,
prerequisite; (to) wait, await, abide, bide
time, postpone,
tarry, stop, defer, do without,
watch for, look out for, need, require (s, ed,
ing);
Shuowen has stopped by rain, waiting it
out instead of waiting for rain; [deferred
gratification]
Notes:
Xu is a Janus word, a word with two seemingly or
partially opposite meanings. The only one that
seems to be in use here means to wait, for rain
or nourishment, with the advice being to make
proper use of the time in getting ready for or
worthy of fulfillment, to optimize or maximize
the meanwhile. The other meaning, to be soaked
by rain, does not seem to have any relevance in
the Zhouyi context. The other Xu, given in the
Ten Wings, is also polysemous in the Yi, with
meanings elsewhere in the text of Beard and
Older Sister.
|
|
06
訟 Sòng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Conflict (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Conflict |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #5 |
Balkin |
Conflict |
Meyer |
Considerations
and Reconsiderations
|
Barrett
|
Arguing
|
Needham |
Strife, Contention
at Law
|
Blofeld
|
Conflict
|
Ni |
Dispute, Litigation
|
Bonnershaw
|
Conflict
|
Palmer |
Contention
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Litigation
|
Pattee |
Conflict |
Chang
|
Lawsuit
|
Peden |
Conflict |
Chu
|
Conflict |
Perrottet |
Conflict |
Chung Wu
|
Litigation
|
Powell |
Conflict |
Clark
|
Conflict
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Friction
|
Cleary |
Contention
|
Reifler |
Conflict |
Coates
|
Divisive Conflict
|
Richmond |
Conflicting
Opposites |
Collins
|
Conflict |
Richter |
A Dispute
|
Crouch
|
Free Speech
|
Riseman |
Conflict |
Damian-Knight
|
Conflict, Deadlock
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Arguing
|
Dening
|
Conflict
|
Rutt |
Dispute
|
Dhiegh
|
Conflict, Litigate,
Go To Law |
Seabrook |
Conflict |
Douglas
|
Strife
|
Secter |
Divisive Conflict,
Dispute |
Feng
|
Lawsuit
|
Shaughnessy |
Lawsuit
|
Fu Youde |
Contention
|
Shchutskii |
Litigation
|
Graeme
|
Conflict
|
Siu |
Strife
|
Hacker
|
Grievance
|
Sneddon |
Conflict |
Hatcher
|
Contention
|
Sorrell |
Conflict,
Dissension, Confrontation |
Heyboer
|
The Gong Speaks
|
Stackhouse |
Dividing Up,
Struggling
|
Hoefler
|
The Conflict |
Stein |
Conflict
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Contention
|
Sterling |
Conflict |
Huang, Kerson
|
The Court
|
Sung |
Contention |
Javary
|
Resolving the
Conflict
|
Toropov |
Conflict |
Jou
|
Lawsuit
|
Walker, Barbara |
Conflict
|
Judge
|
Conflict
|
Wallace |
Contending
|
Karcher
|
Arguing
|
Wei, Henry |
Litigation
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Conflict
|
West |
Conflict
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Contention
|
Whincup |
Grievance
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Fighting, Conflict,
Psychic Struggle
|
Wilhelm |
Conflict |
Kunst |
Dispute
|
Wing |
Conflict |
Legge
|
Contention, Strife
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Dispute
|
Leichtman
|
Disillusionment.
Stress
|
Wu, Yi |
Litigation
|
Liu, Da
|
Conflict |
Wu Wei |
Argument
|
Lynn
|
Contention
|
Wu Weifarer |
Conflict
|
Machovec
|
Challenge, Conflict
|
Young |
Conflict |
Market
|
Avoiding Conflict
|
Yu, Titus |
Arbitration
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Conflict
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Conflict |
十翼 Shi Yi |
違行 Wei2 Xing2,
Contradictory Motion
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
06.M, Key Words
Advocacy, adversarialism, partiality,
partisanship, taking or promoting one side
Presumption, challenge, competition; ambivalence,
approach-approach conflicts
Conflict, disparity, dissent, dissonance, points
of view within the bigger picture
Resistance, friction, strife, grievance,
litigation, dispute, contest, confrontation
Arbitration, diplomacy, (re)conciliation,
reconsideration, mid-course corrections
Revisiting postulates & reference frames,
using feedback, finding metasolutions
06.G, From the
Glossary
Song4 (a,
the) contention, conflict, challenge, dispute,
dissent, litigation, argu-
ment, quarrel,
contest, antagonism; (to) contend, dispute,
challenge, contest, dis
sent, litigate, accuse,
argue, quarrel, reprimand, advocate, speak out
publicly,
bring (suit, a complaint, a
grievance), demand justice, plead before a court
(s, ed,
ing); (to be) quarrelsome, adversarial
Notes:
The biggest problem with the word Conflict for a
Gua Ming is in its seeming implication of
necessary ill-will. It doesn't cover the other
conditions possible here: of jousting, sport,
sporting competition, lively debate, the free
marketplace of ideas, or healthy dialectic.
These all need to be recognized as having
potential positive value. The word Contention is
one of the options broad enough to encompass
this wideer range, or at least that is my
contention.
|
|
07
師 Shī
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Army (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Military |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #37 |
Balkin |
The Army |
Meyer |
Common
Cause
|
Barrett
|
The Army
|
Needham |
Organized Action
|
Blofeld
|
The Army |
Ni |
Military Leadership
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Army
|
Palmer |
The Army |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Army
|
Pattee |
The Army |
Chang
|
Military
|
Peden |
The Army |
Chu
|
Military
Expedition, The Army |
Perrottet |
Army |
Chung Wu
|
The Army
|
Powell |
A Troop of Soldiers
|
Clark
|
Leadership
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Role of Self
|
Cleary |
The Army, An Army |
Reifler |
Soldiers
|
Coates
|
Leadership of
Others
|
Richmond |
Many Forms Within
One √
|
Collins
|
Collective Force
|
Richter |
The Army
|
Crouch
|
The Army
|
Riseman |
The Army |
Damian-Knight
|
The Army,
Challenge, Concentrating Resources |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Legions, Leading
|
Dening
|
The Army
|
Rutt |
Troops
|
Dhiegh
|
The Army, Teacher,
Military Discipline |
Seabrook |
Discipline
|
Douglas
|
The Army |
Secter |
Teamwork,
Coordinating Strategy
|
Feng
|
The Army
|
Shaughnessy |
The Troops
|
Fu Youde |
The Army
|
Shchutskii |
The Army |
Graeme
|
Army, Multitude,
Marshalling our Resources
|
Siu |
The Army |
Hacker
|
An Army |
Sneddon |
Group Action
|
Hatcher
|
The Militia
|
Sorrell |
Honor, Loyalty,
Integration |
Heyboer
|
Legion, Leading
|
Stackhouse |
The Mass of
Humanity
|
Hoefler
|
Gathered Strength
|
Stein |
The Women ?
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Multitude
|
Sterling |
Army
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Army |
Sung |
Multitude, Army
|
Javary
|
Organizing Oneself
|
Toropov |
The Army |
Jou
|
Army
|
Walker, Barbara |
Army, Collective
Force
|
Judge
|
Controlled Threat
|
Wallace |
The Militia
|
Karcher
|
Legions
|
Wei, Henry |
Armed Forces
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Mobilizing the Army
|
West |
The Army
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Army
|
Whincup |
The Army |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Army, Organized
Multitude, Collective Force
|
Wilhelm |
The Army |
Kunst |
Army
|
Wing |
Collective Force
|
Legge
|
The Host, The Army
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
The Multitude, The
Army, The Host |
Leichtman
|
Collective
Unconscious, Gathered Forces
|
Wu, Yi |
The Army
|
Liu, Da
|
The Army |
Wu Wei |
Collective Forces
|
Lynn
|
The Army
|
Wu Weifarer |
Legions
|
Machovec
|
Group Leadership
|
Young |
The Army |
Market
|
Leadership
|
Yu, Titus |
A Troop of Warriors
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Army |
|
|
McCarver
|
Group Action |
十翼 Shi Yi |
眾 Zhong4, The
Multitude
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
07.M, Key Words
Ready reserves, liquidity, solvency, mobile and
fungible assets, resourcefulness
Interdependence, collective force, strength in
numbers, coalition, solidarity, allies
Instruction, discipline, training, regimen;
planning for contingency, preparedness
Hedging, strategic security, expedience; chain of
command based on merit or skill
Guardians, host; multiple uses of resources, the
masses used as reservoir or pool
A defensive army disguised as a people, an ad hoc
army or a grass-roots militia
07.G, From the
Glossary
Shi1 (a,
the) militia, military, reserves, army, armies,
host, hosts, legion(s), troops,
garrison;
general, master, specialist, teacher, tutor,
expert, leader, instructor, director, sage,
assessor, example, (role) model; expertise,
organization, preparedness, readiness;
[liquidity]; all; the people, the multitude,
population; (to) teach, instruct, emulate,
imitate, take as a norm or standard; model or
pattern after another; militarily; unit
of 2500
troops
Note:
It is a little misleading to gloss this as The
Army, especially with its modern connotation of
“standing army.” However, the late 20th century
army (militia) of Switzerland provides a nearly
perfect example of the hidden, liquid and mobile
Reserves described and advocated in this Gua.
Their knives also have the corkscrews and
fingernail files, for performing their alternate
duties as regular people and citizens. The
notions of Leader, Teacher, or the role of
experience, also figure importantly in 07's core
meaning, providing the instruction or
instilled/ingrained structures that allow the
masses to change their shape when the need
arises.
|
|
08
比 Bǐ
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Union
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Merging
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #19 |
Balkin |
Union |
Meyer |
Close
Ties
|
Barrett
|
Seeking Union
|
Needham |
Coherence
|
Blofeld
|
Unity, Coordination
|
Ni |
Fellowship (13)
|
Bonnershaw
|
Association
|
Palmer |
Unity
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Alliance
|
Pattee |
Unity
|
Chang
|
Cooperation
|
Peden |
Union
|
Chu
|
Uniting
|
Perrottet |
Holding Together
|
Chung Wu
|
Subservience
|
Powell |
Seeking Unity
|
Clark
|
Grouping
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Contribution
|
Cleary |
Accord
|
Reifler |
Seeking Union
|
Coates
|
A Community Working
Together
|
Richmond |
The Diverse ?
|
Collins
|
Holding Together |
Richter |
Standing Together
(45)
|
Crouch
|
Alliance
|
Riseman |
Union
|
Damian-Knight
|
Holding Together,
Unity Through Leadership |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Grouping
|
Dening
|
Joining the Right
Group
|
Rutt |
Joining
|
Dhiegh
|
Holding Together,
Union, To Compare |
Seabrook |
Common Interest
|
Douglas
|
Unity
|
Secter |
Uniting, Leadership
(07), Direction
|
Feng
|
Harmony
|
Shaughnessy |
Alliance
|
Fu Youde |
Trust
|
Shchutskii |
Drawing Near (19)
|
Graeme
|
Seeking Union,
Belonging, Becoming One
|
Siu |
Leadership (07)
|
Hacker
|
Alliance
|
Sneddon |
Union
|
Hatcher
|
Belonging
|
Sorrell |
Teamwork,
Agreement, Friendship |
Heyboer
|
Stand By
|
Stackhouse |
Banding Together
(45), Comparing
|
Hoefler
|
Union
|
Stein |
Holding Together
(Union) |
Huang, Alfred
|
Union
|
Sterling |
Union
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Support (45)
|
Sung |
Subaltern [for the
marginalized] Assistance
|
Javary
|
Cohering
|
Toropov |
Union
|
Jou
|
Loyalty
|
Walker, Barbara |
Unity, Joining,
Coordination
|
Judge
|
Solidarity (45)
|
Wallace |
Union
|
Karcher
|
Grouping
|
Wei, Henry |
Neighborliness (13)
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Solidarity (45)
|
West |
Association
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Unity
|
Whincup |
Alliance
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Close Association,
Alliance (45), Unity
|
Wilhelm |
Holding Together
(Union)
|
Kunst |
Ally With, Pair
|
Wing |
Unity
|
Legge
|
Union, Attachment
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Union, To Follow
(17), To Associate
|
Leichtman
|
A New View,
Wholeness
|
Wu, Yi |
Assistance
|
Liu, Da
|
Union
|
Wu Wei |
Joining,
Supporting, Uniting
|
Lynn
|
Closeness
|
Wu Weifarer |
Alliance
|
Machovec
|
Unifying Spirit
|
Young |
Holding Together |
Market
|
Joining Together
|
Yu, Titus |
Emulating
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Union
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Union |
十翼 Shi Yi |
親 Qin1, Relations;
輔 Fu3, Assistance
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
08.M, Key Words
Affiliation, association, alliance, confluence,
congress, concourse, convergence
Assimilation, coherence, cohesion, concord,
commonality; bonding, joining, unity
Affinity, accord, mutuality, merging, sharing,
union, nearness, welcome, kinship
Similarity, relatedness; to be drawn together;
group by type and family, compare
Identification with; organic leadership, forces
of attraction; kind-ness, like-ness
Common ground, origin, interest or cause; mitakuye
oyasin (all of my relations)
08.G, From the
Glossary
Bi3 (to)
accord, belong, combine, go together, join,
affiliate, unite, associate (to,
with); sort,
compare, match, assemble, join, follow, (put,
hold) together, draw an
analogy (s, ed, ing);
(to be) affiliated, paired (with), concordant,
well-disposed;
close, familiar; successive,
comparable, analogous, similar; on behalf of;
(a, the)
union, belonging, affiliation,
association, togetherness, congestion,
commonality
Notes:
Joining together for a purpose or a cause, as
for an alliance, security or support, is much
more consistent with the core meaning of Gua 45
that 08. Both are formed of Water over the
Earth, but more artifice is required, in the
form of dams or embankments, to contain the body
of water than the stream. The Togetherness in
Gua 08 is out of a natural affinity and common
ground. The water here is free-flowing. It is
more about belonging than joining.
|
|
09
小畜 Xiǎo Chù
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Small Restraint
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Shao3 Shu2 Small
Harvest/Reaping
|
Albertson
|
Limiting by the
Weak
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
少菽 #58, Small
Harvest
|
Balkin |
Small Accumulation
|
Meyer |
A
Bit Held Back
|
Barrett
|
Small Taming
|
Needham |
Lesser Inhibition,
Taming
|
Blofeld
|
The Lesser
Nourisher
|
Ni |
Small Accumulation
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Little
Cultivator
|
Palmer |
Holding Back the
Less Able
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Building Up
Influence
|
Pattee |
Force of the Small
|
Chang
|
Open-Mindedness
|
Peden |
The Nurture of the
Small
|
Chu
|
Small Power
|
Perrottet |
Domination by
Weakness
|
Chung Wu
|
Restraint of the
Small
|
Powell |
The Power of the
Weak
|
Clark
|
Small Gathering
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Focus
|
Cleary |
Small Obstruction,
Nurturance of the Small
|
Reifler |
Minor Restraint
|
Coates
|
The Power of the
Modest
|
Richmond |
Using what is Small
|
Collins
|
Power of the Small
|
Richter |
Small Cattle
|
Crouch
|
Farming in the
Small
|
Riseman |
The Restraining
|
Damian-Knight
|
Limited Influence
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Small Accumulating
|
Dening
|
Exercising
Restraint
|
Rutt |
Farming Minor
|
Dhiegh
|
Taming Power of the
Small, Domestic Animals |
Seabrook |
Minor Restraint
|
Douglas
|
Restrained by the
Weak
|
Secter |
Hindrance,
Diversion (44), Distraction (44)
|
Feng
|
Cultivation of the
Small
|
Shaughnessy |
Small Domestic
Animals
|
Fu Youde |
Little Increment
|
Shchutskii |
Rearing of the
Small
|
Graeme
|
Taming Power of the
Small |
Siu |
Restraint by the
Weak
|
Hacker
|
Small Restraint,
Small Accumulation
|
Sneddon |
Taming Force
|
Hatcher
|
Raising Small
Beasts
|
Sorrell |
Interference,
Intuition, Taking Precautions |
Heyboer
|
Tending Small
Livestock
|
Stackhouse |
Small (or Reduced)
Involvement
|
Hoefler
|
The Hindrance
|
Stein |
The Cleansing Wind
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Little Accumulation
|
Sterling |
Taming Power of the
Small |
Huang, Kerson
|
Small Cattle
|
Sung |
Small Restraint
|
Javary
|
Taming through Yin
|
Toropov |
The Restraining
Power of the Small
|
Jou
|
Small Saving
|
Walker, Barbara |
Clouds, Small
Nurture
|
Judge
|
Subtle Restraint
|
Wallace |
Small Husbandry
|
Karcher
|
Small Accumulating
|
Wei, Henry |
Mild Restraint
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Small Tames
|
West |
Mild Restraint
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Taming Power of
the Small |
Whincup |
Small is Tamed
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Retraining &
Taming, Small Developments
|
Wilhelm |
The Taming Power of
the Small
|
Kunst |
Small Domestic
Animal, Keep, Nurture
|
Wing |
Restrained
|
Legge
|
Nourishing
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
A Small Offering,
Raise Cattle
|
Leichtman
|
Limitation (60),
Gentleness (57)
|
Wu, Yi |
The Small
Accumulation
|
Liu, Da
|
Taming the Small
Powers
|
Wu Wei |
Gentle Retraint
|
Lynn
|
Lesser
Domestication
|
Wu Weifarer |
Small Accumulation
|
Machovec
|
Moderation
|
Young |
Minor Accumulation
|
Market
|
Restrained Approach
|
Yu, Titus |
Small Cultivation
of Ch'i
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Restraining
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Minor Restraint |
十翼 Shi Yi |
懿文 Yi4 Wen2
Restraint and Refinement
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
09.M, Key Words
Complexity, complications, attenuation; chaos,
complexity, little things adding up
Micromanagement, diminishing returns, getting
caught up in the details, fussiness
Irritants, nuisances, trifles, worries, cares,
distractions, the back-breaking straws
Attrition, erosion, small demands; wearing forces,
shaping, refining & polishing
Long-term finitude, insignificance, limited
influence, tiny pieces of big puzzles
Subtle persuasion, gradual adaptation and
cumulative changes, fine adjustments
09.G, From the
Glossary
Xiao3
(to be) average, common, diminished,
homogeneous, humble, insignificant,
lesser,
light, little, low(ly, er, est), mean, mediocre,
minor, minute, modest, ordi-
nary, slight,
small(er, est), petty, tiny, trifling, trivial,
unimportant, young(er, est),
minimal; (a, the)
commonness, homogeneity, littleness, meanness,
mediocrity,
pettiness, smallness; commonly,
ordinarily; in detail; some small, of little, a
little;
for a short (time, while); (to)
diminish, minimize, shrink, belittle; does not
imply
bad or wrong, but sometimes inferiority.
Chu4 (to)
take care of, care for, provide for, tend (to),
attend (to), keep, raise,
feed, nurture,
sustain, nourish, rear, bring up, support,
shelter, cherish, train,
manage, cultivate,
retain, restrain, tame, (bring under) control,
herd, domesticate,
raise beasts animals,
brutes; accumulate, store up, gather, hoard,
reserve (s, ed,
ing); (a, the) nurture,
cultivation, culture, domestication, husbandry,
management,
training; domestic animal; raising
... beasts; also pronounced xu4 in verb form, to
raise animals
Notes:
The expression “God is in the detail” is
attributed to Ludwig Mies van der Rohe. Being an
architect, this may have been uttered in a
moment of self-congratulation. The expression
“The Devil is in the details” soon followed. If
we put it to a vote as to who’s really in there,
the Devil gets nine times as many Google hits.
In any event, it's awfully crowded down in those
details. To Micromanage the world is like
herding cats: it will keep you occupied and well
away from more important endeavors,
well-trained, tamed and domesticated. This Gua
is a reminder that there are different scales in
life. The value of the small scale diminishes
when this polishing or refinement is overdone.
|
|
10
履
Lǚ
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Treading Carefully
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Li3, Propriety,
Manners, Courtesy, Respect
|
Albertson
|
Treading |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
禮 #4, Treading
|
Balkin |
Treading |
Meyer |
Foot
Steps
|
Barrett
|
Treading
|
Needham |
Slow Advance (53)
|
Blofeld
|
Treading, Conduct
|
Ni |
Conduct |
Bonnershaw
|
Treading
|
Palmer |
Walking Craefully
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Following (17)
|
Pattee |
Treading |
Chang
|
Courtesy
|
Peden |
Treading
|
Chu
|
Treading, Conduct |
Perrottet |
Stepping
|
Chung Wu
|
Cautious Treading
|
Powell |
Treading Wisely |
Clark
|
Treading
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Behavior of the
Self
|
Cleary |
Treading |
Reifler |
Treading |
Coates
|
Proper Conduct
|
Richmond |
Becoming Real ?
|
Collins
|
Treading |
Richter |
Treading
|
Crouch
|
Step
|
Riseman |
Treading |
Damian-Knight
|
Sincerity, Conduct
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Treading
|
Dening
|
Treading Carefully
|
Rutt |
Stepping
|
Dhiegh
|
Treading, Conduct,
Routinized |
Seabrook |
Taking a Chance
|
Douglas
|
Treading |
Secter |
Audacity,
Impertinence, Boldness (46)
|
Feng
|
Strutting
|
Shaughnessy |
Ritual
|
Fu Youde |
Treading
|
Shchutskii |
Stepping, Offensive
|
Graeme
|
Treading, Proper
Conduct
|
Siu |
Stepping Carefully
|
Hacker
|
Treading |
Sneddon |
Treading Carefully
|
Hatcher
|
Respectful Conduct
|
Sorrell |
Courage, Daredevil,
Taking Risks |
Heyboer
|
The Footprints of
the Ancestors
|
Stackhouse |
Self-Confidence
|
Hoefler
|
Behavior
|
Stein |
Treading Softly
(Correctness)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Fulfillment
|
Sterling |
Treading
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Treading |
Sung |
Stepping Carefully
|
Javary
|
Walking on Thin Ice
(64)
|
Toropov |
Stepping
|
Jou
|
Stepping
|
Walker, Barbara |
Conduct, Treading
Carefully
|
Judge
|
Careful Conduct
|
Wallace |
Treading
|
Karcher
|
Treading
|
Wei, Henry |
Cautious Tread
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Treading Carefully
|
West |
Treading
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Walking Carefully
|
Whincup |
Treading |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Carefully,
Conducting Oneself Skillfully
|
Wilhelm |
Treading (Conduct)
|
Kunst |
Step On, Shoes
|
Wing |
Conduct
|
Legge
|
Treading, Walk
Softly
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Walk, Action
|
Leichtman
|
Balance, Propriety
|
Wu, Yi |
Treading
|
Liu, Da
|
Treading |
Wu Wei |
Walking your Path
|
Lynn
|
Treading
|
Wu Weifarer |
Treading
|
Machovec
|
Tact √
|
Young |
Conduct |
Market
|
Treading with
Caution
|
Yu, Titus |
Treading |
Marshall, Chris
|
Being Cautious
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Treading Carefully
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
禮 Li3, Propriety,
Courtesy, Respect
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
10.M, Key Words
Conduct, deportment, tact, correctness,
concordance; taking steps, actualizing
Treading carefully, circumspect behavior,
action’s meetness, conscientiousness
Audacious steps, challenge, hazarding, strategy,
performance; tests, trials, rites
To carry out, honor; living up to standards;
walking the walk, finding right track
Procedure, protocol; divine guardianship on terms
not your own; reality check
Perform as ‘move through form’; function
properly; testing faith, tempting fate
10.G, From the
Glossary
Lu3 (to)
step, take steps, take a step, tread, walk,
trample (on, upon); perform,
conduct oneself,
carry (on, out), honor, fulfill (s, ed, ing);
(a, the) step, footstep
(s); shoes, sandals;
conduct, behavior, path, track; function,
performance, ceremony; respectful conduct,
heedful conduct
Notes:
Finding the optimum balance between what you
want to do and what the world will allow, you
are, in a sense, what you get away with. At
least we have safety, mortality and extinction
to keep us in check, and at least in this we are
guaranteed one reason to cultivate some respect
in our conduct.
|
|
11
泰 Tài
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Peace (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Peace |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #34 |
Balkin |
Peace |
Meyer |
Safe
and Sound
|
Barrett
|
Flow
|
Needham |
Progression,
Prosperous
|
Blofeld
|
Peace
|
Ni |
Peace, Harmony,
Good Opportunity |
Bonnershaw
|
Peace
|
Palmer |
Benevolence ?
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Smooth Interaction
|
Pattee |
Peace |
Chang
|
Balance
|
Peden |
Peace |
Chu
|
Peace |
Perrottet |
Peace |
Chung Wu
|
Prosperity
|
Powell |
Peace |
Clark
|
Peaceful Flow
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Ideas
|
Cleary |
Tranquility
|
Reifler |
Peace |
Coates
|
A Time of Harmony
|
Richmond |
Harmonious Action
|
Collins
|
Peace |
Richter |
Peace
|
Crouch
|
Heroes (Across the
Water) ?
|
Riseman |
Peace |
Damian-Knight
|
Peace |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Pervading
|
Dening
|
Overall Harmony
|
Rutt |
Great
|
Dhiegh
|
Harmony, Liberal,
Prosperous
|
Seabrook |
Harmony
|
Douglas
|
Peace |
Secter |
Merging, Harmony,
Synergy √
|
Feng
|
Utopia
|
Shaughnessy |
Greatness,
Happiness
|
Fu Youde |
Peace
|
Shchutskii |
Flowering
|
Graeme
|
P., Pervading
Energy, Riding the Great Wave
|
Siu |
Peace |
Hacker
|
Peace, Flowing |
Sneddon |
Peace |
Hatcher
|
Interplay
|
Sorrell |
Peace, Harmony,
Benevolence |
Heyboer
|
Mount Tai
|
Stackhouse |
Rising Above
Adversity
|
Hoefler
|
Prospering
|
Stein |
Peace
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Advance (46)
|
Sterling |
Peace |
Huang, Kerson
|
Peace |
Sung |
Successfulness
|
Javary
|
Flourishing
|
Toropov |
Peace |
Jou
|
Positive
|
Walker, Barbara |
Peace
|
Judge
|
Peace
|
Wallace |
Affluence (55)
|
Karcher
|
Pervading
|
Wei, Henry |
Prosperity
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Prosperity (55)
|
West |
Peace
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Tranquility
|
Whincup |
Flowing
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Peace, Tranquility,
Prospering
|
Wilhelm |
Peace
|
Kunst |
Great
|
Wing |
Prospering
|
Legge
|
Waxing
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Great, Prosperous,
Extensive
|
Leichtman
|
Growth
|
Wu, Yi |
Peace
|
Liu, Da
|
Peace |
Wu Wei |
Peaceful
Prosperity, Harmony
|
Lynn
|
Peace
|
Wu Weifarer |
Peace
|
Machovec
|
Personal
Development
|
Young |
Flowering
|
Market
|
Harmony
|
Yu, Titus |
Intermingling √
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Peace
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Peace |
十翼 Shi Yi |
交 Jiao1,
Interaction, Interrelation
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
11.M, Key Words
Affirmation, prosperity, accessibility,
availability, agreeableness, concert, peace
Reconciling opposites, integrating, conjoining,
synergy, symbiosis, coexistence
Complements, interaction, interpenetration,
interregulation, intercourse, harmony
Interaction, communication, attunement; thriving,
positivity, affirmation, optima
To suffuse, permeate; the resolution of paradox,
broad-mindedness, hybrid vigor
Healthy & productive arrangements;
confirmation, facilitation, accord, interlacing
11.G, From the
Glossary
Tai4 (a,
the) (free) interplay, harmony, peace, facility,
prosperity, happiness,
success, extravagance,
affluence; grandiosity; smooth interaction; (to
be) har-
monizing, prospering, prosperous,
pervading, exalted, honorable, superior,
extravagant, flowering, flourishing, great,
affirming, broad minded, liberal,
extensive,
large, permeating, pervasive, grand, most,
extreme, interactive, safe,
peaceful, tranquil;
the west wind; (to) spread out, suffuse,
interpenetrate, permeate, pervade, communicate
(s, ed, ing); greatly
Note:
Peace doesn't really convey the core meaning of
11, even though this can occur within Tai. The
core meaning is closer to "everything
working together in a greater good, as if this
is how things should be." Peace may be a nice,
positive state, but the word doesn't convey any
sense of the dynamic energy and productive
output of this exuberant interaction of forces.
Synergy would be a better name if it wasn't so
anachronistic.
|
|
12
否 Pǐ
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Stagnation
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Fu4, Wife, Matron,
but Pi3 a.p. Fou3, loan?
|
Albertson
|
Decadence
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
婦 #2, The Wife,
also notes possible loan
|
Balkin |
Standstill |
Meyer |
Complete
Standstill
|
Barrett
|
Blocked
|
Needham |
Stagnation,
Retrogression |
Blofeld
|
Standstill,
Obstruction (N) |
Ni |
Misfortune ?
|
Bonnershaw
|
Stagnation
|
Palmer |
Obstruction
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Obstruction (N)
|
Pattee |
Standstill |
Chang
|
Division
|
Peden |
Stagnation |
Chu
|
Standstill,
Stagnation |
Perrottet |
Stagnation |
Chung Wu
|
Stagnation
|
Powell |
Standstill |
Clark
|
Obstruction
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Caution
|
Cleary |
Obstruction |
Reifler |
Disjunction
|
Coates
|
A Time of
Inactivity
|
Richmond |
Standstill |
Collins
|
Stagnation |
Richter |
Obstruction
|
Crouch
|
Eclipse (36)
|
Riseman |
Disharmony
|
Damian-Knight
|
Standstill,
Stagnation |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Obstruction
|
Dening
|
Stagnation
|
Rutt |
Bad √
|
Dhiegh
|
Standstill,
Decision Making, Choice √ |
Seabrook |
Greed ?
|
Douglas
|
Stagnation |
Secter |
Separation √,
Standstill, Pulling Apart
|
Feng
|
Chaos
|
Shaughnessy |
Negation,
Obstructed
|
Fu Youde |
Obstruction
|
Shchutskii |
Decline
|
Graeme
|
Stagnation,
Obstruction, Divergence (38)
|
Siu |
Clogging,
Stagnation
|
Hacker
|
Standstill |
Sneddon |
Stagnation |
Hatcher
|
Separating
|
Sorrell |
Stopped, Powerless,
Obstructed |
Heyboer
|
To Say No √
|
Stackhouse |
Separate
Inclinations or Tendencies
|
Hoefler
|
The Standstill |
Stein |
Disharmony, Waning
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Hindrance (39)
|
Sterling |
Stagnation |
Huang, Kerson
|
Stagnation |
Sung |
Closing
|
Javary
|
Deteriorating
|
Toropov |
Standing Still
(Stagnation)
|
Jou
|
Negative
|
Walker, Barbara |
Stagnation,
Standstill
|
Judge
|
Stagnation
|
Wallace |
Disjunction
|
Karcher
|
Obstruction
|
Wei, Henry |
Adversity
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Decline
|
West |
Stagnation
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Stagnation
|
Whincup |
Blocked
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Obstruction, Delay,
Impeding Stagnation
|
Wilhelm |
Standstill
(Stagnation)
|
Kunst |
Bad √, Not
|
Wing |
Stagnation |
Legge
|
Waning, Distress
(47)
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Close, To Stop
|
Leichtman
|
Impasee (39),
Resistance
|
Wu, Yi |
Adversity
|
Liu, Da
|
Stagnation |
Wu Wei |
Separation, Decline
|
Lynn
|
Obstruction
|
Wu Weifarer |
Disorder
|
Machovec
|
Frustration √
|
Young |
Standstill |
Market
|
Disharmony
|
Yu, Titus |
Alienation
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Disharmony
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Retrogression |
十翼 Shi Yi |
不交 Bu4 Jiao1, No
Interaction/Interrelation |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
12.M, Key Words
Disjunction, discontinuity, disengagement, pulling
apart, alienation, indifference
Denial, negation, division, schism, pettiness,
aloofness, apathy, numbness, decay
Stagnation, entropy, disorder, decadence,
standstill; to misunderstand, disapprove
Ignorance, small-mindedness, lowest common
denominators, leaders out of touch
Stratification, abstraction, disintegrity,
disarray, dissonance, disharmony, discord
Non-participation, non-cooperation, negating and
the need to negate, wrongness
12.G, From the
Glossary
Bi3 (to be)
inferior, wrong, worthless, decaying, bad,
stagnant, stagnating, disin-
tegrating,
alienated, inappropriate; (to) deny, refuse,
stop, negate, disapprove (of),
separate (from)
(s, ed, ing); on the contrary; not, if not, or
not, not do; (a, the)
standstill, stagnation,
separation, disintegrity, negation, denial,
incoherence; [entropy]; what is not so; not,
wrong; also pronounced fou3: to not be, if not,
if out of
Note:
Obstruction is a poor choice of names in this
context, even without the confusion with Gua 39.
It may be a valid gloss for the word Pǐ (also
pronounced Fǒu) in its broader usage in the
language, but its use here betrays a
misunderstanding of the forces at work in this
Gua. These forces are moving in different
directions, away from each other, not in
opposition or confrontation. The core meaning is
that we have a choice between the superior and
the inferior, an opportunity to exercise our own
good judgment and conscience, and to practice
Selection, the neglected half of the
evolutionary process. Bad is actually a fairly
good name for this Gua, but drawing this does
not mean that things will be bad. It is simply
an opportunity to make a good choice.
|
|
13
同人
Tóng Rén
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Fellowship With Men
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Human Association
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #6 |
Balkin |
Fellowship With
People |
Meyer |
People
Living Together
|
Barrett
|
People in Harmony
|
Needham |
State of
Aggregation (08, 45)
|
Blofeld
|
Like-Minded
Persons, Beloved Friends
|
Ni |
Uniting with People
|
Bonnershaw
|
Fellowship
|
Palmer |
Companions
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Joining Forces
|
Pattee |
Fellowship |
Chang
|
Grouping
|
Peden |
Fellowship |
Chu
|
Fellowship,
Brotherhood |
Perrottet |
Community
|
Chung Wu
|
Fellowship
|
Powell |
Companions
|
Clark
|
Friendship
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Listener
|
Cleary |
Sameness with
People
|
Reifler |
Society
|
Coates
|
A Productive
Association
|
Richmond |
Fulfillment in
Difference
|
Collins
|
Community
|
Richter |
Gathering
|
Crouch
|
Mustering Men
|
Riseman |
Social Fellowship
|
Damian-Knight
|
Fellowship With
Men, Cooperation |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Concording People
|
Dening
|
Cooperating with
Others
|
Rutt |
Mustering (03, 07)
|
Dhiegh
|
Fellowship With
Men, United, Companionate |
Seabrook |
Sharing
|
Douglas
|
Fellowship |
Secter |
Relationship,
Laison, Companionship
|
Feng
|
Together with
People
|
Shaughnessy |
Gathering Men
|
Fu Youde |
Fellowship
|
Shchutskii |
Relatives
|
Graeme
|
Seeking Harmony
|
Siu |
Fellowship |
Hacker
|
Companions
|
Sneddon |
Companionship
|
Hatcher
|
Fellowship With
Others
|
Sorrell |
Companionship,
Sharing, Cooperation |
Heyboer
|
Mankind
|
Stackhouse |
People Who Fit
Together Well
|
Hoefler
|
Togetherness
|
Stein |
Sisterhood
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Seeking Harmony
|
Sterling |
Solidarity with Men
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Gathering (45)
|
Sung |
Companionship
|
Javary
|
Agreeing with All
|
Toropov |
Fellowship
|
Jou
|
Fellowship
|
Walker, Barbara |
Fellowship,
Community, Friends |
Judge
|
Fellowship
|
Wallace |
Fellowship
|
Karcher
|
Concording People
|
Wei, Henry |
Comradeship
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Concord Among
People
|
West |
Fellowship
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Fellowship With
Others |
Whincup |
With Others
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Association of
Friends or Equals
|
Wilhelm |
Fellowship With Men
|
Kunst |
Gather, People
|
Wing |
Community
|
Legge
|
Union of Men,
Brotherhood
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Union of Men
|
Leichtman
|
Integration,
Fellowship |
Wu, Yi |
Uniting (with)
People
|
Liu, Da
|
Fellowship of Men |
Wu Wei |
Mingling
|
Lynn
|
Fellowship
|
Wu Weifarer |
Unity
|
Machovec
|
Friendship
|
Young |
Relatives
|
Market
|
Fellowship |
Yu, Titus |
Companions
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Fellowship |
|
|
McCarver
|
Companionship |
十翼 Shi Yi |
類族 Lei4 Zu2, Class
and Family
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
13.M, Key Words
Society, social organization, human association,
classes of people, community
Extended family, fraternity, agreement, coalition;
crossing cultural boundaries
Ethnocentrism, anthropocentrism & xenophobia;
common purposes & causes
Mutual endorsement and admiration societies,
like-minded people, consensus
Schools of thought, group-think, cultural
diversity, relativity of mores & values
Belief systems, collective associations, mass
follies; symposiums, convergences
13.G, From the
Glossary
Tong2 (to)
agree, assemble, assimilate, affiliate,
associate, belong, come together,
commune,
partake in, conform to, congregate, converge,
concur, gather, harmo-
nize, identify, join,
make uniform, share, unite (s, ed, ing) (in,
with, to); (to be)
alike, all, as one,
colloquial, concordant, conforming, consensual,
equal, identical,
identified, in the company
of, like minded, one, one with, similar, the
same, united,
together with, unanimous,; (a,
the) community, assembly (ies), associates,
asso-
ciation, colleagues (of), agreement,
convergence, fellowship (with), meeting,
joining,
gathering, harmony, identity, oneness,
partners, sameness, unity, union; of the same
...; fellow...; simultaneously, concurrently;
and, with, as well as
Ren2
(a, the) person, people, man, woman, one(s),
other(s), another, human being,
individual (s);
each (one), other persons/people; anybody,
anyone, everybody,
everyone, somebody, someone
(else)(’s); some, those; humanity, humankind,
mankind, society; character, citizen, fellow,
folk; inhabitant, member, occupant,
participant, persona, personality, population,
personnel, staff, role; (in) adulthood;
(of)
maturity; (to be) human, adult, grown, mature;
humanity’s; (a, the) person’s,
people’s,
occupant’s; fellow-; -body, -man, -person, -ist
Notes:
What binds us together here, our consensus or
shared intention, is an important part of the
core meaning of 13, since this is what defines
the line between Us and that Fellowship over
there, across the Great Stream. This is cultural
anthropology then, and has, as its highest goal,
to define the line that surrounds us all, the
search for human nature and its proper
realtionship with the stars that hover so high
above our campfires, to borrow the image from
the Da Xiang.
|
|
14
大有 Dà Yǒu
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Abundance (55)
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Wealth in Profusion
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #50 |
Balkin |
Great Possession |
Meyer |
Major
Holding
|
Barrett
|
Great Possession
|
Needham |
Greater Abundance
|
Blofeld
|
Great Possessions |
Ni |
Great Provides
|
Bonnershaw
|
Wealth
|
Palmer |
Many Possessions |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Great Wealth
|
Pattee |
Great Possessions |
Chang
|
Great Wealth
|
Peden |
Prosperity
|
Chu
|
Great Possessing,
Amassing
|
Perrottet |
Possession of
Great Things
|
Chung Wu
|
Great Wealth
|
Powell |
Abundant
Possessions |
Clark
|
Prosperity
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Power Skills
|
Cleary |
Great Possession |
Reifler |
Wealth
|
Coates
|
Modesty in a High
Position
|
Richmond |
Fulfillment |
Collins
|
Great Wealth |
Richter |
Great Possession
|
Crouch
|
Big Haul
|
Riseman |
Possession in
Abundance
|
Damian-Knight
|
Possession in Great
Measure |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Great Possession
|
Dening
|
Outstanding Good
Fortune
|
Rutt |
Large, There
|
Dhiegh
|
Possession in Great
Measur, Great Having |
Seabrook |
Success
|
Douglas
|
Wealth
|
Secter |
Prosperity,
Responsibility, Managing Assets
|
Feng
|
Great Affluence
|
Shaughnessy |
The Great
Possession
|
Fu Youde |
Great Possession
|
Shchutskii |
Possession of Many
Things
|
Graeme
|
Possession in Great
Measure, Great Harvest |
Siu |
Wealth
|
Hacker
|
Great Possessions |
Sneddon |
Abundance
|
Hatcher
|
Big Domain
|
Sorrell |
Prosperity,
Affluence, Possessions |
Heyboer
|
Great Assets
|
Stackhouse |
Great Possessions
Indeed
|
Hoefler
|
Prosperity
|
Stein |
The Goddess’ Gifts
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Great Harvest
|
Sterling |
Possession in Great
Measure
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Great Harvest |
Sung |
Great Possession
|
Javary
|
Great Power to Make
Real
|
Toropov |
Possessing Plenty
|
Jou
|
Great Possession
|
Walker, Barbara |
Wealth, Great
Possessions
|
Judge
|
Wealth
|
Wallace |
Great Possession
|
Karcher
|
Great Possessions,
Great Possessing
|
Wei, Henry |
Great Wealth
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Great Power of
Achievement
|
West |
Wealth
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Abundance (55)
|
Whincup |
Great Wealth |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Great Possessions |
Wilhelm |
Possession in Great
Measure |
Kunst |
Big Have
|
Wing |
Sovereignty √
|
Legge
|
Great Havings
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Great Possessions |
Leichtman
|
Good Fortune,
Abundance
|
Wu, Yi |
Great Possession
|
Liu, Da
|
Great Possessions |
Wu Wei |
Great Wealth
|
Lynn
|
Great Holdings
|
Wu Weifarer |
Great Gifts
|
Machovec
|
Real Wealth √
|
Young |
Great Possession |
Market
|
Prosperity and
Abundance
|
Yu, Titus |
Great Possession |
Marshall, Chris
|
Plenty of Time
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Great Possession |
十翼 Shi Yi |
歸焉 Gui1 Yan2,
Belonging Here
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
14.M, Key Words
Possession of greatness, wealth, endowments,
enrichment, abundance, affluence
Assets, dominion, domain as the home, belonging
here, tenure; laying of claims
Vantage, command, territory, (spheres of)
influence; enterprise, venture, credit
Value, interest, appreciation, treasuring, worth,
gratitude, counting of blessings
Wealth of experience; owning one’s power to
assign, rearrange and revise values
Prometheus (foresight), gave fire from heaven to
man; entitlement, appropriation
14.G, From the
Glossary
Da4
(to be) accomplished, best, better, big,
complete, critical, crucial, developed,
enormous, entire, extreme, far, full, fully
grown, good, grand, great(er, est), hea-
vy,
high, large(r), (very, greatly) important, long,
loud, major, mature, mighty,
more, most, noble,
noteworthy, old, overall, (more, most) perfect,
pure, realized,
ripe, seasoned, serious,
significant, strong, successful, vast, whole,
wholesome,
vital; a lot of, full of, lots of;
master-, (a, the) completeness, (full)
development,
entirety, grand(eur, ness),
greatness, growth, (great) importance, largesse,
ma-
jority, maturity, vastness, wholeness; a
great deal, (very) much, very; already,
completely, entirely, fully, greatly,
thoroughly, wholly, en masse, well-; of (great,
crucial, vital) importance
You3
(to) be, (in) being; (there, one, it, this,
they, those) is, am, are, was, were,
being,
has, have, had, has/have been, will be, come(s)
to be; (there is) one, some-
one, something;
exist, remain, stay (s); become, arise, appear,
grow, attain to,
learn to be, turn into;
(there) will, would, could, may, might, can
(be); (this) will
get; (if there) is, are, was,
were; (were) there, one, it, they; have, (in)
having; (one,
that, they) has, have, had; has
one’s, have their; had (one’s, their); contain,
hold
(onto), keep, maintain, own, retain,
possess, stay; presume, assume, remember,
take
... for granted; will have, (one they) (will,
could, might, may) have; bring (up,
about);
get, achieve, acquire, attain, capture, claim,
earn, find, gain, learn, take on;
seize, take,
took (possession of) (s, ed, ing); (to be)
present, there; in possession of,
possessed of,
with; contained, held; abundant, rich,
plentiful; (a, the) attainment,
claim,
possession (of); being, existence, presence;
domain, dominion (in, over);
what exists/is
there; the, this, this one, the one in question;
something; anybody,
somebody, someone (’s);
given this/that, this (being) given; of, about,
with, for;
His (especially of the sovereign),
his, her, its, their; will, would ... with, to,
for;
-ing, -ous
Note:
In the Shi Yi section, Gui1 Yan2, Belonging
Here, is from the Xu Gua. The word Domain in my
own Gua Ming translation comes from the Latin
Domus, home. A Domine was the lord of a
household manor, and by analogy, became a name
for the Western deity. Dominion, then, is to lay
claim to a domain, to own it, to make oneself at
home in this part of the world. And, as with
owning up to something, it implies a sense of
taking responsibility. A deed or title may not
be necessary to one who has control over what
owning and valuing really mean in the end. Great
Possessing, then might be a better name than
Great Possessions.
|
|
15
謙 Qiān
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Humility (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Qian1, Deficient,
Unworthy, Lowly
|
Albertson
|
Humility |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
嗛 #35, Modesty
|
Balkin |
Modesty (N) |
Meyer |
Modest
Approach
|
Barrett
|
Integrity
|
Needham |
Highness in Lowness
|
Blofeld
|
Modesty
|
Ni |
Modesty,
Egolessness |
Bonnershaw
|
Modesty
|
Palmer |
Modesty |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Modesty
|
Pattee |
Modesty |
Chang
|
Humility
|
Peden |
Humility
|
Chu
|
Modesty |
Perrottet |
Modesty
|
Chung Wu
|
Humility
|
Powell |
Humility
|
Clark
|
Humility
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Extremes
|
Cleary |
Humility
|
Reifler |
Modesty |
Coates
|
Modesty in a
Superior Man
|
Richmond |
Adapting to the
Flow
|
Collins
|
Modesty |
Richter |
Modesty
|
Crouch
|
Modesty (Hamster)
|
Riseman |
Modesty |
Damian-Knight
|
Modesty |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Humbling, Holding
Back
|
Dening
|
Modesty
|
Rutt |
Rat
|
Dhiegh
|
Respectful, Humble,
Retiring, Modesty |
Seabrook |
Modesty
|
Douglas
|
Modesty |
Secter |
Humility, Modesty,
Selfless Action |
Feng
|
Humility
|
Shaughnessy |
Unsatisfied
|
Fu Youde |
Modesty
|
Shchutskii |
Humility
|
Graeme
|
Modesty,
Humbleness, Authenticity
|
Siu |
Modesty |
Hacker
|
Modesty |
Sneddon |
Modesty |
Hatcher
|
Authenticity
|
Sorrell |
Humility, Modesty,
Gentleness |
Heyboer
|
Give and Take
|
Stackhouse |
Holding One's
Words, Without Prejudice
|
Hoefler
|
Moderation
|
Stein |
Temperance
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Humbleness
|
Sterling |
Modest
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Modesty |
Sung |
Humility
|
Javary
|
Restraining Oneself
|
Toropov |
Humility
|
Jou
|
Modesty
|
Walker, Barbara |
Modesty, Moderation
|
Judge
|
Unpretentiousness √
|
Wallace |
Humility
|
Karcher
|
Humbling, Holding
Back
|
Wei, Henry |
Humility
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Restraint
|
West |
Modesty
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Modesty
|
Whincup |
Modesty |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Lack of
Prentiousness and Ostentation √
|
Wilhelm |
Modesty
|
Kunst |
Hamster, Humble
|
Wing |
Moderation
|
Legge
|
Humility, Merit
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Modesty |
Leichtman
|
Being Centered,
Moderation
|
Wu, Yi |
Humility
|
Liu, Da
|
Modesty |
Wu Wei |
Modesty,
Humbleness, Moderation
|
Lynn
|
Modesty
|
Wu Weifarer |
Modesty
|
Machovec
|
Humility
|
Young |
Modesty |
Market
|
The Middle Way
|
Yu, Titus |
The Emptied
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Modesty
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Modesty
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
平施 Ping2 Shi1,
Fair/Just Apportionment
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
15.M, Key Words
Due regard, respectfulness, to honor others
according their merit; ordinary reality
Genuine, unpretentious, unassuming, modest,
accurate, realistic, honest, authentic
Consistent, inexcessive; basis in fact, surety,
solidity, firmness, stability, sobriety
Curtailing the superfluous, parsimony;
thoroughness, realism; rocks in the rough
On solid foundations; exacting appreciation,
accurate assessment, groundedness
Simplicity, nothing extra or extraneous,
restraint, limiting to the most stable form
15.G, From the
Glossary
Qian1 (a,
the) authenticity, respectfulness, respect,
modesty; (to be) unassuming,
authentic,
respectful, yielding, deferent, reverent,
humble, modest; deficient
Note:
Modesty is a little weak here as the Gua Ming,
even though, ironically, this is the best
translation of the word Qian as used in several
of the lines. Several of the lines describe what
is wrong with our conventional understanding of
modesty, especially the disingenuous
self-effacement. This understanding is confirmed
by the Mawangdui Gua Ming, also Qian, which
toadies and sycophants would use to describe
themselves as Unworthy. Humility is weaker
still, this coming much closer to the subject of
62. Honesty would be a better gloss for the core
meaning of the Gua, and "tell it like it is" or
"call a spade a spade" a better description. In
the Da Xiang many translators drift towards
saying the objective is to make things equal, to
level things out. This is incorrect. The
objective is to know them for what they are, to
give a fair assessment. There is in this Gua a
little bit of holding back or conservative
reluctance to go too far in assessing things.
Note that the unbroken line is back of center,
suggesting reticence. See the notes at Gua 16
for contrast, where the unbroken line is ahead
of center, suggesting readiness.
|
|
16
豫
Yù
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Harmony
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Yu2, 1st Person;
Yu2, Surplus, Overflow
|
Albertson
|
Enthusiasm
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
余 #27, Excess
|
Balkin |
Enthusiasm |
Meyer |
Getting
Things Ready
|
Barrett
|
Enthusiasm
|
Needham |
Inspiration
|
Blofeld
|
Repose
|
Ni |
Comfort
|
Bonnershaw
|
Complacency
|
Palmer |
Enthusiasm |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Joyous (58)
|
Pattee |
Enthusiasm |
Chang
|
Entertainment
|
Peden |
Enthusiasm |
Chu
|
Broadcasting
|
Perrottet |
Enthusiasm |
Chung Wu
|
Merriment
|
Powell |
Anticipation (5)
|
Clark
|
Preparing
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Skills
|
Cleary |
Joy, Happiness
|
Reifler |
Enthusiasm |
Coates
|
An Enthusiastic
Following
|
Richmond |
In Rest
|
Collins
|
Weariness (47)
|
Richter |
Happiness
|
Crouch
|
Enthusiasm
(Elephant)
|
Riseman |
Enthusiasm |
Damian-Knight
|
Enthusiasm |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Providing For,
Responsibility
|
Dening
|
Thinking Ahead
|
Rutt |
Elephant
|
Dhiegh
|
Enthusiasm |
Seabrook |
Enthusiasm |
Douglas
|
Calm Confidence
|
Secter |
Inspiration,
Confidence, Enthusiasm |
Feng
|
Flowing, Singing
|
Shaughnessy |
Comfort
|
Fu Youde |
Enjoyment
|
Shchutskii |
Freedom
|
Graeme
|
Delight,
Enthusiasm, Being Ready
|
Siu |
Contentment |
Hacker
|
Contentment
|
Sneddon |
Harmony
|
Hatcher
|
Readiness
|
Sorrell |
Motivation,
Inspiration, Encouragement |
Heyboer
|
Weaving Images
|
Stackhouse |
Eager to Get Going,
Ready to Go
|
Hoefler
|
Enthusiasm |
Stein |
Enthusiasm,
Willingness
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Delight
|
Sterling |
Enthusiasm |
Huang, Kerson
|
Weariness (47)
|
Sung |
Harmonious Joy
|
Javary
|
Burning Oneself Out
|
Toropov |
Enthusiasm |
Jou
|
Joy
|
Walker, Barbara |
Repose, Harmony
|
Judge
|
Enthusiasm
|
Wallace |
Pride ?
|
Karcher
|
Providing For,
Responding
|
Wei, Henry |
Satisfaction
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Joyful Enthusiasm
|
West |
Enthusiasm |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Enthusiasm |
Whincup |
Contentment
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Joyful Enthusiasm,
Confident Repose
|
Wilhelm |
Enthusiasm |
Kunst |
Elephant
|
Wing |
Harmonize
|
Legge
|
Pleasure, Harmony,
Satisfaction
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Easy Movement,
Pleasure
|
Leichtman
|
Divine Order,
Evocation
|
Wu, Yi |
Enjoyment
|
Liu, Da
|
Happiness
|
Wu Wei |
Enthusiasm, Revelry
|
Lynn
|
Contentment
|
Wu Weifarer |
Enthusiasm
|
Machovec
|
Happiness
|
Young |
Enjoyment
|
Market
|
Enjoyment
|
Yu, Titus |
Elephant Dance
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Enthusiasm
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Harmonious Joy |
十翼 Shi Yi |
順動 Shun4 Dong4,
Responsive Movement |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
16.M, Key Words
Enthusiasm, eagerness, exuberance, willingness,
zest, the joyful noise, inspiration
Spontaneity, attunement, rhythms, consonance,
synchrony; an optimum readiness
Acting in a timely fashion; responsive movement;
prepare, provide for, allow for
Forwardness, predisposition, inclination,
initiative, earnestness, encouragement
Confidence, preparedness, contentment,
satisfaction; using momentum and inertia
Complacent, smug, self-indulgent; enthusiasm as
Theos within, needing an outlet
16.G, From the
Glossary
Yu4 (to)
prepare, provide, allow, (get, make) ready,
prearrange, anticipate, pre-
sume, make
allowance(s), take precaution(s) (for); think
beforehand; be happy, be
content, rejoice (s,
ed, ing); (a, the) preparation, preparedness,
readiness, antici-
pation; willingness,
cheerfulness, enthusiasm, contentment;
complacency, smug-
ness, indulgence,
swinishness, surplus, surfeit; responsive
action, easy movement;
excursions back and
forth; (to be) prepared (for), ready (for);
alerted, cautious,
careful; willing, content
(to); comfortable, satisfied, at ease, happy
(with); docile;
idle, remiss; preliminary,
provisional; already, previously, beforehand;
elephant-
like, slow, heavy, ponderous,
deliberate, inertial; in advance, in preparation
Notes:
There is a confusing ambivalence in the way Yu
is translated, in a range from a thrilled
enthusiasm to a weary or even smug complacency.
Between these is a Readiness or a Preparedness
to go either way, along with the flow. Maybe the
key here is in the Tuan Zhuan's gloss of Shun
Dong, Responsive Movement, which also handily
accounts for the reference to music in the Da
Xiang text. The unbroken line in the image leans
just forward of center, perhaps indicating a
slight predilection for forward motion, given
the right excuse, just as 15's line holds itself
slightly back in a more conservative position.
|
|
17
隨 Suí
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Following |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text
|
Albertson
|
Adjusting
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #47 |
Balkin |
Following |
Meyer |
Getting
Along With
|
Barrett
|
Following
|
Needham |
Succession
|
Blofeld
|
Following,
According With |
Ni |
Compliance,
Following |
Bonnershaw
|
Following
|
Palmer |
According or
Agreeing With
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Alignment
|
Pattee |
Following |
Chang
|
Following
|
Peden |
Following |
Chu
|
Following |
Perrottet |
Handing Over
|
Chung Wu
|
Following |
Powell |
Allegiance
|
Clark
|
Following
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Opinions
|
Cleary |
Following |
Reifler |
Following |
Coates
|
Encouraging
Followers
|
Richmond |
Becoming, New Form
|
Collins
|
Following |
Richter |
Following
|
Crouch
|
Pursuing
|
Riseman |
Following |
Damian-Knight
|
Following,
Adaptation to the Times |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Following
|
Dening
|
Being Adaptable
|
Rutt |
Pursuit
|
Dhiegh
|
Acquiring
Followers, To Accompany, Accord
|
Seabrook |
Following |
Douglas
|
Following |
Secter |
Following,
Pursuing, Accompanying |
Feng
|
Following, Tracking
|
Shaughnessy |
Following
|
Fu Youde |
Following
|
Shchutskii |
Succession
|
Graeme
|
Following, The
Quest
|
Siu |
Acquiring Followers
|
Hacker
|
The Chase
|
Sneddon |
Following |
Hatcher
|
Following
|
Sorrell |
Pursuit, Ambition,
The Chase |
Heyboer
|
Follow without
Resistance
|
Stackhouse |
Following the Ways,
Participating
|
Hoefler
|
The Succession
|
Stein |
Following |
Huang, Alfred
|
Following
|
Sterling |
Following |
Huang, Kerson
|
The Chase
|
Sung |
Following
|
Javary
|
Following
|
Toropov |
Following |
Jou
|
Following
|
Walker, Barbara |
Following,
Adaptation, Accord
|
Judge
|
Following
|
Wallace |
Following
|
Karcher
|
Following |
Wei, Henry |
Following |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Following
|
West |
Following
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Following |
Whincup |
The Hunt
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Willing to Folllow,
Adaptability
|
Wilhelm |
Following |
Kunst |
Pursue, Pursuit,
Marrow
|
Wing |
Adapting
|
Legge
|
Following
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Following, Follow |
Leichtman
|
Accepting (2),
Adaptability
|
Wu, Yi |
Following
|
Liu, Da
|
Following |
Wu Wei |
Leading and
Following
|
Lynn
|
Following
|
Wu Weifarer |
Following
|
Machovec
|
Associating with
Others (13)
|
Young |
Following |
Market
|
Following |
Yu, Titus |
Following |
Marshall, Chris
|
Following |
|
|
McCarver
|
Following |
十翼 Shi Yi |
隨時 Sui2 Shi2,
Following the Time/Season
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
17.M, Key Words
Quest, search, pursuit, seeking; incentives,
attraction, allure, affinity, tugging, bait
Draw, pull, persuasion, compliance; consequent,
consequence; adapting as fitness
To go along with, find the rhythm of, taking a
pulse; follow up & follow through
Allegiances, loyalties; subordinating, adherence,
obedience, consent, submission
Guidance, orientation; succeeding, succession;
magnetic center, ethical compass
Opportunism in taking guidance, advice &
direction; follow as tracking & hunting
17.G, From the
Glossary
Sui2 (to)
follow (up, through); succeed, trail, go along,
fall in with, wait on, com-
ply, accord, let,
allow, adopt, adapt, conform, respond (in, with,
to); lag behind,
accompany, imitate, look like,
resemble, carry out, pursue, chase, go after,
come
after (s, ed, ing); (to be) followed by,
successive, succeeding, consecutive,
sub-
sequent; pursued, chased; (a, the)
consequence, succession, pursuit, company,
success, response; obsequiousness;
subsequently, afterward(s), next, then, at once,
presently, instantly, forthwith, right behind,
in due course, in the course of time,
accordingly, according to
Note:
Without question, Following is the perfect Gua
Ming here, but this only leaves us the task of
unfolding it like a Chinese word and exposing
its many dimensions to cover the proper
territory of this Gua. Following should carry a
broad set of connotations that include active,
even aggressive, modes of following, such as
tracking, hunting and pursuit. You can follow
your gut or follow a hunch. It is not just doing
what your deity's minister tells you what the
deity tells you to do. To follow properly is to
Succeed. It is not merely Following passively
along: there is Thunder in the Lake here, and
the movement is driven by a sensible pulse. The
pulse occurs in time, like a drum beat, and
''following in time' is brought up in the Tuan
Zhuan and described in the Da Xiang. Finally,
the Nuremberg defense of "I was only following
orders" is suggested in 17.6, where it follows
that there are consequences to being someone
else's consequence.
|
|
18
蠱
Gǔ
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Arresting Decay
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Ge4, Identity,
Individuality, Personality, Ego
|
Albertson
|
Removing Decay
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
箇 #16, Branch
|
Balkin |
Remedying |
Meyer |
Festering
Mess √
|
Barrett
|
Corruption
|
Needham |
Corruption
|
Blofeld
|
Decay
|
Ni |
Correcting the
Corruption |
Bonnershaw
|
Decay
|
Palmer |
Decay
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
[The Parents]
Enterprise
|
Pattee |
Work on Decay
|
Chang
|
Prevention
|
Peden |
Repair
|
Chu
|
Decay, Correcting
|
Perrottet |
Renewal
|
Chung Wu
|
Misdeeds
|
Powell |
Arresting Decay
|
Clark
|
Error
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Correction
|
Cleary |
Degeneration,
Disruption
|
Reifler |
Fixing
|
Coates
|
Eliminating
Stagnation and Decay
|
Richmond |
Decay
|
Collins
|
Repair the Broken
|
Richter |
Corruption
|
Crouch
|
Curse of the
Fathers
|
Riseman |
Reparation of the
Spoiled
|
Damian-Knight
|
Work on What Has
Been Spoiled |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Corruption,
Rennovating
|
Dening
|
Dealing with Decay
|
Rutt |
Mildew
|
Dhiegh
|
Work on ...
Spoiled, Poison, Decay |
Seabrook |
Repair
|
Douglas
|
Decay
|
Secter |
Repair, Correcting,
Restoring
|
Feng
|
Decay
|
Shaughnessy |
Disorder
|
Fu Youde |
Decay
|
Shchutskii |
Correction
|
Graeme
|
Decay, Poison,
Renovation, Work...Spoiled
|
Siu |
Arresting of Decay
|
Hacker
|
Illness, Decay
|
Sneddon |
Arresting Decay |
Hatcher
|
Detoxifying
|
Sorrell |
Decay, Repair,
Responsibility |
Heyboer
|
Can o' Worms
|
Stackhouse |
Inner Turmoil from
Disease, Bad Ideas
|
Hoefler
|
The Restoration
|
Stein |
Decay
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Remedying
|
Sterling |
Working on What is
Corrupted
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Work
|
Sung |
Destruction
|
Javary
|
Repairing
|
Toropov |
Work on what has
Fallen into Disorder/Decay
|
Jou
|
Decay
|
Walker, Barbara |
Decay
|
Judge
|
Remedial Action
|
Wallace |
Degeneracy
|
Karcher
|
Corruption,
Renovating
|
Wei, Henry |
Deterioration
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Restoring what has
Deteriorated
|
West |
Decay
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Decay
|
Whincup |
Illness
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Facing
Disintegration or Decline, Disrepair
|
Wilhelm |
Work on What Has
Been Spoiled (Decay)
|
Kunst |
Pestilence, Poison
|
Wing |
Repair
|
Legge
|
Having
Painful/Troublesome Services to Do
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Poison, Destruction
|
Leichtman
|
Reform, Mending
|
Wu, Yi |
Work on Decay
|
Liu, Da
|
Work after Spoiling
|
Wu Wei |
Correcting
Deficiencies
|
Lynn
|
Ills to be Cured
|
Wu Weifarer |
Coping
|
Machovec
|
Overcoming
Backwardness
|
Young |
Fixing
|
Market
|
Revising Obsolete
Patterns
|
Yu, Titus |
A Can of Worms
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Repairing Decay
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Decaying |
十翼 Shi Yi |
治 Zhi4 Healing,
Curing, Setting Right
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
18.M, Key Words
Fixations, toxic ideas, dogma, pathologies, bad
medicine, ego, poison, venom, rot
Degeneration, deterioration, decay, suffocation,
spoilage, corruption, resentment
Righting wrongs, antidotes, reparation,
restoration, renewal, fresh air; clear the air
Revitalization, rejuvenation, redemption, stirring
it up; purging, cleansing, curing
Poor circulation, constipation, necrosis, atrophy,
stuffiness, festering, decadence
Stirring up, remedial action, corrective measures,
flushing out the system, reform
18.G, From the
Glossary
Gu3 (a, the)
corruption, decay, decadence, rot, putrefaction,
worms (in food or the
belly), toxicity, poison,
pestilence; bad medicine, bad magic, slow
poison, venom;
fixation (s), stagnation,
deception, guile, delusion, insanity; (glossed
in guwen as
chong M1519: worms, insects,
reptiles); (a, the) renewal, healing, curing,
purging,
detoxifying; [neurosis, toxic ideas, a
closed mind] ; (to be) fixated, degenerating,
deteriorating, decaying. This is a janus word,
meaning both to be poisoned and to
cure from
poison.
Notes:
Fixing or Arresting Decay is a little peculiar
here since the problems have come from things
being fixed, arrested, stuck or stagnant in
pathological patterns and thus decaying for the
lack of refreshing movement and vitality.
Correction, then, involves putting things back
in motion. Gu is a Janus word in this context,
meaning both toxins and the recovery from
toxins. Historically, Gu was a dark magic
poison: one put a venomous snake, a scorpion, a
spider, a lizard and a centipede together in a
bowl. Then the remains of the last survivor were
used to make a slave, cause insanity or work
evil (young boys make this kind of concoction
all the time, though actual creatures used may
vary). This is Bad Medicine: not fresh, not
alive and not changing. The idea of correcting
injurious fixations in one's own lineage may
have been sensitive at the time in the light of
traditions of filial piety and reverence for the
ancestors. The Zhouyi authors might have been
taking an opportunity to broaden the spirit of
this tradition by calling it a form of respect
to improve one's lineage and in the process
become better ancestors ourselves.
|
|
19
臨
Lín
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Approach
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Lin2, Woods,
Forest(er), Manager of a Group
|
Albertson
|
Drawing Near
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
林 #36, The Forest
|
Balkin |
Overseeing |
Meyer |
On
the Verge Of
|
Barrett
|
Nearing
|
Needham |
Approach of
Authority |
Blofeld
|
Approach |
Ni |
Advancing
|
Bonnershaw
|
Approach
|
Palmer |
To Draw Near
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Approaches to
Ruling
|
Pattee |
Approach |
Chang
|
Governing
|
Peden |
Approach |
Chu
|
Approach |
Perrottet |
Approach |
Chung Wu
|
Condescension
|
Powell |
Approaching |
Clark
|
Approaching
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Wanting
|
Cleary |
Overseeing
|
Reifler |
Conduct (10)
|
Coates
|
A Time of Expansion
and Growth
|
Richmond |
Overgrowth
|
Collins
|
The Approach |
Richter |
Approaching
|
Crouch
|
Wailing
|
Riseman |
Conduct (10)
|
Damian-Knight
|
Advance, Approach,
A Clead Road Ahead |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Nearing
|
Dening
|
Moving Towards Your
Goal
|
Rutt |
Keening
|
Dhiegh
|
Approach,
Provisional, About To |
Seabrook |
The Rise to Power
|
Douglas
|
Getting Ahead
|
Secter |
Opportunity
Approaching, Possibility |
Feng
|
Intimacy
|
Shaughnessy |
To Look Down Upon
|
Fu Youde |
Looking Down
|
Shchutskii |
Visit
|
Graeme
|
Appr. Greatness,
Nearing, Taking Command
|
Siu |
Getting Ahead
|
Hacker
|
Authority
Approaches |
Sneddon |
Approach |
Hatcher
|
Taking Charge
|
Sorrell |
Taking Action,
Encounter, Involvement |
Heyboer
|
Overseeing
|
Stackhouse |
Different Classes
of People
|
Hoefler
|
The Nearing
|
Stein |
Approach
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Approaching
|
Sterling |
Approach
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Prevailing
|
Sung |
Advance and Arrival
|
Javary
|
Approaching
|
Toropov |
Oversight of Action
|
Jou
|
Approach
|
Walker, Barbara |
Approach, Promotion
|
Judge
|
Initiative
|
Wallace |
Approach
|
Karcher
|
Nearing
|
Wei, Henry |
Advent
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Benevolent
Attention
|
West |
Advance
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Overseeing
|
Whincup |
Leadership
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Approaching,
Overseeing, Promotion
|
Wilhelm |
Approach
|
Kunst |
Oversee (Sscrifice)
|
Wing |
Promotion
|
Legge
|
The Approach of
Authority
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Advance
|
Leichtman
|
Self-Realization,
Great Promise
|
Wu, Yi |
Approach
|
Liu, Da
|
Approach |
Wu Wei |
To Arrive, To
Approach |
Lynn
|
Overseeing
|
Wu Weifarer |
Approaching
|
Machovec
|
Moving Ahead
|
Young |
Becoming Great
|
Market
|
Gathering Strength
|
Yu, Titus |
On the Threshold
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Growth
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Approach |
十翼 Shi Yi |
與 Yu3, In Concert,
Collaboration, Assistance
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
19.M, Key Words
To manage, preside, conduct, oversee, supervise,
allocate, deploy; due diligence
Commitment, approach, engagement, assuming
command, taking responsibility
Accession, rising to the occasion, getting
involved, going to work, undertaking
Groundwork, prospect-us, preparation; ripe timing,
moment at hand, imminence
Warming up, intending to do, mapping out things to
be done; rolling up sleeves
Step up, gear up, tool up; implement, getting
into position; on threshold, about to
19.G, From the
Glossary
Lin2 (a,
the) management, undertaking, oversight,
responsibility, supervision,
commitment,
accession, prospect, project, prospectus;
exalted approach; (to)
supervise, oversee,
manage, take command, take charge, commit
(oneself), arrive,
near, approach, go to, be
about to, view from above, look down on, look in
on,
inspect, condescend to, favor (s, ed, ing);
(to be) temporary, provisional, ad hoc,
near
to, about to, on the brink of, imminent, at
hand; [rolling up sleeves, getting
down and
dirty]
Notes:
The core meaning of Lin derives from its
assocaition to the 12th Month of the year, the
month of getting ready to really get
ready to begin working on this new year's
harvest, now a mere "eight months" away. But you
don't work on it by counting the 8th Month's
harvest so far ahead of time. It is untimely to
step back and admire your work now. Fast
Approaching is the busiest season in an
agricultural community. It is Nearing the time
to roll up the sleeves and get dirty. If you are
not in motion yet then you are laying out plans
of attack, hiring workers, clearing the
irrigation ditches (see the Gua Xiang as a
furrow in the Earth) and readying the equipment,
hence the references to leadership and
management skills, and glosses of overseing and
oversight. Some people who draw this aren't
farmers, but some kind of Accession, stepping up
into a position of greater work or
responsiblility, is indicated.
|
|
20
觀
Guān
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Contemplation |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Contemplation |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #59 |
Balkin |
Viewing |
Meyer |
Looking
Things Over
|
Barrett
|
Seeing
|
Needham |
View, Vision
|
Blofeld
|
Looking Down
|
Ni |
Contemplation,
Point of View |
Bonnershaw
|
Viewing
|
Palmer |
Examine
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Observation
|
Pattee |
Contemplation |
Chang
|
Inspection and
Introspection
|
Peden |
Contemplation |
Chu
|
Contemplation |
Perrottet |
Contemplation |
Chung Wu
|
Admiration
|
Powell |
Contemplation |
Clark
|
Contemplation
|
Ra Uru Hu |
The Now
|
Cleary |
Observing,
Observation
|
Reifler |
Contemplation |
Coates
|
Contemplation of
the Meaning of Life
|
Richmond |
Wholeness ?
|
Collins
|
Contemplation |
Richter |
Viewing
|
Crouch
|
Observance
|
Riseman |
View
|
Damian-Knight
|
A Panoramic View,
Planning, Projecting
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Viewing
|
Dening
|
Taking an Overview
|
Rutt |
Observing
|
Dhiegh
|
Contemplation,
View, Examine |
Seabrook |
Concentration
|
Douglas
|
Contemplation |
Secter |
Composure,
Awareness, Contemplation |
Feng
|
Observing
|
Shaughnessy |
Looking Up
|
Fu Youde |
Observing
|
Shchutskii |
Contemplation |
Graeme
|
Discerning Meaning,
Gaining Perspective
|
Siu |
Contemplation |
Hacker
|
Observing
|
Sneddon |
Contemplation |
Hatcher
|
Perspective
|
Sorrell |
Contemplation,
Perspective, Observation |
Heyboer
|
The Heron
|
Stackhouse |
Looking, Seeing,
Showing
|
Hoefler
|
Observation
|
Stein |
Contemplation
(Example)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Watching
|
Sterling |
Contemplation
|
Huang, Kerson
|
View
|
Sung |
Steady Observation
|
Javary
|
Seeing the Truth
|
Toropov |
Contemplating
|
Jou
|
Observation
|
Walker, Barbara |
Contemplation
|
Judge
|
Recognition
|
Wallace |
Observing
|
Karcher
|
Viewing
|
Wei, Henry |
Contemplation |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Contemplation
|
West |
Contemplation
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Observing
|
Whincup |
Watching
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Observing or
Contemplating
|
Wilhelm |
Contemplation
(View)
|
Kunst |
Observe
|
Wing |
Contemplating
|
Legge
|
Manifesting and
Contemplating
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Observe
|
Leichtman
|
Inner Patterns,
Reading the Signs
|
Wu, Yi |
Contemplation
|
Liu, Da
|
Observation
|
Wu Wei |
Seeing Yourself
Inwardly ?
|
Lynn
|
Viewing
|
Wu Weifarer |
Contemplation
|
Machovec
|
Perception
|
Young |
Contemplation |
Market
|
Deep Understanding
|
Yu, Titus |
Bird's Eye View
|
Marshall, Chris
|
View
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Observation |
十翼 Shi Yi |
省 Xing3, Studying,
Examining, Inspecting
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
20.M, Key Words
Observe, view, attend, study, contemplate,
consider, examine; the examined life
Investigation, reconnaissance, review, survey,
learning, comprehension, compass
(Changing) points of view, frames of mind,
postulates, hypotheses, outlooks, ken
Frames of reference, reframing; universes of
discourse; suspending a (dis-)belief
Overview, taking inventory, overall view,
objectivity(-ification); reading the signs
Understanding other perspectives, a point of view
of being beheld or objectified
20.G, From the
Glossary
Guan1 (to)
attend, behold, comprehend, consider,
contemplate, divine, evaluate,
examine, gaze
(at, upon), gaze with concentration, look
(at/for/to), observe, per-
ceive, see, study,
view, watch, scry, regard (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
comprehension,
observation, perception,
perspective, prospect, scenery, sight, view,
vista
Note:
Guan is the same word found in Guan Yin, the
goddess of compassion. Yin there means calls or
cries, which are heard and felt, not seen. Guan,
then, is attending with more senses than vision.
Most glosses emphasize the sight, but the
understanding of Guan here should be broader
than this. Attending or Studying may work
somewhat better for this particular aspect of
Guan. The six lines trace a gradual improvement
in perspective, from narrow to comprehensive,
and in our access to alternative or additional
points of view. Also important to the mix is the
idea of being viewed, trying to see ourselves
more objectively, which attends the gain of
alternative points of view. Exemplary behavior,
becoming a better, cleaner person is the flip
side of earnest study.
|
|
21
噬嗑 Shì Hé
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Biting Through |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Severing
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #55, Pron. Shike |
Balkin |
Biting Through |
Meyer |
First
Bite, Deep Breath
|
Barrett
|
Biting Through
|
Needham |
Biting or Burning
Through
|
Blofeld
|
Gnawing
|
Ni |
Biting Through
Hardship |
Bonnershaw
|
Chewing
|
Palmer |
Biting Through |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Biting, Law
Enforcement
|
Pattee |
Biting Through |
Chang
|
Justice
|
Peden |
Biting Through |
Chu
|
Gnawing Through |
Perrottet |
Biting Through |
Chung Wu
|
Biting
|
Powell |
Biting Through |
Clark
|
Gnawing
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Hunter/Huntress
|
Cleary |
Biting Through |
Reifler |
Biting Through |
Coates
|
Breaking Through
Obstacles
|
Richmond |
Oppression (47)
|
Collins
|
Biting Through |
Richter |
Biting and Snapping
|
Crouch
|
Biting Through
|
Riseman |
Biting Through |
Damian-Knight
|
Being Decisive
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Gnawing and Biting
Through
|
Dening
|
Getting Down to
Essentials
|
Rutt |
Flaying
|
Dhiegh
|
Biting Through,
Loquacious, Reformation |
Seabrook |
Decisiveness (43)
|
Douglas
|
Biting Through |
Secter |
Breakthrough,
Wotking Through, Persisting
|
Feng
|
Biting and Chewing
|
Shaughnessy |
Biting and Chewing
|
Fu Youde |
Biting
|
Shchutskii |
Clenched Teeth
|
Graeme
|
Biting Through,
Eradicating an Obstruction
|
Siu |
Punishment
|
Hacker
|
Biting Through |
Sneddon |
Biting Through |
Hatcher
|
Biting Through
|
Sorrell |
Effort,
Determination, Making It Go Right |
Heyboer
|
Biting Through |
Stackhouse |
Confrontation, Two
Different Ways
|
Hoefler
|
Prevailing Against
Odds
|
Stein |
Taking Hold
(Recourse)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Eradicating
|
Sterling |
Biting Through |
Huang, Kerson
|
Biting |
Sung |
Mastication,
Punishment, Pressing, Squeezing
|
Javary
|
Acting Decisively
|
Toropov |
Biting Past |
Jou
|
Bite Through
|
Walker, Barbara |
Gnawing, Reform
|
Judge
|
Decisive Action
|
Wallace |
Biting Through |
Karcher
|
Gnawing and Bitting
Through
|
Wei, Henry |
Punishment
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Cutting Through
Separation
|
West |
Biting Through
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Biting Through |
Whincup |
Biting Through |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Persistent Biting
and Chewing
|
Wilhelm |
Biting Through |
Kunst |
Bite, Crunch
|
Wing |
Reform
|
Legge
|
Union by Gnawing,
Biting Through
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Bite and Chew
|
Leichtman
|
Inner Conflict, The
Storm
|
Wu, Yi |
Biting for Closing
Up
|
Liu, Da
|
Chewing
|
Wu Wei |
Punishment
|
Lynn
|
Bite Together
|
Wu Weifarer |
Biting Through
|
Machovec
|
Accepting
Punishment
|
Young |
Biting Through |
Market
|
Biting Through |
Yu, Titus |
Teeth Close
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Biting Through |
|
|
McCarver
|
Biting Through |
十翼 Shi Yi |
明罰 Ming2 Fa2,
Clear Penalties
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
21.M, Key Words
Gnaw, chew, bite + close together, shut noisily,
clamp down; meta-level solutions
Retributive justice, enforcement, force,
execution, dispatch, severity, lex talionis
Emphatic judgment; police action & power;
legal recourse, punishment, sentence
Cogency, credibility, teeth, bite, decisiveness,
incisiveness, trenchancy; severance
Instruments of justice, legal constraints,
criminal law (dist Gua 06, civil disputes)
Insufferable things; accountability, culpability;
closure, finality, termination, ends
21.G, From the
Glossary
Shi4 (to)
bite (into, on), bite down on, bite off, eat,
devour, gnaw, chew (on) (s,
ed, ing)
He2 (to be)
through, together, closed, closing; (to)
consolidate, bite, eat, chew,
join the teeth;
close, shut, unite, join (s, ed, ing); noisily,
loudly, completely; as
ke4: suddenly, promptly
Notes:
Many people will draw this Gua in a reading and
wonder what punishment they may soon be facing.
But thirty centuries ago the Zhouyi was written
for the King, and then for the inner court, and
so this Gua actually describes the process and
ethics of administering or executing justice,
not receiving it. The Yi is now in the hands of
the common man, who might have a lot to feel
guilty about, and in this case he might apply
the recipient's perspective to himself, but this
was not the original intent. The no-nonsense
Eliminating Obstacles to one's intentions is
reminiscent of Alexander's treatment of the
Gordian Knot: you simply slice right through the
problem. Today it may be argued that one of the
great components of the crime rate combines the
unfair, excessive, sloppy or biased formulation
of the law with the seeming randomness or
irregularity of its enforcement. Gua 21
recommends a different approach: simple laws
with consistent and cogent enforcement.
|
|
22
賁 Bì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Adornment |
MWD - Hatcher |
Fan2, Complicated,
Intricate, Prolific
|
Albertson
|
Elegance
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
繁 #14, Luxuriance
|
Balkin |
Adornment |
Meyer |
Refinement
|
Barrett
|
Beauty
|
Needham |
Ornament, Pattern
|
Blofeld
|
Elegance
|
Ni |
Adornment,
Beautification |
Bonnershaw
|
Style √
|
Palmer |
To Adorn
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Adornment
|
Pattee |
Grace |
Chang
|
Beauty
|
Peden |
Grace
|
Chu
|
Adornmentation |
Perrottet |
Beauty
|
Chung Wu
|
Adornment |
Powell |
Grace |
Clark
|
Beautify
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Openness ?
|
Cleary |
Adornment
|
Reifler |
Beauty
|
Coates
|
Aesthetic Form
|
Richmond |
Give Way ?, Knowing
Both
|
Collins
|
Grace (N) |
Richter |
Adornment
|
Crouch
|
Well Dressed
|
Riseman |
Gracefullness |
Damian-Knight
|
Grace |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Adorning
|
Dening
|
Adornment
|
Rutt |
Bedight |
Dhiegh
|
Grace, Adornment,
Elegant |
Seabrook |
Form
|
Douglas
|
Adornment |
Secter |
Adornment,
Embellish, Elegance
|
Feng
|
Elegance, High
Lights
|
Shaughnessy |
Decorated
|
Fu Youde |
Adornment
|
Shchutskii |
Decoration
|
Graeme
|
Elegance, Adorning,
Coming into Bloom
|
Siu |
Public Image
|
Hacker
|
Adornment |
Sneddon |
Adornment
|
Hatcher
|
Adornment
|
Sorrell |
Beauty,
Celebration, Acceptance |
Heyboer
|
Flower Power
|
Stackhouse |
Beauty, Art,
Culture, Ornament
|
Hoefler
|
Loveliness
|
Stein |
Grace
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Adorning
|
Sterling |
Grace |
Huang, Kerson
|
Decoration
|
Sung |
Decoration
|
Javary
|
Embellishing
|
Toropov |
Grace |
Jou
|
Grace
|
Walker, Barbara |
Elegance, Grace
|
Judge
|
Style √
|
Wallace |
Adorning
|
Karcher
|
Adorning
|
Wei, Henry |
Ornament
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Refinement
|
West |
Grace
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Adornment
|
Whincup |
Adorned
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Adorning, Grace
|
Wilhelm |
Grace
|
Kunst |
Motley, Adorned
|
Wing |
Grace
|
Legge
|
Ornamental,
Adorning
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Decorate
|
Leichtman
|
Perfection,
Materialism
|
Wu, Yi |
Decoration
|
Liu, Da
|
Gracefulness,
Decoration
|
Wu Wei |
Outer Refinement
|
Lynn
|
Elegance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Grace
|
Machovec
|
The Artificial You
|
Young |
Decoration
|
Market
|
Ornament
|
Yu, Titus |
Iridescently
Composed
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Gracefulness
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Grace |
十翼 Shi Yi |
文 Wen2,
Refinement, Enhancement
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
22.M, Key Words
Dressing up, beautifying, decorating,
embellishing; relation of form to content
Elaboration, costumery, vanity, cosmetics,
fashion, facade, veneer, posturing
Refinement, style, grace, elegance, charm, class,
etiquette, protocol, formality
Nearsight, limited vision, myopia, glamour,
fascination, sham, illusion, pomp
Superficiality, public image, fancy surfaces;
proximity’s effect on apparent size
Aesthetics, beauty way, highlighted substance; the
cultural artifact as substance
22.G, From the
Glossary
Bi4 (to)
adorn, dress (up), beautify, embellish,
decorate, make graceful (s, ed, ing)
(to be)
elegant, brilliant, ornate, fancy, dressed up,
sumptuous; superficial, near-
sighted; (a, the)
adornment, ornamentation; shell, treasure; model
(s)
Note:
As pleasant as Grace may be, is not a good Gua
Ming. Only two slivers of the meanings of the
English word Grace mesh with the core meaning of
22: the sense used in "social graces," and a
grace of movement allowed by intense
concentration or focus on what is nearby. The
core idea is "vision that is limited to what is
neaby," the Light blocked by the Mountain. This
is nearsightedness, not in the pejorative sense
of shortsightedness, but simply having a better
view of the nearby than of the far away, and
good reasons not to trust one's longer view of
things. Think of politicians making long-term
decisions with no real vision beyong the next
election. Both the Tuan and the Da Xiang offer
this caution. This is what is fashionable and
shallow, but it's also what helps us to get
along with each other, and sometimes some of the
fashion and culture that comes out of it is
worth keeping.
|
|
23
剝 Bō
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Falling Apart
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Fracturing
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #11 |
Balkin |
Splitting Apart |
Meyer |
Coming
Apart
|
Barrett
|
Stripping Away
|
Needham |
Disaggregation,
Dispersion (59)
|
Blofeld
|
Peeling Off
|
Ni |
Erosion, Decline
|
Bonnershaw
|
Shedding
|
Palmer |
Peeling, Splitting
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Falling Apart
|
Pattee |
Splitting Apart |
Chang
|
Fairness √
|
Peden |
Disruption
|
Chu
|
Cleavage
|
Perrottet |
Collapse
|
Chung Wu
|
Tearing
|
Powell |
Disintegration
|
Clark
|
Pruning
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Assimilation
|
Cleary |
Stripping Away
|
Reifler |
Collapse
|
Coates
|
A Time of
Disintegration
|
Richmond |
Solitude
|
Collins
|
Splitting Apar |
Richter |
Splitting
|
Crouch
|
The Flaying
|
Riseman |
Disintegration
|
Damian-Knight
|
Separation (12)
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Stripping
|
Dening
|
Doing Away with the
Old (49)
|
Rutt |
Flaying
|
Dhiegh
|
Splitting Apart, To
Peel Off, Flay, Intrigue |
Seabrook |
Disintegration
|
Douglas
|
Shedding (49)
|
Secter |
Downfall, Unstable,
About to Collapse
|
Feng
|
Eating Away, Falls
Down
|
Shaughnessy |
Flaying
|
Fu Youde |
Stripping Away
|
Shchutskii |
Destruction
|
Graeme
|
Splitting Apart,
Stripping, Falling Away |
Siu |
Intrigue
|
Hacker
|
Falling
|
Sneddon |
Falling Apart
|
Hatcher
|
Decomposing
|
Sorrell |
Falling Down,
Disintegration, Separation |
Heyboer
|
The Wine Skin and
the Knife
|
Stackhouse |
Laying Bare,
Finality
|
Hoefler
|
Deterioration
|
Stein |
Splitting Apart |
Huang, Alfred
|
Falling Away
|
Sterling |
Disintegration |
Huang, Kerson
|
Loss (41)
|
Sung |
Falling, Flaying
|
Javary
|
Enduring (32)
|
Toropov |
Splitting Apart |
Jou
|
Peeling
|
Walker, Barbara |
Splitting, Peeling
Off, Deterioration
|
Judge
|
Deterioration
|
Wallace |
Breaking Apart
|
Karcher
|
Stripping |
Wei, Henry |
Deprivation
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Usury
|
West |
Division
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Stripping Away |
Whincup |
Destruction
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Stripping Away |
Wilhelm |
Splitting Apart |
Kunst |
Flay, Strip
|
Wing |
Deterioration
|
Legge
|
Falling, Causing to
Fall, Decay, Overthrow
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Strip
|
Leichtman
|
Restraint, Schism
|
Wu, Yi |
Splitting
|
Liu, Da
|
Decay (18)
|
Wu Wei |
Undermining,
Overthrowing, Ending
|
Lynn
|
Peeling
|
Wu Weifarer |
Stripping Away
|
Machovec
|
Dealing with Deceit
|
Young |
Splitting Apart |
Market
|
Unstable
Foundations
|
Yu, Titus |
Fracturing
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Disintegration
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Splitting Apart |
十翼 Shi Yi |
消 Xiao1,
Deterioration, Decay
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
23.M, Key Words
Curtail, abridge, cut back, trim excess, pare
down, deprive, skin, strip, flay, ruin
Ground, downgrade, stabilize, consolidate,
broaden base, return to basics, reduce
Deterioration, breakdown, overthrow,
destabilization, deconstruction, insecurity
Overripeness, dross rotting around a seed,
nourishment from decay, germination
Germaneness, essentials; pruning; concessions for
sustainability, wide foundation
Leaving what should be left, carrying on with less
but with stability; lightening up
23.G, From the
Glossary
Bo1 (to)
curtail, (pare, cut, break) down, abridge, strip
away, split, lay bare, ex-
propriate, reduce,
cut up, skin, peel, flay, deprive, ruin, break,
pluck, degrade,
scavenge, loot (s, ed, ing);
(to be) decomposing, decadent, unsustainable,
dis-
integrating, breaking down; deprived,
stripped (of), ill-founded; (a, the)
deconstruction, destruction, deterioration
Notes:
If you look closely at a climax ecosystem you
will see that the quantity of death and decay is
exactly equal to the quantity of birth and
growth. Recycling is mandatory. This may be
humankind's least favorite of all the natural
laws and the efforts we spend in its denial are
truly staggering in scope. So there it is: we
live one life, in a system that's much bigger
than we are. We pile it up as high as we can,
then watch it go back down. Some of us
participate by returning the favors as we go, as
if to pay our rent. They Consolidate and
maintain their base of support. The truly noble
support the people below them, the true noble
has noblesse
oblige, the noble obligation. The
knives eventually come out for those who do not.
The natural gravity gets an assist. The Gua
Xiang is a too-tall tower, an affront to the
laws of gravity if it lacks an adequate base, a
picture of the Unsustainable. But the fruit has
to rot for the seed to sprout, and the beast
that's for dinner needs to be skinned.
|
|
24
復 Fù
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Returning |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Returning |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #39 |
Balkin |
Return |
Meyer |
Coming
Back Again
|
Barrett
|
Returning
|
Needham |
Point of Return
|
Blofeld
|
Return |
Ni |
Revival, Renewal
|
Bonnershaw
|
Return
|
Palmer |
Return |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Returning
|
Pattee |
Return |
Chang
|
Cycle
|
Peden |
Return
|
Chu
|
Return |
Perrottet |
Turning Point
|
Chung Wu
|
Renewal
|
Powell |
The Turning Point
|
Clark
|
Return
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Rationalizing
|
Cleary |
Return |
Reifler |
Returning |
Coates
|
A New Cycle Begins
|
Richmond |
Return and Make New
|
Collins
|
Return |
Richter |
Returning
|
Crouch
|
Return
|
Riseman |
Returning |
Damian-Knight
|
The Return, Turning
Point, Transition |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Returning
|
Dening
|
Turning Point
|
Rutt |
Returning
|
Dhiegh
|
Return, To Repeat,
Restore, Renewal |
Seabrook |
Return
|
Douglas
|
Returning |
Secter |
Return, The Turning
Point, New Beginning |
Feng
|
Recycle, Spring's
back
|
Shaughnessy |
Returning
|
Fu Youde |
Return
|
Shchutskii |
Return |
Graeme
|
Return, Turning
Back
|
Siu |
Recovery
|
Hacker
|
Return |
Sneddon |
Returning |
Hatcher
|
Returning
|
Sorrell |
Return, Renewal,
Rebirth |
Heyboer
|
Return to your Town
|
Stackhouse |
Turning Back,
Returning
|
Hoefler
|
The New Beginning
|
Stein |
The Wheel of Life
(Return)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Turning Back
|
Sterling |
Return
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Return |
Sung |
Returning |
Javary
|
Returning
|
Toropov |
Returning |
Jou
|
Return
|
Walker, Barbara |
Return, Repeating
|
Judge
|
Recovery
|
Wallace |
Return
|
Karcher
|
Returning |
Wei, Henry |
Returning |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Return of the Light
|
West |
Returning |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Return |
Whincup |
Return |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Return |
Wilhelm |
Return (The Turning
Point)
|
Kunst |
Return |
Wing |
Repeating
|
Legge
|
Returning, Coming
Back
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Return |
Leichtman
|
Cycles, Renewal
|
Wu, Yi |
Returning
|
Liu, Da
|
Return, Revival |
Wu Wei |
Return of the Right
Force
|
Lynn
|
Return
|
Wu Weifarer |
Returning
|
Machovec
|
Minor Setback ?
|
Young |
Renewal
|
Market
|
The Turning Point
|
Yu, Titus |
Turning Back
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Return
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Returning |
十翼 Shi Yi |
反 Fan3, Reversal,
Turning Around/Back
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
24.M, Key Words
Coming back, coming home, coming around, beginning
anew; to resume, retrace
Re-; Restoration, restitution, redintegration,
renewal, reunion, recovery, resilience
Natural processes, cycles, the inevitability of
cycles, recycling; renewed promise
Pivotal point, still point, turning point, axis of
the world, winter solstice, rebirth
Core truths surviving digression, reconstitution,
rededicated efforts, revitalization
More coming around than turning back, 361 degrees
instead of 180 degrees (Fan)
24.G, From the
Glossary
Fu4
(to) devolve, recover, recur, redo, renew,
recommence, recall, repay, reply,
repeat,
restore, resume, retrace, return, revert,
revise, revive, (come, go, turn)
around, back,
home (to); fall back (on); overturn, turn over
(s, ed, ing); (a, the)
answer, recovery,
recurrence, renewal, reply, response, return;
(to be) in answer,
reply, response, return
(to); recurring, recurrent; again, repeatedly;
coming and
going
Notes:
I would use Returning here instead of Return,
since a verb is better at keeping processes in
motion. As with notions of duality at the time
of the Zhouyi's composition, there didn't seem
to be quite as complicated or convoluted a
notion of cyclicity as was later developed in
Chinese culture, but enough of it was there in
the turning of the Si Shi or Four Seasons, and
observances were already marked at twelfth and
twenty-fourth points of the year. This was the
Rule of Heaven and this Gua marks what is
perhaps its most signigicant transit, across the
Winter Solstice, when the light began to Turn
Around and Return. As such it would become a
synecdoche for the entire cycle and the
cyclicity of processes in general. But as a Gua
Ming, Returning must also expand to include
Returning to the Way or Path that is proper to
humanity. In fact, the Tuan uses the word Dao
here in this original sense, long before it
became plastered over with all of the
metaphysical nonsense. It doesn't even say where
the path is: it assumes that deep down you know
and know the way back.
|
|
25
无妄 Wú Wàng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Correctness
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Wu2 Meng4, No
Leading, Pressing Forward
|
Albertson
|
Innocence |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
无孟 #7, Pestilence
|
Balkin |
Innocence |
Meyer |
Simple-Hearted
|
Barrett
|
Without
Entanglement
|
Needham |
Unexpectedness
|
Blofeld
|
Integrity, The
Unexpected
|
Ni |
Innocence,
Unexpected Happening |
Bonnershaw
|
Honesty
|
Palmer |
Not False
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Unexpected
|
Pattee |
Innocence |
Chang
|
Endurance
|
Peden |
Innocence |
Chu
|
Circumspection, The
Unexpected
|
Perrottet |
Innocence |
Chung Wu
|
Freedom from
Vainness |
Powell |
Innocence |
Clark
|
Disentangling (40)
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Spirit of Self
|
Cleary |
No Error, Fidelity
|
Reifler |
The Simple
|
Coates
|
Natural Innocence
|
Richmond |
Natural Innocence |
Collins
|
Innocence |
Richter |
The Unexpected
|
Crouch
|
Unexpected
|
Riseman |
Simplicity
|
Damian-Knight
|
Innocence, The
Unexpected |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Without Embroiling
|
Dening
|
Innocence (Avoiding
Complications)
|
Rutt |
Unexpected
|
Dhiegh
|
Innocence,
Unexpected, Instinctive Goodness |
Seabrook |
Simplicity
|
Douglas
|
Simple Integrity
|
Secter |
Naturalness,
Spontaneous, Unpretentious
|
Feng
|
No Fault, Naiveté
|
Shaughnessy |
Pestilence, a
Disease
|
Fu Youde |
The Unexpected
|
Shchutskii |
Faultlessness
|
Graeme
|
Innocence, Without
Falshood, Disentangling
|
Siu |
Instinctive
Goodness
|
Hacker
|
No Error, No
Expectations
|
Sneddon |
Innocence |
Hatcher
|
Without Pretense
|
Sorrell |
Unexpected,
Spontaneous, Openness |
Heyboer
|
Natural
|
Stackhouse |
Innocence, Not
Hiding, Not Offending
|
Hoefler
|
The Unexpected |
Stein |
Innocence (Wonder)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Without Falsehood
|
Sterling |
Innocence |
Huang, Kerson
|
Propriety ?
|
Sung |
Freedom from Error
|
Javary
|
Spontaneously
Reacting
|
Toropov |
Innocence |
Jou
|
Innocence |
Walker, Barbara |
Innocence, The
Unexpected |
Judge
|
Spontaneity
|
Wallace |
Without Presumption
|
Karcher
|
Without Embroiling
|
Wei, Henry |
Blamelessness
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Innocence
|
West |
Innocence
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Fidelity
|
Whincup |
No Expectations
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Innocent
Faithfulness
|
Wilhelm |
Innocence (The
Unexpected) |
Kunst |
Not Expect,
Reckless, The Unexpected
|
Wing |
Innocence |
Legge
|
Free from
Insincerity
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Without Blame,
Without Error
|
Leichtman
|
Humility ?
|
Wu, Yi |
Non-Fault
|
Liu, Da
|
Innocence (The
Unexpected) |
Wu Wei |
Innocent Action,
Unexpected Misfortune
|
Lynn
|
No Errancy
|
Wu Weifarer |
Innocence
|
Machovec
|
Childlike
Simplicity
|
Young |
Innocence |
Market
|
Innocent Success
|
Yu, Titus |
Without
Expectations
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Innocence
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Freedom from Error
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
Zheng4, Integrity,
Uprightness
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
25.M, Key Words
Lacking, avoiding, no + presumption, pretension,
recklessness, falseness, delusion
Artlessness, guilelessness; naturalness,
simplicity, sincerity, a natural intelligence
Natural gifts, instinctive goodness, spontaneity,
integrity, innocence, inner voices
Pure motives, openness, surprise, wonder, original
mind, faith in innate goodness
Credulity, vulnerability, susceptibility,
accessibility; good faith; the noble savage
Presumption of innocence, benefit of doubt; issues
of confidence, trust & honesty
25.G, From the
Glossary
Wu2
(to be, being, is, am, are, will be, exists,
remains) (has, have, had, having,
with) (do,
does, did) (there is/are/will be) (it/this/these
is/are) no, not, nothing,
never, rarely,
seldom, no longer, without, with no; but (no,
not); there, this, these
(is, are) no, not,
nothing (of); not (a, the); (to be) absent,
gone, non-existent; des-
titute, wanting, in
vain; lacking in; free of/from; avoided, devoid,
void, deprived,
regardless, instead (of),
rather than, despite; not much, no longer; not
being; (the)
least, minimum, (so, very) little;
no matter; no ... done; neither ... nor, whether
... or
not, without ... or; (to) (simply) lack,
want; avoid, escape; not have, own/possess/
have no/less/fewer; find/leave/use no; do no,
not do, do nothing to (s, -ed, -ing);
(will,
would) not (be); do(es) not exist; were there
no; has/have gone off; will/
would not
be(come); (a, the) absence/lack/want of,
avoidance of; nothing, emp-
tiness,
non-being/existence, no-thing-ness; un-, ill-,
im-, in-, dis-, de-, non-; -less;
don't, do not
Wang4 (a,
the) presumption, pretense, expectation,
falseness, duplicity, pretext,
guile, deceit,
folly, error, disorder, disarray, distraction,
extravagance, distortion;
(to be) irregular,
incoherent, presumptuous, pretentious, full of
oneself, false,
erroneous, vain, futile,
ignorant, fanciful, duplicitous, wild, empty,
void, reckless,
entangled, idle, incorrigible,
absurd, stupid, wanton, foolish, disorderly,
untrue,
embroiled, entangled; falsely, wrongly,
foolishly, wantonly; (to) look toward, ex-
pect,
hope; assume, presume, pretend (s, ed, ing)
Notes:
Artlessness or Guilelessness can translate both
words in Wu Wang literally. This is about being
true to your nature and ignoring whatever there
is of culture that might get in the way of this.
The Zhouyi makes a point of noting that this is
not a guarantee that things will not go wrong,
even if the converse is true and being Artful
and full of Guile will generally get you into
trouble. Zhuangzi proposes: "Perfect sincerity
offers no guarantee." Things happen without
reason or purpose, things happen by accident,
although many reasons are made up in retrospect,
especially to account for bad things happening
to good people. Whole pantheons of deities are
made up out of this. But a life lived simply to
learn is superior to a life of pretending to
know, and the odds generally fall in favor of
the good-hearted. As an extra layer of
protection against grave injustice, many
societies add a presumption of Innocence or a
benefit of the doubt for cases where questions
arise, and the burden of proof falls on the
accuser. People understand deep down that the
violation of Innocence is a loss to us all, as
it costs us our ability to trust. Without trust
there can be no civilization.
|
|
26
大畜 Dà Chù
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Great Taming
Force
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Tai4 Chu4, Same
Meaning as Received Text
|
Albertson
|
Limiting by the
Strong
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
泰畜 #10, Great
Storage, pron. Taixu
|
Balkin |
Great Accumulation
|
Meyer |
Unlimited
Resources
|
Barrett
|
Great Taming
|
Needham |
Greater Inhibition
|
Blofeld
|
The Great Nourisher
|
Ni |
Great Amassment
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Big Cultivator
|
Palmer |
Great Domesticating
Powers
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Building Up Great
Strength
|
Pattee |
Force of the Great
|
Chang
|
Tolerance
|
Peden |
Restraint (44)
|
Chu
|
The Great
Restraining
|
Perrottet |
Domination by
Strength
|
Chung Wu
|
Restraint of the
Great
|
Powell |
The Restraining
Force
|
Clark
|
Focused Activity
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Egotist
|
Cleary |
Great Buildup,
Nurturance of the Great
|
Reifler |
Major Restraint
|
Coates
|
Exercising Great
Power
|
Richmond |
The Flow and the
Channel ?
|
Collins
|
Holding Firm
|
Richter |
Great Cattle
|
Crouch
|
Farming in the
Large
|
Riseman |
Great Power in
Restraint
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Taming Power of
the Great |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Great Accumulating
|
Dening
|
Controlling Your
Resources
|
Rutt |
Farming, Major
|
Dhiegh
|
The Taming Power of
the Great |
Seabrook |
Great Restraint
|
Douglas
|
Accumulation
through Restraint
|
Secter |
Firm Restraint
Under Pressure, Obligations
|
Feng
|
Cultivation of the
Great
|
Shaughnessy |
Great Domestic
Animals
|
Fu Youde |
Great Increment
|
Shchutskii |
Rearing of the
Great
|
Graeme
|
Great Accumulation
|
Siu |
Restraint by the
Strong
|
Hacker
|
Big Restraint, Big
Accumulation
|
Sneddon |
Taming Force
|
Hatcher
|
Raising Great
Beasts
|
Sorrell |
Control, Harnessing
Power, Taking the Reins |
Heyboer
|
Raising Big Cattle
|
Stackhouse |
Great (or
Increased) Involvement
|
Hoefler
|
The Great Taming
Power
|
Stein |
The Wisewoman
(Grounding) ?
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Great Accumulation
|
Sterling |
Taming Power of the
Great |
Huang, Kerson
|
Big Cattle
|
Sung |
Great Accumulation
|
Javary
|
Taming the Great
|
Toropov |
The Restraining
Power of the Great
|
Jou
|
Great Saving
|
Walker, Barbara |
Energy, Great
Nurture
|
Judge
|
Conservation √
|
Wallace |
Large Husbandry
|
Karcher
|
Great Accumulating
|
Wei, Henry |
Great Restraint
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Great Tames
|
West |
Strong Restraint
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Taming Power of
the Great |
Whincup |
Big is Tamed
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Taming the Big,
Great Accumulation
|
Wilhelm |
The Taming Power of
the Great
|
Kunst |
Big Domestic
Animal, Keep, Nurture
|
Wing |
Potential Energy
|
Legge
|
Great Restraint and
Accumulation
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Great Restraint,
Great Offering
|
Leichtman
|
Inner Power,
Motivating Power
|
Wu, Yi |
Great Accumulation
|
Liu, Da
|
Taming the Great
Powers
|
Wu Wei |
Great Restraint
|
Lynn
|
Great Domestication
|
Wu Weifarer |
Great Accumulation
|
Machovec
|
Self-Control
|
Young |
Major Accumulation
|
Market
|
The Power of
Knowledge
|
Yu, Titus |
Major Cultivation
of Ch'i
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Restraint (44)
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Major Restraint |
十翼 Shi Yi |
畜德 Chu4 De2,
Training in Character
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
26.M, Key Words
Domesticating, taming, civilizing, harnessing,
schooling, training, husbandry
Stewardship, trust, legacy, dynasty, foundation,
endowment, usufruct, service
Inheritance, responsibility, discipline,
restraint, inhibition; investing in potential
Mound building, cultural accumulation;
consolidating gains, making them work
Banking, investment, conservation (as distinct
from conservatism), guardianship
One’s place in history, shoulders of giants,
ancestry & posterity, making destiny
26G, From the
Glossary
Da4
(to be) accomplished, best, better, big,
complete, critical, crucial, developed,
enormous, entire, extreme, far, full, fully
grown, good, grand, great(er, est), hea-
vy,
high, large(r), (very, greatly) important, long,
loud, major, mature, mighty,
more, most, noble,
noteworthy, old, overall, (more, most) perfect,
pure, realized,
ripe, seasoned, serious,
significant, strong, successful, vast, whole,
wholesome,
vital; a lot of, full of, lots of;
master-, (a, the) completeness, (full)
development,
entirety, grand(eur, ness),
greatness, growth, (great) importance, largesse,
major-
ity, maturity, vastness, wholeness; a
great deal, (very) much, very; already,
com-
pletely, entirely, fully, greatly,
thoroughly, wholly, en masse, well-; of (great,
crucial, vital) importance
Chu4
(to) take care of, care for, provide for, tend
(to), attend (to), keep, raise, rear,
feed,
nurture, sustain, nourish, bring up, support,
shelter, cherish, train, manage,
cultivate,
retain, restrain, tame, (bring under) control,
herd, domesticate, raise
beasts animals,
brutes; accumulate, store up, gather, hoard,
reserve (s, ed, ing);
(a, the) nurture,
cultivation, culture, domestication, husbandry,
management,
training; domestic animal; raising
... beasts
Notes:
This Gua depicts assuming the reins of our
beasts of burden and taking control in the
building of wealth, dynasty, culture and
civilization. This is the Gua of the builders,
living for things that are sure to outlive them.
There is a grand presumption here, the perfect
counterpoint to 25, that we have a right to play
at being gods if we can only command the wealth
and property required to do so. Thankfully the
gifted can still command cultural wealth and
intellectual property, given sufficient access
to "knowledge of prior ideas and past deeds."
Clearly there is a conservative element at work
here: great accumulation must precede great
expense, and in managing this accumulation we
re-encounter the same need for trust that we
find in 25.
|
|
27
頤
Yí
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Nourishment
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Sustenance √
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #15 |
Balkin |
Nourishment |
Meyer |
An
Open Mouth
|
Barrett
|
Nourishment
|
Needham |
Nutrition
|
Blofeld
|
Nourishment, Jaws |
Ni |
Providing
Nourishment |
Bonnershaw
|
Jaws
|
Palmer |
Taking Nourishment
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Mouth, Providing
Nourishment
|
Pattee |
Nourishment |
Chang
|
Need and Supply
|
Peden |
Nourishment |
Chu
|
Jaws, Nourishment |
Perrottet |
Mouth
|
Chung Wu
|
Nourishing
|
Powell |
Nourishment |
Clark
|
Nourishment
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Caring
|
Cleary |
Nourishment, Lower
Jaw |
Reifler |
Nourishment |
Coates
|
Nourishing Oneself
and Others
|
Richmond |
Choice from the
Flow ?
|
Collins
|
Nurturing
|
Richter |
Cheeks
|
Crouch
|
Jaws
|
Riseman |
Nourishment |
Damian-Knight
|
Nourishment, Health
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Jaws, Swallowing
|
Dening
|
Nourishing
|
Rutt |
Molars
|
Dhiegh
|
Corners of the
Mouth, Prov. Nourishment |
Seabrook |
Stimulation
|
Douglas
|
Nourishment |
Secter |
Sustenance,
Nourishment, Nurture |
Feng
|
Looking Up ?
|
Shaughnessy |
Jaws
|
Fu Youde |
Nourishment |
Shchutskii |
Nourishment |
Graeme
|
Nourishment |
Siu |
Sagacious Counsel
|
Hacker
|
Bulging Cheeks
|
Sneddon |
Nourishment |
Hatcher
|
Hungry Mouth
|
Sorrell |
Feedback,
Fulfillment, Nourishment |
Heyboer
|
Jaws
|
Stackhouse |
Food Eating Food,
What Nourishes What
|
Hoefler
|
Nourishment |
Stein |
Providing
Nourishment (Caring)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Nourishing
|
Sterling |
Nutrition
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Cheeks
|
Sung |
Cheek, Nourishment
|
Javary
|
Nourishing Daily
|
Toropov |
The Corners of the
Mouth |
Jou
|
Jaws
|
Walker, Barbara |
Nourishment,
Mouths, Jaws
|
Judge
|
Support
|
Wallace |
Nourishing |
Karcher
|
Jaws, Swallowing
|
Wei, Henry |
Nourishment |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Nourishment |
West |
Nourishment
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Nourishment |
Whincup |
Bulging Cheeks
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Providing Care and
Attention, Nourishment
|
Wilhelm |
Corners of the
Mouth, Prov. Nourishment |
Kunst |
Jaw
|
Wing |
Nourishing |
Legge
|
Jaws Hang Down,
Nourishing
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Jaws, Nourishment |
Leichtman
|
Investing,
Nurturing Love
|
Wu, Yi |
Nourishment
|
Liu, Da
|
Nourishment |
Wu Wei |
Providing
Sustenance
|
Lynn
|
Nourishment
|
Wu Weifarer |
Nourishing |
Machovec
|
Self-Sufficiency √
|
Young |
Nourishment |
Market
|
Seeking Nourishment
|
Yu, Titus |
The Jaw
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Provision
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Nourishment |
十翼 Shi Yi |
養 Yang3,
Fostering, Nourishing, Nurturing
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
27.M, Key Words
Appetites, hungers, drives; sustenance, nutrition,
nurture, provision, nourishment
Meeting needs, furnishing necessities,
self-reliance, self-assertion, competence
Choices of menu, diet, good taste, selecting the
input for output, fostering health
Finding the genuine & productive appetites,
starving the false; potential energy
Appetite and its gratification, nutrition as a
science, fostering growth and the true
Nutrient and energy cycles, raw material and
fuel; hungering properly; G.I.G.O.
27.G, From the
Glossary
Yi2 (a, the)
appetite, hunger (s); nourishment, nutrition,
sustenance, jaws, open
jaws, mouth, hungry
mouth, chin, cheek; self-care; (to) take care of
oneself, keep
fit, consume, eat, take in,
ingest, feed on, nourish, rear, feed, furnish
necessities,
care for; hunger (s, ed, ing); (to
be) appetitive, hungry, oral; with appetite,
with
hunger
Notes:
Appetitive Behavior, the following of our
Hungers, is one of our life's great givens.
Abraham Maslow's "Hierarchy of Needs" may
undergo a great deal of fine tuning over the
coming centuries but its fundamental premise
will remain: when we meet our lower or most
basic needs, we are then freer to move on to
meeting our higher needs. And in this freedom
and moving on we often have an opportunity to
choose what we want to need next. Of course the
advertising industry has jumped into this with
both feet, but those of us with De or character
can find our workarounds and retain some control
of our hungers. It doesn't really matter that
this is a small minority: we all know that the
prey far outnumber the predators.
|
|
28
大過
Dà Guò
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Excess
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Tai4 Guo4, Same
Meaning as Received Text |
Albertson
|
Dominance by the
Mighty
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
泰過 #48, Great
Surpassing
|
Balkin |
Greatness in Excess
|
Meyer |
Last
Straw
|
Barrett
|
Great Exceeding
|
Needham |
Greater
Topheaviness
|
Blofeld
|
Excess
|
Ni |
Great Excess
|
Bonnershaw
|
Excess
|
Palmer |
Great Experience
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Excess
|
Pattee |
Critical Point
|
Chang
|
Abnormality
|
Peden |
Effort
|
Chu
|
Inner Preponderance
|
Perrottet |
Predominance
|
Chung Wu
|
Excess of the Great
|
Powell |
Excess
|
Clark
|
Crisis
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Game Player
|
Cleary |
The Passing of
Greatness, Excess of Greatness
|
Reifler |
Greatness in Excess
|
Coates
|
Great Potential
|
Richmond |
Rigidity
|
Collins
|
Great Excess
|
Richter |
Great Excess
|
Crouch
|
Great Passage
|
Riseman |
Excessive Greatness
|
Damian-Knight
|
Preponderance of
the Great |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Great Exceeding
|
Dening
|
Overload
|
Rutt |
Passing, Major
|
Dhiegh
|
Preponderance of
the Great, Experience |
Seabrook |
Stress √
|
Douglas
|
Excess
|
Secter |
Excessive,
Overextended, Overburdened √
|
Feng
|
Great Excess, High
Over-Head
|
Shaughnessy |
Great Surpassing |
Fu Youde |
Great Fault
|
Shchutskii |
Overdevelopment of
the Great
|
Graeme
|
Great Exceeding,
Taking Action, Crisis Point
|
Siu |
Great Gains ?
|
Hacker
|
Big in Excess
|
Sneddon |
Excess
|
Hatcher
|
Greatness in Excess
|
Sorrell |
Pressure, Tension,
Transcendence
|
Heyboer
|
Across the Great
Pass
|
Stackhouse |
Great Injury, Great
Problems
|
Hoefler
|
Excess
|
Stein |
Interesting Times |
Huang, Alfred
|
Great Exceeding
|
Sterling |
Preponderance of
the Great |
Huang, Kerson
|
Great Excess
|
Sung |
Great Passing
|
Javary
|
Greatly Exceeding
|
Toropov |
Exceeding in What
Is Great
|
Jou
|
Great Passing
|
Walker, Barbara |
Excess, Strain
|
Judge
|
Importance
|
Wallace |
Greatly Exceeding
|
Karcher
|
Great Exceeding |
Wei, Henry |
Excessive Greatness
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Great in Excess
|
West |
Excess
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Preeminence
|
Whincup |
Big Gets By
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Overabundant
Surplus
|
Wilhelm |
Preponderance of
the Great
|
Kunst |
Big Passing
|
Wing |
Critical Mass
|
Legge
|
Extraordinary,
Exceeding
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Greatly Beyond the
Ordinary
|
Leichtman
|
Crisis, Point of
Tension
|
Wu, Yi |
Great Passing
|
Liu, Da
|
Great Excess
|
Wu Wei |
Excess of Power
|
Lynn
|
Major Superiority
|
Wu Weifarer |
Great Exceeding
|
Machovec
|
Continuing Problems
|
Young |
Excess Yang
|
Market
|
Inner Strength
|
Yu, Titus |
Flying Way Above ?
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Great Weight
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Large Excess |
十翼 Shi Yi |
動 Dong4, Inpetus,
Excitement, Movement
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
28.M, Key Words
Inundation, saturation, surcharge, extremity,
crisis, emergency, stress, pressure
Encroachment, transgression, overload, live load,
hurried adapting, resilience
Surpassing, overwhelming, extraordinary, too much;
going beyond, transition
Peak experience, stretching limits, pushing
envelopes; more than bargained for
Excess, unleashing, abnormality, heavy matters,
under strain, humbling events
Going far beyond, greatly transcending, greeting
something greater than yourself
28.G, From the
Glossary
Da4
(to be) accomplished, best, better, big,
complete, critical, crucial, developed,
enormous, entire, extreme, far, full, fully
grown, good, grand, great(er, est), high,
heavy, large(r), (very, greatly) important,
long, loud, major, mature, more, most,
mighty,
noble, noteworthy, old, overall, (more, most)
perfect, pure, realized, ripe,
seasoned,
serious, significant, strong, successful, vast,
whole, wholesome, vital; a
lot of, full of,
lots of; master-, (a, the) completeness, (full)
development, entirety,
grand(eur, ness),
greatness, growth, (great) importance, majority,
vastness, whole-
ness largesse, maturity; a
great deal, (very) much, very; already,
entirely, fully,
completely, greatly,
thoroughly, wholly, en masse, well-; of (great,
crucial, vital)
importance
Guo4
(to) go beyond, go past, exceed, surpass,
transcend, miss, stray from, pass
(by, over);
bypass, get by, transgress, trespass, stray,
err, inundate, predominate,
exceed proper
limits; (s, ed, ing); (to be) passing,
transient, errant, past, in excess,
extreme,
exceptional, too much (of), excessive, beyond,
above, overly, unusual,
extraordinary;
greater/larger than; (a, the) error,
transgression, fault, excess (ive-
ness) (s);
will err; to a fault, to extremity, to excess,
to extremes
Notes:
When the Exraordinary happens we adapt, we
become what we need to become. Rules that once
demanded obedience might mean little or nothing
now. It's OK to jaywalk to escape a collapsing
building. Amusingly, the Zhouyi uses the
attraction between men and women separated by
their ages as an example or metaphor for such
Force Majeure, ancient forces that are far
beyond our limited comprehension. The Ridgepole
might symbolize the highest expectation we have
of our need for protection, but our insurance
against being swept away completely is still
measured in probabilities and all contingencies
can never be covered. We can only expect, when
that day comes, that we will have to leave what
used to be.
|
|
29
坎 Kǎn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Perilous Pit
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Gan4, from Gan
River Gorge (Jiangxi Prov)
|
Albertson
|
The Pit
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
贛 #17, Repeated
Entrapment
|
Balkin |
The Abyss |
Meyer |
Anticipate
Pitfalls
|
Barrett
|
Repeating Chasms
|
Needham |
Flowing Motion, Pit
|
Blofeld
|
The Abyss
|
Ni |
The Abyss |
Bonnershaw
|
Chasm
|
Palmer |
The Watery Depths
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Abyss
|
Pattee |
The Abysmal |
Chang
|
Water
|
Peden |
The Abyss
|
Chu
|
The Abyss
|
Perrottet |
Abyss
|
Chung Wu
|
Entrapment
|
Powell |
The Abyss
|
Clark
|
Training
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Saying Yes
|
Cleary |
Multiple Danger,
Constant Pitfalls
|
Reifler |
The Deep
|
Coates
|
A Dangerous
Situation
|
Richmond |
The Unfamiliar
|
Collins
|
The Abysmal |
Richter |
Watery Pits
|
Crouch
|
Pit
|
Riseman |
The Deep
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Deep Waters
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Repeating Gorge,
Venturing
|
Dening
|
Danger (The Abyss)
|
Rutt |
Pit
|
Dhiegh
|
Unfathomable
Mystery
|
Seabrook |
Problems
|
Douglas
|
The perilous Chasm
|
Secter |
Foreboding, Crisis,
Peril
|
Feng
|
Double Trap, Deep
Breaths
|
Shaughnessy |
Repeated Entrapment
|
Fu Youde |
Water Danger
|
Shchutskii |
Abyss |
Graeme
|
The Abyss,
Formless, Darkness, Danger
|
Siu |
Danger
|
Hacker
|
Water |
Sneddon |
Perilous Pit
|
Hatcher
|
Exposure
|
Sorrell |
Abyss, Crisis,
Pitfall |
Heyboer
|
The Teachings of
Danger
|
Stackhouse |
Learning to Master
One's Own Emotions
|
Hoefler
|
Danger
|
Stein |
The Depths
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Darkness (36)
|
Sterling |
Abysmal Water
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Water |
Sung |
Sinking
|
Javary
|
Overcoming Vertigo
|
Toropov |
Recurring Hazards
|
Jou
|
Water
|
Walker, Barbara |
Abyss, Water,
Danger
|
Judge
|
Persistence
|
Wallace |
Water, Pitfalls
|
Karcher
|
Repeating the
Gorge, Venturing
|
Wei, Henry |
Peril
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Danger, Water
|
West |
The Deep
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Watery Depths
|
Whincup |
Pits
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Chasm, Profound
Depth or Void, Danger
|
Wilhelm |
The Abysmal (Water)
|
Kunst |
Pitfall
|
Wing |
Danger
|
Legge
|
Dangerous Defile
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Water, The Pit |
Leichtman
|
Challenge, Threat
|
Wu, Yi |
(Repeated) Sinking
|
Liu, Da
|
Water |
Wu Wei |
Water, Danger, The
Abyss
|
Lynn
|
The Constant
Sinkhole
|
Wu Weifarer |
The Depths
|
Machovec
|
Shorcomings
Increase Problems
|
Young |
Danger
|
Market
|
The Dangerous
Ravine
|
Yu, Titus |
Testing Wings over
the Chasm
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Abyss
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Abysmal
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
險 Xian3, Risk,
Exposure, Hazard
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
29.M, Key Words
Repeated, multiple, familiar with + crisis, risk,
hazard, peril, exigency, trial, danger
Pit, chasm, canyon, gorge, strait, test; living on
the edge, the way out is through
Immerse, plunge in, undergo, commit, fall to, get
involved; fear, vertigo, anxiety
Concentration, alertness, challenge, unarguable
constraints, the will to live, heart
Flow, water’s approach to givens, necessity to
perform; fluidity, grace, courage
Enlightening confrontations, the hard fact as
teacher; Castaneda’s having to believe
29.G, From the
Glossary
Kan3 (a,
the) pit, pitfall, hole, cavity, snare, trap,
canyon, chasm, defile, gorge,
depth, precipice,
grave, risk, exposure, danger, dangerous
position, dangerous
place, crisis, exigency,
critical situation; gravity; water necessity
(s); (to) trap,
entrap, bury in a pit; (a, the)
pit’s, canyon’s, chasm’s, risk’s; (a pun)
Notes:
Rather than simply overreacting to the words
Peril, Danger or Abyss, try asking instead: what
is it that is deliberately and enthusiastically
sought by people who climb about in these deep
canyons and boat right through the white water
rapids. There is a full-hearted commitment to
the process of surviving, to the passing of this
trial. There is a great simplicity in having
most of our options removed by serious
constraints to the path or the route ahead. The
senses sharpen, the heart pounds, the whole
being responds to the challenge by waking up,
being more fully alive. It's a Risk, but it's
life learning more about life and what it is
capable of.
|
|
30
離 Lí
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Clinging |
MWD - Hatcher |
Luo2, Bird
Netting, Sieve; To Bestow, Spread
|
Albertson
|
Sunlight (35)
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
羅 #49, The Net
|
Balkin |
Radiance |
Meyer |
Sudden
Flare-Up
|
Barrett
|
Clarity
|
Needham |
Deflagration,
Adherence, Adhesion
|
Blofeld
|
Flaming Beauty
|
Ni |
Radiance
|
Bonnershaw
|
Brilliance
|
Palmer |
To Shine Brightly,
To Part
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Fire, Fiery Temper
|
Pattee |
Flaming Beauty
|
Chang
|
Fire
|
Peden |
Dependence
|
Chu
|
Clinging Light,
Fire
|
Perrottet |
Attachment
|
Chung Wu
|
Allegiance
|
Powell |
Flaming Beauty |
Clark
|
Illuminating
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Recognition of
Feelings
|
Cleary |
Fire |
Reifler |
Fire |
Coates
|
Dependence on the
Powers of the Universe
|
Richmond |
Clinging to the
Real
|
Collins
|
The Clear
|
Richter |
Fire
|
Crouch
|
Firebird
|
Riseman |
Fire |
Damian-Knight
|
The Clinging, Fire,
The Heart of the Matter
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Radiance,
Clarifying
|
Dening
|
Shedding Light on
Things
|
Rutt |
Oriole
|
Dhiegh
|
The Clinging |
Seabrook |
Clarity
|
Douglas
|
Brilliant Beauty
|
Secter |
Attachment,
Dependence, Brilliance
|
Feng
|
Shining, Flaming
Bright
|
Shaughnessy |
To Fasten
|
Fu Youde |
Fire
|
Shchutskii |
Radiance
|
Graeme
|
Brightness,
Clarity, Clinging Fire, Radiance
|
Siu |
The Cosmic Mean
|
Hacker
|
Fire |
Sneddon |
Brightness
|
Hatcher
|
Arising
|
Sorrell |
Nurture, Reliance,
Shining |
Heyboer
|
To Catch the Bird
of Brightness
|
Stackhouse |
Birds and Beasts
Distinctly √ Marked
|
Hoefler
|
Fire
|
Stein |
The Caressing Fire
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Brightness
|
Sterling |
Clinging Fire
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Fire |
Sung |
Brightness,
Separateness
|
Javary
|
Overcoming
Bedazzlement (Fire)
|
Toropov |
Fire
|
Jou
|
Fire
|
Walker, Barbara |
Beauty, Fire,
Intelligence
|
Judge
|
Normative
Constraint
|
Wallace |
Fire, Attachment
|
Karcher
|
Radiance,
Clarifying
|
Wei, Henry |
Light, Adherence
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Clarity, Fire
|
West |
Brilliance
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Shining Brightly
|
Whincup |
Shining Light
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Fire
|
Wilhelm |
The Clinging (Fire)
|
Kunst |
Lia-Bird
|
Wing |
Synergy
|
Legge
|
Double Brightness
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Fire, Brightness,
Divided, Distantly |
Leichtman
|
Collaboration,
Addiction
|
Wu, Yi |
Brightness
|
Liu, Da
|
Fire |
Wu Wei |
Clarity, Adherence
|
Lynn
|
Cohesion
|
Wu Weifarer |
Radiance
|
Machovec
|
The golden Mean
|
Young |
Radiance
|
Market
|
Gentle Clarity
|
Yu, Titus |
The Sun Beast
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Fire
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Clinging
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
麗
離 Li4 Li2, Conditioned Arising
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
30.M, Key Words
Radiate, diversify, individuate, glow, distinguish
self; depart, go on; energy cycles
Fire, flame, light, ignition, sunlight, beauty,
radiance; transformational processes
Coherence, moment, presence, attention,
sentience, intelligence, enlightenment
Dependence on fuel, relying on place and
conditions; photosynthesis, metabolism
Temporally conditioned consciousness, dependent
arising; appearances, seeming
Inherent in & adhering to conditions;
instance, existence, articulation; continuum
30.G, From the
Glossary
Li2 (to)
rise, arise, radiate, diverge, separate,
contrast, depart, differ, digress, part,
get
distance, distinguish (from, out of);
articulate, leave, spread out, stand out,
move
on, abandon, choose (one), decide, part, cut,
divide, distribute, arrange, set
out, pass on,
pass through, hang down, hang from (s, ed, ing);
(to be) distinct,
different, diverse,
diversified, divided, separated, off, away
(from), distant, apart
(from), without;
pendant, dependent, dispersed, independent (of);
(a, the) arising,
rearising, departure,
removal, distinction, divergence, division,
separation, dis-
tance, difference (from);
radiance, display, fire, flame, firelight,
highlight; net; vis
a vis each other; a bird,
esp. an oriole (colorful contrast); figure
ground relation-
ships; the root of the English
word "existence" is to stand out or stand forth;
"When Li birds sing, silk worms grow" (Shuowen)
Note:
Li4, from the Tuan Zhuan, also means beautiful
or elegant, as well as clinging, dependent, or
conditioned. Li4 Li2 then means Beautiful
Arising as well as Dependent/Conditioned
Arising. This version of the idea of conditioned
arising arose before the arrival of Buddhism in
China. The two Li's are almost opposite in
meaning, as if reversed in their direction. One
is the convergence of forces that led to this
moment, the sunlight that got locked up in the
plant that the cow ate and turned into beef and
milk. This is what is depended upon and why we
care for the cow. The other Li is that light
lighting up again, in the mind of the one who
dined on the cow or her milk, and then to
continue to radiate outward, diverging in the
various activities of the day. Li Li, thus and
in a word, is the fourth dimension, past and
future, as these light up in the present moment,
in the intelligence and consciousness that is
sunlight on the move again.
|
|
31
咸 Xián
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Influence |
MWD - Hatcher |
Qin1, Intense,
Attentive, Respectful, Hope For
|
Albertson
|
Persuasion
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
欽 #44, Feelings, To
Respect
|
Balkin |
Mutual Influence |
Meyer |
Magnetic
Attraction
|
Barrett
|
Influence
|
Needham |
Reaction,
Interweaving
|
Blofeld
|
Attraction,
Sensation
|
Ni |
Mutual Attraction
|
Bonnershaw
|
Feeling
|
Palmer |
All Embracing
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Move, Influence
|
Pattee |
Influence |
Chang
|
Passion
|
Peden |
Influence
|
Chu
|
Stimulation,
Compelling
|
Perrottet |
Courtship
|
Chung Wu
|
Affection
|
Powell |
Influence |
Clark
|
Uniting (8)
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Leading
|
Cleary |
Sensing,
Sensitivity
|
Reifler |
Tension
|
Coates
|
The Influence of
the Strong Over the Weak
|
Richmond |
Coming Out of
Himself
|
Collins
|
Influence |
Richter |
Unity
|
Crouch
|
Power
|
Riseman |
Stimulation
|
Damian-Knight
|
Influence, Natural
Attraction |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Conjoining
|
Dening
|
Mutual Attraction
|
Rutt |
Chopping
|
Dhiegh
|
Influence, All,
Entirely |
Seabrook |
Attraction
|
Douglas
|
Mutual Attraction
|
Secter |
Responsive
Charisma, Stimulation
|
Feng
|
Affect
|
Shaughnessy |
In All Cases, To
Feel 感
|
Fu Youde |
Sensation
|
Shchutskii |
Combination,
Interaction
|
Graeme
|
Influence
|
Siu |
Influencing to
Action
|
Hacker
|
Mutual Influence
|
Sneddon |
Influence |
Hatcher
|
Reciprocity
|
Sorrell |
Influence,
Incisive, Sensitivity |
Heyboer
|
Affect and
Affection
|
Stackhouse |
Heartfelt,
Something that Hits Home
|
Hoefler
|
The Attraction
|
Stein |
Influence
(Courtship)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Mutual Influence
|
Sterling |
Influence
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Cutting
|
Sung |
Exerting Influence
|
Javary
|
Inciting
|
Toropov |
Courtship
|
Jou
|
Influence
|
Walker, Barbara |
Attraction,
Pleasure
|
Judge
|
Influence
|
Wallace |
Sympathy
|
Karcher
|
Conjoining
|
Wei, Henry |
Mutual Influence |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Influence of
Attraction
|
West |
Mutual Influence
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Wooing
|
Whincup |
Movement
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Sense and
Sensitivity, Attraction, Influence
|
Wilhelm |
Influence (Wooing)
|
Kunst |
Cut Off, Salty,
Chop Off
|
Wing |
Attraction
|
Legge
|
Moving, Influencing
to Movement
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Influence, To
Move
|
Leichtman
|
Shared Benefits,
Magnetism
|
Wu, Yi |
Response
|
Liu, Da
|
Attraction,
Stimulation
|
Wu Wei |
Attraction,
Influence
|
Lynn
|
Reciprocity
|
Wu Weifarer |
Influence
|
Machovec
|
Influencing Others
|
Young |
Influence |
Market
|
Mutual Influence
|
Yu, Titus |
Stimulation, Mutual
Influence
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Relating
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Influence |
十翼 Shi Yi |
感 Gan3, Feeling,
Stimulation, Attraction |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
31.M, Key Words
Mutuality, symbiosis, interactions, convergence,
coalition, congress, in concert
Sharing, embrace, affinity; persuasion, influence,
incentives, interest, affection
Complements, healthy combinations, right for each
other, compelling fulfillment
Congress for mutual purposes, teamwork; coming
together, resonating with others
Eros, attraction, sensuality, stimulation,
prompting, arousal, stirrings, response
Common interests, meeting each other’s needs,
valence bonding, synergy, dyad
31.G, From the
Glossary
Xian2 (to
be) joined, conjoined, united (in, with), in
touch with; moved, touched,
persuaded (in, by);
together, altogether, all, every, mutual,
shared, concordant,
convergent, integrated,
complete, full, finished; everywhere; (to) feel,
sense; join,
conjoin, unite, put together,
reciprocate, touch, come into contact, move,
embrace,
share, come together, convene,
converge, complete (s, ed, ing) (in, with,
toget-
her); (a, the) feeling, sensation (s);
persuasion, reciprocity, mutuality; entirely,
fully, completely, wholly; (also used for gan,
3232, to stimulate, influence, at-
tract)
Notes:
The core
meaning of Xian combines two Western ideas for
which the West has just the right words: Eros
and Symbiosis. Unfortunately they don't
combine into a single, recognizable idea and
the words just don't sound very authentic as a
Gua Ming. This Gua uses eros and libido as a
general metaphor for the will to interact with
the world and live a fertile existence.
Clearly the fertility part works best when
mutuality is involved and the attraction is
reciprocal, and this is the hard part.
Attracting another to a the degree that we
ourselves are drawn requires attractive
behavior, courtship behavior, even good or our
best behavior. Getting out of one's self and
into something more fertile is the subject
matter of the lines.
|
|
32
恆 Héng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Perseverance |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Continuity |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #32 |
Balkin |
Enduring |
Meyer |
Eventuality
|
Barrett
|
Lasting
|
Needham |
Duration, Constant
|
Blofeld
|
The Long-Enduring
|
Ni |
Constancy
|
Bonnershaw
|
Constancy
|
Palmer |
Constant
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Constancy
|
Pattee |
Duration |
Chang
|
Help
|
Peden |
Persistence |
Chu
|
Constancy, Enduring
|
Perrottet |
Duration |
Chung Wu
|
Constancy
|
Powell |
Endurance
|
Clark
|
Consistency
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Continuity
|
Cleary |
Constancy,
Persistence
|
Reifler |
Continuity
|
Coates
|
Endurance in the
Midst of Change
|
Richmond |
Continuing,
Branching Out
|
Collins
|
Duration |
Richter |
Constancy
|
Crouch
|
Enduring
|
Riseman |
Continuity
|
Damian-Knight
|
Duration, Power to
Subsist in Time |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Persevering
|
Dening
|
Perseverance
|
Rutt |
Fixing
|
Dhiegh
|
Duration, Constant,
Persevering |
Seabrook |
Permanence
|
Douglas
|
Long Duration
|
Secter |
Enduring Constancy,
Perseverance
|
Feng
|
Endurance, Old
Faithful
|
Shaughnessy |
Constancy
|
Fu Youde |
Constancy
|
Shchutskii |
Constancy
|
Graeme
|
Persevering,
Persistence in Time, Steady C.
|
Siu |
Enduring
|
Hacker
|
Constancy
|
Sneddon |
Perseverance
|
Hatcher
|
Continuity
|
Sorrell |
Purposeful,
Constant, Persistent |
Heyboer
|
Steady the Helm of
the Heart
|
Stackhouse |
Constancy of Will
and Purpose
|
Hoefler
|
The Duration
|
Stein |
Duration (Lovers) ?
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Long Lasting
|
Sterling |
Duration
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Steadfastness
|
Sung |
Constancy
|
Javary
|
Lasting
|
Toropov |
Persisting
|
Jou
|
Constancy
|
Walker, Barbara |
Endurance,
Continuance
|
Judge
|
Endurance
|
Wallace |
Constancy |
Karcher
|
Persevering |
Wei, Henry |
Lasting, Steadiness
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Constancy
|
West |
Duration
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Constancy |
Whincup |
Constancy
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Steadfast and
Faithful, Constancy
|
Wilhelm |
Duration
|
Kunst |
Long Time,
Constant, Perpetuation
|
Wing |
Continuing
|
Legge
|
Perseverance,
Continuously Maintaining |
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Constancy
|
Leichtman
|
Enduring Values,
Immortality
|
Wu, Yi |
Duration
|
Liu, Da
|
Duration |
Wu Wei |
Duration
|
Lynn
|
Perseverance |
Wu Weifarer |
Duration
|
Machovec
|
Maturity
|
Young |
Duration |
Market
|
Perseverance |
Yu, Titus |
Inner Light
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Duration |
|
|
McCarver
|
Duration |
十翼 Shi Yi |
久 Jiu3, Duration,
Enduring, Lasting
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
32.M, Key Words
Continuing, surviving, lasting, endurance,
steadiness; adaptability, sustainability
Duration, protraction, longevity, persistence,
coherence across time, consistency
Regularity, constancy, stability, maturity,
integrity, proficiency, learned versatility
Self-renewal, self-regeneration, self-succession;
the long run; alignment, meetness
Keeping to path or vow, holding true throughout
outer changes, dynamic balance
Perseverance, not always predictability or a
sameness; resourcefulness, resilience
32.G, From the
Glossary
Heng2 (a,
the) duration, continuity, continuance,
endurance, steadiness, constan-
cy, consistency,
longevity, sustainability; (what, that which)
endures, survives; (to
be) regular, enduring,
lasting, chronic, continuing, persistent,
persisting, continu-
ous, perennial, perpetual,
prolonged, constant, throughout; (to) last in,
go on, en-
dure (changes), continue, persevere,
stay, perpetuate, prolong (s, -ed, -ing);
always; constantly, lastingly, persistently,
continuously, regularly, perseveringly
Notes:
One might expect a book called the Changes to
have an interesting take on things which persist
through time. Western ideas have been influenced
for millenia by Greek notions that cannot permit
perfection to coexist with change. The Western
gods themselves are denied the ability to change
or grow, and ultimately, even to move, because
that would imply a prior, imperfect state,
unthinkable in a divinity. In the Zhouyi a thing
can only survive by adapting as its existence
progresses. To endure, unchanged, in a fixed
state, is not Duration but delusion. Continuity
endures, history itself endures, original
bearings and principles can persist, genes can
get passed down generally intact, but anything
that is real is going to have to rub up against
other realities and get altered in the process.
A thing merely continues until it is
unrecognizably altered.
|
|
33
遯 Dùn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Retreat (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Yuan3, u.f. 遠,
Remote, (Regard as) Distant
|
Albertson
|
Retiring
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
掾 #3, Yuan3,
Wielding
|
Balkin |
Retreat |
Meyer |
Under
Cover
|
Barrett
|
Retreat
|
Needham |
Regression
|
Blofeld
|
Yielding,
Withdrawal
|
Ni |
Retreat
|
Bonnershaw
|
Withdrawal |
Palmer |
To Hide
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Retreat
|
Pattee |
Retreat |
Chang
|
Discretion and
Pressure
|
Peden |
Retreat |
Chu
|
Retiring,
Withdrawal |
Perrottet |
Retreat |
Chung Wu
|
Retreat
|
Powell |
Withdrawal |
Clark
|
Withdrawal
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Privacy
|
Cleary |
Withdrawal |
Reifler |
Retreat |
Coates
|
Strategic
Withdrawal √
|
Richmond |
Withdrawal |
Collins
|
Retreat |
Richter |
Retreat
|
Crouch
|
Abduction (Piglet)
|
Riseman |
Retreat |
Damian-Knight
|
Retreat, Strategic
Withdrawal |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Retiring
|
Dening
|
Retreating
|
Rutt |
Pig, Piglet
|
Dhiegh
|
Retreat,
Withdrawal, Impose Upon, To Hide |
Seabrook |
Retreat
|
Douglas
|
Withdrawal |
Secter |
Withdrawal,
Retreat, Relinquishing |
Feng
|
Withdrawal, Flight
|
Shaughnessy |
To Retreat, Piglet
|
Fu Youde |
Little Pig
|
Shchutskii |
Retreat |
Graeme
|
Retreat, Withdrawal
|
Siu |
Withdrawal |
Hacker
|
The Piglet
|
Sneddon |
Retreat |
Hatcher
|
Distancing
|
Sorrell |
Retreat,
Withdrawal, Sanctuary |
Heyboer
|
Save your Bacon
|
Stackhouse |
Temp. Escape,
Keeping Trouble at a Distance
|
Hoefler
|
The Withdrawal |
Stein |
Withdrawal |
Huang, Alfred
|
Retreat
|
Sterling |
Retreat
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Little Pig
|
Sung |
Retirement
|
Javary
|
Retreating
|
Toropov |
Retreating
|
Jou
|
Yielding
|
Walker, Barbara |
Retreat,
Withdrawal, Yielding
|
Judge
|
Withdrawal
|
Wallace |
Withdrawal |
Karcher
|
Retiring
|
Wei, Henry |
Retreat |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Retreat
|
West |
Withdrawal
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Withdrawal |
Whincup |
The Piglet
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Withdrawal or
Discontinuation, Retreat
|
Wilhelm |
Retreat
|
Kunst |
Young Pig
(Withdraw)
|
Wing |
Retreat
|
Legge
|
Retiring, Seclusion
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Retreat |
Leichtman
|
Stepping Bac
kWithdrawal |
Wu, Yi |
Retreat
|
Liu, Da
|
Retreat, Withdrawal
|
Wu Wei |
Withdrawal
|
Lynn
|
Withdrawal
|
Wu Weifarer |
Retreat
|
Machovec
|
Strategic
Withdrawal |
Young |
Retreat |
Market
|
Retreat |
Yu, Titus |
The Pig
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Retreat |
|
|
McCarver
|
Retreat |
十翼 Shi Yi |
退 Tui4,
Withdrawal; 遠 Yuan3, Distance
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
33.M, Key Words
To retreat, step back, detach; strategic pullback,
withdrawal, neutrality, abstention
Issues of freedoms from and to; retire a debt;
retirement, sabbatical, sabbath, rest
Seclusion, refuge, sanctuary, asylum, reserve,
haven, safe distance, out of reach
Retraction, resignation, quitting claim;
inaccessibility, discretion, disengagement
Escaping, transcending, reframing; taking a
larger point of view, a bigger picture
Neutralizing, letting go, standing down, stepping
back, getting away, evasiveness
33.G, From the
Glossary
Dun4 (to)
retreat, withdraw, retire, escape, evade, avoid,
flee, hide away, withdraw
from, get distance
from, step back (from), run away, abscond,
skulk, hide; drag
the feet in walking (s, ed,
ing); (a, the) retirement, retreat, reservation,
sanctuary;
distance, distancing, withdrawal;
[reframing]; (to be) hidden, concealed, evasive,
withdrawn, invisible, secluded
Notes:
Tactical or Strategic Withdrawal sums up 33's
core meaning better than Retreat, even though
Retreat is the best translation of Dun in most
of the lines. For any problem we encounter there
is an optimum Distance from which it may be
successfully addressed. As Einstein said, "The
significant problems we face cannot be solved at
the same level of thinking we were at when we
created them." Dun is movement in search of that
optimum distance. This might be jumping up one
level of abstraction, or fleeing to higher
ground, or just getting the hell out of an
impossible dilemma. Now, as to the Pig or the
Piglet as Gua Ming, this is an artifact of
academia, where polysemy in the classical
Chinese language is not officially recognized.
The solution to the problem it poses simply
requires getting some distance from the academic
world, just as the little pig will try to get
distance from you and your butcher's tools.
|
|
34
大壯 Dà Zhuàng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Power of the
Great |
MWD - Hatcher |
Tai4 Zhuang4, Same
Meaning as Rec'd Text
|
Albertson
|
The Strength of the
Mighty
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
泰壯 #26, Great
Maturity
|
Balkin |
Great Power |
Meyer |
Full
Realization
|
Barrett
|
Great Vigor
|
Needham |
Great Power
|
Blofeld
|
The Power of the
Great |
Ni |
Great Strength
|
Bonnershaw
|
Great Power
|
Palmer |
Great Strength |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Great Strength
|
Pattee |
Great Power |
Chang
|
Powerful People
|
Peden |
Power of the Great
|
Chu
|
The Power of the
Great |
Perrottet |
Power of
the Strong |
Chung Wu
|
Great Strength
|
Powell |
Strength of
Greatness
|
Clark
|
Powerful
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Might
|
Cleary |
The Power of the
Great, Great Power |
Reifler |
Great Strength |
Coates
|
A Position of Great
Power
|
Richmond |
A Store of Power
(26)
|
Collins
|
Injured by the
Great
|
Richter |
Great Strength
|
Crouch
|
Great Injury
|
Riseman |
Great Power
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Power of the
Great |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Great Invigorating
|
Dening
|
Great Power
|
Rutt |
Big Injury
|
Dhiegh
|
The Power of the
Great, Great Authority |
Seabrook |
Power
|
Douglas
|
Vigorous Strength
|
Secter |
Powerful,
Irresistable, Forging Ahead
|
Feng
|
Great Toughness
|
Shaughnessy |
Great Maturity
|
Fu Youde |
Great Power
|
Shchutskii |
Great Power
|
Graeme
|
Great Strength,
Invigorating
|
Siu |
Great Vigor |
Hacker
|
Big Uses Force
|
Sneddon |
Great Power |
Hatcher
|
Big and Strong
|
Sorrell |
Big and Strong,
Opportunity, Breaking Free |
Heyboer
|
A Man of Stone
|
Stackhouse
|
Great Strength,
More than Mere Force
|
Hoefler
|
The Great Might
|
Stein |
Justice (Power)
(21)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Great Strength
|
Sterling |
Power of the Great
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Great Injury
|
Sung |
Great Vigour
|
Javary
|
Wielding the Great
Strength
|
Toropov |
The Power of the
Great |
Jou
|
Great Vigor
|
Walker, Barbara |
Power, Greatness
|
Judge
|
Power
|
Wallace |
Great Strength |
Karcher
|
Great Invigorating
|
Wei, Henry |
Great Strength |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Great Strength
|
West |
Strength
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Power of the Great
|
Whincup |
Big Uses Force
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Power of the
Great |
Wilhelm |
The Power of the
Great
|
Kunst |
Big Strong, Big
Injure
|
Wing |
Great Power |
Legge
|
Abundance of
Strength and Vigor
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Great Strength |
Leichtman
|
Expanding
Influence, Peak Energy
|
Wu, Yi |
Great Strength
|
Liu, Da
|
Great Power
|
Wu Wei |
Great Power |
Lynn
|
Great Strength
|
Wu Weifarer |
Great Strength |
Machovec
|
Optimal Influence √
|
Young |
Great Power |
Market
|
Gentle Strength
|
Yu, Titus |
Great Force |
Marshall, Chris
|
Great Power
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Great Strength |
十翼 Shi Yi |
則止 Ze2 Zhi3, The
Rule of Stillness
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
34.M, Key Words
Much, great, full, big, major, extensive +
strength, vigor, energy, potency, force
Assertion, aggression, self-reliance, tenacity,
forging ahead; initiative, purpose
To be headstrong, demanding, pushy, obstinate,
obsessed, driven; testing a limit
Robust, dominant; feedforward, the need for
feedback & sense; might needs right
Power wanting governing; meta-solutions to
problems; problems of tunnel vision
Insight as reorganizing perceptual field; power is
really measured by effectiveness
34.G, From the
Glossary
Da4
(to be) accomplished, best, better, big,
complete, critical, crucial, developed,
enormous, entire, extreme, far, full, fully
grown, good, grand, great(er, est), high,
heavy, large(r), (very, greatly) important,
long, loud, major, mature, mighty, old,
more,
most, noble, noteworthy, overall, (more, most)
perfect, pure, realized, ripe,
seasoned,
serious, significant, strong, successful, vast,
whole, wholesome, vital; a
lot of, full of,
lots of; master-, (a, the) completeness, (full)
development, entirety,
grand (-eur, -ness),
greatness, growth, (great) importance, largesse,
wholeness, vast-
ness, maturity, majority; a
great deal, (very) much, very; already,
completely, en-
tirely, fully, greatly,
thoroughly, wholly, en masse, well-; of (great,
crucial, vital)
importance
Zhuang4
(to be) strong, vigorous, forceful, powerful,
potent, fertile, big, mighty,
large, great,
grand, magnificent, stout, able-bodied, healthy,
hardy, hearty, virile,
full-blown, fully grown,
dynamic, robust, fierce, dominant, animated,
lively, indomitable in spirit, [alpha] ; (a,
the) strength, vigor, energy, force, power,
might,
potency, prime of life, dominance,
fierceness; (to) strengthen, embolden, enliven,
encourage, enspirit, invigorate, animate, make
better; (grow, wax) strong (s, ed, ing)
Notes:
This Gua illustrates the difference between
Power and Force. In scientific terms, Power is
the rate at which energy changes form. It often
has little to do with force. Where work is to be
done, efficiency or efficacy is an important
measure and wasted energy is merely entropy.
Therefore, resistance to applied force is only a
measure of power when heat is the desired
result. The symbolism makes good use of a big,
pushy, butt-head ram or billy goat, wielding
what he hopes the ewes or does will mistake for
power. But this is only power when noise and
nuisance is the desired result. Real power is in
the lack of resistance, in the opening or
opportunity, the hole in the fence, in the hole
for the axle, in the still place, in the pause,
as the Za Gua suggests, where the opening is
found.
|
|
35
晉 Jìn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Progress (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Jin4, Cross Water,
might be u.f. 晉 |
Albertson
|
Making Headway
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
溍 #51, Aquas,
Aquatic
|
Balkin |
Progress |
Meyer |
Light
Coming Back
|
Barrett
|
Advancing (N)
|
Needham |
Rapid Advance |
Blofeld
|
Progress
|
Ni |
Progress |
Bonnershaw
|
Advance
|
Palmer |
To Advance |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Advancement
|
Pattee |
Progress |
Chang
|
Progress
|
Peden |
Progress |
Chu
|
Progress, Advance |
Perrottet |
Progress |
Chung Wu
|
Advancement
|
Powell |
Progress |
Clark
|
Fluorishing
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Change
|
Cleary |
Advance
|
Reifler |
Advance |
Coates
|
Rapid Progress
|
Richmond |
Primal Forces
Create Change
|
Collins
|
Advancement
|
Richter |
Advancing
|
Crouch
|
Advancing
|
Riseman |
Progress |
Damian-Knight
|
Progress |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Prospering
|
Dening
|
Progress
|
Rutt |
Advancing
|
Dhiegh
|
Progress, To
Advance |
Seabrook |
Progress
|
Douglas
|
Progress
|
Secter |
Progress,
Advancement, Improvement
|
Feng
|
Advancement, Rising
Son
|
Shaughnessy |
To Advance
|
Fu Youde |
Advance
|
Shchutskii |
Rising (Above the
Horizon)
|
Graeme
|
Insight, Proceeding
Forward, Rising Sun
|
Siu |
Progress |
Hacker
|
Advance |
Sneddon |
Progress |
Hatcher
|
Expansion
|
Sorrell |
Success, Winning,
Popularity |
Heyboer
|
The Gift
|
Stackhouse
|
Birds Gather in
Field at Sunrise
|
Hoefler
|
Progress |
Stein |
Progress
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Proceeding Forward
|
Sterling |
Progress |
Huang, Kerson
|
Advance |
Sung |
Forwardness
|
Javary
|
Slowly Advancing in
Daylight
|
Toropov |
Moving Forward
|
Jou
|
Advancing
|
Walker, Barbara |
Progress
|
Judge
|
Progress
|
Wallace |
Advancing |
Karcher
|
Prospering
|
Wei, Henry |
Advancement |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Progress
|
West |
Progress
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Advancement
|
Whincup |
Advancement |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Steady Improvement
|
Wilhelm |
Progress
|
Kunst |
Advance |
Wing |
Progress
|
Legge
|
Advancing
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Advance, To
Fluorish |
Leichtman
|
Enlightenment,
Favorable Change
|
Wu, Yi |
Going Upward
|
Liu, Da
|
Progress |
Wu Wei |
Great Progress
|
Lynn
|
Advance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Prospering
|
Machovec
|
Succeeding
|
Young |
Progress |
Market
|
Advance |
Yu, Titus |
Rising (46)
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Progress |
|
|
McCarver
|
Advance |
十翼 Shi Yi |
進 Jin4, Progress,
Advance, Development
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
35.M, Key Words
To advance, progress, develop, improve, grow,
circulate, open, warm, thaw, dawn
Acknowledge, demonstrate; energize; emergence,
discovery, disclosure, exposure
Enterprise, venture, free markets; learning by
way of freedom, liberty, permission
Overt, sunny, healthy, vibrant, generous,
outgoing; daylight, daytime, sunshine
Openness, assent, acknowledgment, opening up,
glasnost; present, offer, promote
Character, virtu, self-development; growth too
temporary, healthy to be parasitic
35.G, From the
Glossary
Jin4 (to)
advance, progress, grow, develop, extend,
prosper, increase, improve,
enter (upon), make
progress, lead, introduce, present, insert (s,
ed, ing); (to be)
forward, advanced, far along;
(a, the) growth, advancement, progression,
pro-
motion, development
Notes:
In natural ecosystems, inputs of free energy
tend to fuel the system's self-organizational
capabilities. Sunlight almost always tends to
make them more coherent as well as more robust
and diverse. This principle also operates in
laissez faire or free-market economics (an
ecosystem quite distinct from corporate
capitalism). The prosperity alone is sufficient
to enable the system to run itself, as if by
Adam Smith's Invisible Hand. The "Classical
Liberal" approach to both wealth and liberty is
in fact a good part of the subject matter of
this Gua. Transparency and sunshine laws can
also be inferred. Both Advance and Progress are
problematic here as Gua Ming, specifically for
their ease of confusion with Gua 46 and 53,
while Prosperity and Fluorishing can be easily
confused with 11 and 55. The word Expansion
avoids this confusion.
|
|
36
明夷 Míng Yí
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Darkening of the
Light |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Hiding One's Light
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #38
|
Balkin |
Darkening of the
Light |
Meyer |
Light
Going Out
|
Barrett
|
Brightness Hidden
|
Needham |
Darkening
|
Blofeld
|
Darkening of the
Light, Injury (N) |
Ni |
The Time of
Darkness
|
Bonnershaw
|
Eclipse
|
Palmer |
Brightness Dimmed
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Darkening of the
Light |
Pattee |
Darkening Light |
Chang
|
Injustice
|
Peden |
Darkness
|
Chu
|
Darkening of the
Light |
Perrottet |
Eclipse
|
Chung Wu
|
Light Obliterated
|
Powell |
Sinking Light
|
Clark
|
Darkness
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Crisis
|
Cleary |
Concealment of
Illumination
|
Reifler |
Darkening of the
Light |
Coates
|
A Time of
Diminished Influence
|
Richmond |
Effort through
Resistance
|
Collins
|
Wounded Light (N)
|
Richter |
The Bright Pheasant
|
Crouch
|
Brilliance Wounded
(The Yi Covenant)
|
Riseman |
Darkening of the
Light |
Damian-Knight
|
Darkening of the
Light |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Brightness Hiding
|
Dening
|
Keeping a Low
Profile
|
Rutt |
Crying Pheasant
|
Dhiegh
|
Darkening of the
Light, Waning, Barbarians |
Seabrook |
Negativity
|
Douglas
|
Hiding of the Light
|
Secter |
Constraint,
Suppression, Tyranny
|
Feng
|
Light Darkened
|
Shaughnessy |
Calling Pheasant
|
Fu Youde |
Darkness
|
Shchutskii |
Defeat of the Light
|
Graeme
|
Darkening of the
Light, Brilliance Injured
|
Siu |
Intelligence
Unappreciated
|
Hacker
|
The Bright (Calling
) Pheasant
|
Sneddon |
Intelligence
Wounded |
Hatcher
|
Brightness Obscured
|
Sorrell |
Damaged, Rejection,
Invalidation |
Heyboer
|
Brightness and
Leveling
|
Stackhouse |
The Bright and the
Dark, Hidden Virtues
|
Hoefler
|
Eclipse of Light
|
Stein |
Adversity
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Brilliance Injured
|
Sterling |
Darkening of the
Light |
Huang, Kerson
|
The Crying Pheasant
|
Sung |
Appearance of Clear
Intelligence Wounded
|
Javary
|
Enshrouding Oneself
|
Toropov |
Diminishing of the
Light
|
Jou
|
Darkening
|
Walker, Barbara |
Darkening, Injury,
Repression
|
Judge
|
Decline
|
Wallace |
Brightness Injured
|
Karcher
|
Hiding Brightness,
Brightness Hiding
|
Wei, Henry |
Darkened Light
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Darkening of the
Light |
West |
Dimmed Light
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Brightness Dimmed
|
Whincup |
The Bright Pheasant
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Concealing the
Light
|
Wilhelm |
Darkening of the
Light |
Kunst |
Bright Ordinary,
Pheasant Wound
|
Wing |
Censorship
|
Legge
|
Intelligence
Wounded or Repressed
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Bright Bird,
Brightness Obscured
|
Leichtman
|
Sabotage,
Vulnerability
|
Wu, Yi |
Brightness Injured
|
Liu, Da
|
Darkening of the
Ligh, The Darkened Light |
Wu Wei |
Persecution
|
Lynn
|
Suppression of the
Light
|
Wu Weifarer |
Dimming
|
Machovec
|
Being Misunderstood
|
Young |
Defeat of the Light
|
Market
|
Hiding the Light
|
Yu, Titus |
Feigning Bird
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Fading Light
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Darkening of the
Light |
十翼 Shi Yi |
用晦 Yong4 Hui4,
Using the Darkness
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
36.M, Key Words
Light, clarity, wisdom, intelligence + hidden,
prevented, concealed, suppressed
Discreet, cloaked, dampened, camouflaged,
disguised, censored; go underground
Banking, long-term investment, placing assets in
durable forms, burying treasure
Turning down the flame, banking the coals;
withdrawing one’s consent & support
Covert intelligence, stealth operations, cloak
& dagger scenarios, shadow warriors
Self-suppression, repression, making ordinary,
dumbing down shrewdly, veiling
36.G, From the
Glossary
Ming2
(a, the) brightness, clarity, enlightenment,
illumination, light, lucidity, luster;
discernment, intelligence (of), perception,
perceptiveness, resolution, vision,
eyesight;
agreement, covenant; (to be) aware, bright,
brilliant, clear, clear-sighted,
conscious,
enlightened, evident, explicit, illustrious,
informed, intelligent, intelligible, lucid,
manifest, perceptive, pure, sagacious, shining,
visionary; plain (as
day and night); (to)
assert, awaken, see, brighten, clarify,
elucidate, enlighten,
envision, explain, get
clear, illuminate, shine, illustrate, make
evident, perceive,
show, understand, see (s,
ed, ing)
Yi2 (to
be) hidden, obscure(d), covered, covert, kept
out of sight, suppressed,
repressed, common,
usual, invisible, level, even, just, equal,
smooth, plain, simple, ordinary, vulgar,
foreign, barbaric, distant, injured, hurt,
wounded, dark; (to)
hide, obscure, cover, make
ordinary, suppress, disappear, fade into
context, re-
press, injure, kill, wound, hurt,
extinguish (s, ed, ing); (to feel) at rest, at
ease,
tranquil, safe, secure, sated, satisfied,
full; (a, the) hiddenness, obscurity, cover,
dark, cloak, shroud; need to know, camouflage;
without color
Notes:
While the circumstances that surround this Gua
might recommend or suggest that one's light be
dimmed, hidden or shielded, this is not really
an image of this light being defeated, wounded
or damaged. The process of Darkening the Light
is proactive: it is done deliberately, as a
stratagem. Covert Intelligence, in fact, is a
viable, literal translation of Ming Yi, and a
couple of instances of its use are described in
the lines. Disguise is used in the lines as
well: a man feigning a limp, and a bird feigning
a broken wing as a misdirection, and a prisoner
feigning insanity (a reference to an historical
Chinese Hamlet). Also useful here is the notion
of banking the coals of a fire, reducing its
rate of combustion, to allow the flame to last
through the night.
|
|
37
家人
Jiā Rén
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Family (N) |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Family |
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #63 |
Balkin |
The Family |
Meyer |
Under
One Roof
|
Barrett
|
People in the Home
|
Needham |
Relation (Parts in
Wholes)
|
Blofeld
|
The Family |
Ni |
Family
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Family
|
Palmer |
The Family |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Family
|
Pattee |
Family |
Chang
|
Family
|
Peden |
Family |
Chu
|
The Family, Proper
Relations |
Perrottet |
Family |
Chung Wu
|
The Family
|
Powell |
The Family |
Clark
|
Family
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Friendship (13)
|
Cleary |
People in the Home
|
Reifler |
The Family |
Coates
|
The Relationships
Within the Family
|
Richmond |
Nourishing
Relationships
|
Collins
|
The Family |
Richter |
The Family
|
Crouch
|
Clan Folk
|
Riseman |
The Family |
Damian-Knight
|
The Family |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Dwelling (Clan)
People
|
Dening
|
The Family
|
Rutt |
Household
|
Dhiegh
|
The Family, Clan,
Home, Lineage |
Seabrook |
Proper
Relationships
|
Douglas
|
The Family |
Secter |
Kinship
Obligations, Allegiance
|
Feng
|
Family Member
|
Shaughnessy |
Family Members
|
Fu Youde |
Family
|
Shchutskii |
Household
|
Graeme
|
Household, Going
Home, Way of the Woman
|
Siu |
Family Life
|
Hacker
|
The Family |
Sneddon |
Family |
Hatcher
|
Family Members
|
Sorrell |
Home, Family,
Belonging |
Heyboer
|
Family of Man
|
Stackhouse |
The Family Type,
Home
|
Hoefler
|
The Family |
Stein |
The Matriarchy
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Household
|
Sterling |
Family
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Family |
Sung |
The Family
|
Javary
|
Organizing for the
Long Term
|
Toropov |
Members of the
Family
|
Jou
|
Family
|
Walker, Barbara |
Family
|
Judge
|
Community (13)
|
Wallace |
People in the Home
|
Karcher
|
Dwelling (Clan)
People
|
Wei, Henry |
The Family |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Family
|
West |
Family |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
People in the
Family
|
Whincup |
The Household
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Fundamental
Social Group, Household
|
Wilhelm |
The Family (The
Clan)
|
Kunst |
Family, Home
|
Wing |
Family
|
Legge
|
Family Members,
Household
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
The Family |
Leichtman
|
Heritage, The
Loving Parent
|
Wu, Yi |
The Family
|
Liu, Da
|
The Family |
Wu Wei |
The Family, The
Organization |
Lynn
|
The Family
|
Wu Weifarer |
The Family
|
Machovec
|
The Family |
Young |
The Family |
Market
|
A Household
|
Yu, Titus |
Family Members
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Family
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Family |
十翼 Shi Yi |
家謂 Jia1 Wei4,
Familial Designations/Roles
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
37.M, Key Words
Home, household, clan, familiar, kindred + people,
others, individuals, humanity
A microclimate, hearth, warmth, security,
intimacy; roles in working relationships
Microcosm, moral boundaries and practice, division
of labor, social organization
Relations, convection, influences on the larger
world; contributions, propagation
Commitments, ties, partnerships and contracts;
meeting basic social requirements
Domestic, dominion, domain, domine; householder in
Hindu & Buddhist doctrine
37.G, From the
Glossary
Jia1 (a,
the) family, house, household, home, dwelling,
domestic affair, relative,
clan, class,
profession (s); (ruling) families; familiar,
kindred; school of thought,
specialist; (to be)
familial, familiar, at home, domestic, indoors;
(to) live with,
together; keep a household; (s,
ed, ing); (a, the) family’s, household’s
Ren2
(a, the) person, people, man, woman, one(s),
other(s), another, human being,
individual (s);
each (one), other persons/people; anybody,
anyone, everybody,
everyone, somebody, someone
(else)(’s); some, those; humanity, humankind,
mankind, society; character, citizen, fellow,
folk; inhabitant, member, occupant,
participant, persona, personality, population,
personnel, staff, role; (in) adulthood;
(of)
maturity; (to be) human, adult, grown, mature;
humanity’s; (a, the) person’s,
people’s,
occupant’s; fellow-; -body, -man, -person, -ist
Notes:
The Chinese name Jia Ren suggests that the
subject of discussion is the Family's People or
Members (Ren). This is what we are concerned
with here, not simply the Family or Household
(Jia) as a unit in the larger society. Family
Members may sound a little more awkward, but it
is both more literal and more to the point. The
text goes on to discuss the various roles and
processes within the family.
|
|
38
睽 Kuí
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Disunion
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Guai1,
Strangeness, Contradiction, Oddness
|
Albertson
|
Alienation
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
乖 #53, Perversion
|
Balkin |
Opposition (N) |
Meyer |
Noticing
the Difference
|
Barrett
|
Opposing
|
Needham |
Opposition |
Blofeld
|
The Estranged,
Opposites
|
Ni |
Opposition,
Disharmony |
Bonnershaw
|
Contraries
|
Palmer |
Opposition |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Parting
|
Pattee |
Opposition |
Chang
|
Difference
|
Peden |
Opposition |
Chu
|
Opposition,
Estrangement |
Perrottet |
Opposition |
Chung Wu
|
Incongruity
|
Powell |
Opposites |
Clark
|
Separation
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Fighter ?
|
Cleary |
Opposition,
Disharmony |
Reifler |
Neutrality ?
|
Coates
|
Working with
Opposition
|
Richmond |
Opposition in Time,
Taking Turns |
Collins
|
Opposition |
Richter |
Disunity
|
Crouch
|
Aims
|
Riseman |
Neutrality,
Disunity
|
Damian-Knight
|
Opposition |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Polarizing
|
Dening
|
Opposition
|
Rutt |
Espy
|
Dhiegh
|
Distant From,
Separated, Opposition |
Seabrook |
Opposition
|
Douglas
|
Opposites |
Secter |
Stalemate, Impasse
(39), Dilemma
|
Feng
|
Diversion
|
Shaughnessy |
2 Eyes Seeing
Differently, See Incorrectly
|
Fu Youde |
Conflict
|
Shchutskii |
Discord
|
Graeme
|
Opposition,
Misunderstamnding, Divergence
|
Siu |
Alienation
|
Hacker
|
Estrangement
|
Sneddon |
Disunion
|
Hatcher
|
Estrangement
|
Sorrell |
Solitary, The
Stranger, Alienated |
Heyboer
|
Looking Askance
|
Stackhouse |
Watchful Eyes,
Strange Signs
|
Hoefler
|
The Opposite
|
Stein |
Opposition |
Huang, Alfred
|
Diversity
|
Sterling |
Opposition |
Huang, Kerson
|
Abandoned
|
Sung |
Strangeness,
Disunion
|
Javary
|
Seeing Both Sides
of a Coin
|
Toropov |
Opposition |
Jou
|
Opposition
|
Walker, Barbara |
Estrangement,
Opposition
|
Judge
|
Opposition
|
Wallace |
Disunity
|
Karcher
|
Diverging,
Polarizing
|
Wei, Henry |
Separation (12)
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Opposition
|
West |
Opposition |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Contradiction (6)
|
Whincup |
Estrangement
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Estrangement,
Alienation, Opposition
|
Wilhelm |
Opposition
|
Kunst |
Set Sights, To
Sight
|
Wing |
Contradiction
|
Legge
|
Division, Mutual
Alienation, Disunion |
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Strange
|
Leichtman
|
Ambiguity, Discord
|
Wu, Yi |
Opposition
|
Liu, Da
|
Opposition |
Wu Wei |
Alienation
|
Lynn
|
Contrariety
|
Wu Weifarer |
Opposition
|
Machovec
|
Alienation (12)
|
Young |
Opposition |
Market
|
Misunderstanding
|
Yu, Titus |
Not Eye to Eye √
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Opposition |
|
|
McCarver
|
Division |
十翼 Shi Yi |
不同行 Bu4 Tong2
Xing2, Not Acting as One
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
38.M, Key Words
Divergence, dissociation, disparity, dissonance,
dissention, discord, contradiction
Polarization, parting of ways, ambivalence,
tension, stress; odd, crafty, perverse
Uniqueness, diversity, contrast, standing out,
sticking out, separation, strangeness
To stare, squint as if disbelieving, be
astonished; individual nature, distinctiveness
Separateness, aloneness, alienation, incongruity;
to stand alone, agree to disagree
Detachment, isolation, aloneness; emphasis,
articulation, stress as in highlighting
38.G, From the
Glossary
Kui2 (to
be) estranged, separated, distant, weird,
dissociated, divergent, foreign
alien,
separate(d), removed, polarized, contrary,
unusual, strange, opposed, in
opposition,
diametrically opposed; (a, the) disparity,
estrangement, separation,
polarity; eyes not
aligned, moving separately
Note:
On opposite ends of the spectrum, in oppposite
parts of the sky: these are really the only
senses in which the word Opposition applies
here. Opposites, therefore, would be a more
useful Gua Ming than Opposition. The character
Kui seems to depict eyes that are somehow
discomforting to see, either wild, or strange,
or rolling, or glaring, or staring off in
different directions. In any event there are two
things here that are unalike, as are the
constituent Ba Gua of Fire and Water. The image
of eyes that are doing different things might
suggest the phenomenon called Retinal Disparity:
the two eyes that share one head have different
points of view. They send different pictures to
the brain. We don't mind, though, because the
brain uses the differences to constuct its
perception of depth. As an analogy, this extends
readily into both cultural and biological
diversity, where depth is also a function of
divergence. It can even be used to support
freedom of speech and the value of a free
marketplace of ideas. We merely have to get
beyond the discomfort of other people
disagreeing with us.
|
|
39
蹇 Jiǎn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Arresting Movement
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Barrier
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #20 |
Balkin |
Obstruction |
Meyer |
Limping
Along
|
Barrett
|
Limping
|
Needham |
Retardation
|
Blofeld
|
Trouble
|
Ni |
Obstruction |
Bonnershaw
|
Obstacle
|
Palmer |
Obstruction |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Obstacles
|
Pattee |
Obstruction |
Chang
|
Stoppage
|
Peden |
Obstruction |
Chu
|
Impediments
|
Perrottet |
Obstacle
|
Chung Wu
|
Difficulty
|
Powell |
Obstacles |
Clark
|
Obstacles
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Provocateur ?
|
Cleary |
Trouble, Halting
|
Reifler |
Difficulty
|
Coates
|
Obstructions to
Progress
|
Richmond |
Upheaval ?
|
Collins
|
Obstruction |
Richter |
Impediments
|
Crouch
|
Hobbled
|
Riseman |
Obstruction |
Damian-Knight
|
Obstruction |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Limping,
Difficulties
|
Dening
|
Facing Obstruction
|
Rutt |
Stumbling
|
Dhiegh
|
Halt, Proud, Go
Lame, Obstruction |
Seabrook |
Obstruction |
Douglas
|
Obstructions |
Secter |
Blockage,
Obstruction, Impediment |
Feng
|
Stonewall
|
Shaughnessy |
Afoot
|
Fu Youde |
Trouble
|
Shchutskii |
Obstacle
|
Graeme
|
Hardship, Impasse,
Difficulty
|
Siu |
Obstruction |
Hacker
|
Obstruction |
Sneddon |
Arresting Movement
|
Hatcher
|
Impasse
|
Sorrell |
Impasse, Barriers,
Obstacles |
Heyboer
|
Cold Feet
|
Stackhouse |
Recovery, Someone
Rests the Feet
|
Hoefler
|
The Blockade
|
Stein |
Obstruction |
Huang, Alfred
|
Hardship
|
Sterling |
Obstruction |
Huang, Kerson
|
Admonishment
|
Sung |
Difficulty |
Javary
|
Overcoming What
Causes Obstruction
|
Toropov |
Barriers
|
Jou
|
Limping
|
Walker, Barbara |
Trouble, Obstacles,
Difficulty
|
Judge
|
Obstruction
|
Wallace |
Encumbrance
|
Karcher
|
Limping,
Difficulties
|
Wei, Henry |
Difficulty
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Obstacle
|
West |
Obstruction
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Obstruction |
Whincup |
Stumbling
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Halting,
Hesitating, Obstacles or Obstructions
|
Wilhelm |
Obstruction
|
Kunst |
Hobble, Stumble
|
Wing |
Obstacles
|
Legge
|
Difficulties,
Incompetency
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Difficulty
|
Leichtman
|
Hurdles, Barriers,
Inhibitions
|
Wu, Yi |
Obstruction
|
Liu, Da
|
Obstruction |
Wu Wei |
Dangerous Adversity
|
Lynn
|
Adversity
|
Wu Weifarer |
Difficulty
|
Machovec
|
Overcoming
Obstacles
|
Young |
Obstacles
|
Market
|
Dealing with
Difficulties
|
Yu, Titus |
Stumbling Blocks
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Obstruction |
|
|
McCarver
|
Obstruction |
十翼 Shi Yi |
難 Nan2,
Difficulty, Hardship, Problem
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
39.M, Key Words
Impediment, delay, detour, complication,
inconvenience, drawback, immobility
Hindrance, holdup, barrier, obstruction, obstacle,
interruption, discouragement
Discontent, stationary period; convoluted route,
reorientation; options narrowing
A closed mountain pass, waiting out the storm;
lowering expectations and goals
Redefine goals for achievability; detoured but not
deterred; ability to compensate
Knowing when to stop, consolidate progress to
date, rethink directions and plans
39.G, From the
Glossary
Jian3 (a,
an, the) impasse, obstacle, impediment,
drawback, setback, obstruction,
difficulty,
misfortune, fault, holdup, detour, limp,
complication, handicap; (to) go
lame, limp,
walk lame, stumble (s, ed ing); (to be) halting,
hobbled, proud, arro-
gant, impassable,
obstructed, complicated, set back, held up,
detained, deterred,
interrupted; defective
Notes:
The word Impediments works best in integrating
the various "foot problem" meanings of Jian.
Interestingly, the word "scruple" was a pebble
in the shoe, preventing one from going forward.
My word Impasse means unable able to cross the
pass, and this is from the Bagua configuration
of Water over the Mountain. A key observation
here is that the Impasse is not permanent. The
big problem here is one's own sense of urgency.
If this can be set aside, then sideways, at
least for a time, is a perfectly viable
direction. One might even find the festive
comanionship of others, even that of a sage, off
in that new sideways direction. It is suggested
that the capacity for such acceptance might be a
function of one's maturity.
|
|
40
解 Jiě
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Removing Obstacles
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Liberation
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #30 |
Balkin |
Deliverance |
Meyer |
Letting
Loose
|
Barrett
|
Release
|
Needham |
Disaggregation,
Liberation
|
Blofeld
|
Release
|
Ni |
Dissolution of the
Problem
|
Bonnershaw
|
Letting Go
|
Palmer |
Let Loose
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Removing Obstacles
|
Pattee |
Deliverance |
Chang
|
Relief
|
Peden |
Opportunity
|
Chu
|
Deliverance,
Release, Clarification |
Perrottet |
Relief
|
Chung Wu
|
Relief
|
Powell |
Deliverance |
Clark
|
Loosening
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Aloneness ?
|
Cleary |
Solution,
Liberation
|
Reifler |
Release
|
Coates
|
A Time of
Deliverance
|
Richmond |
Release from
Indecision
|
Collins
|
Liberation
|
Richter |
Release
|
Crouch
|
Untied
|
Riseman |
Liberation
|
Damian-Knight
|
Deliverance |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Loosening,
Deliverance
|
Dening
|
Release from
Obstruction
|
Rutt |
Unloosing
|
Dhiegh
|
Deliverance,
Unloose, Fall Off |
Seabrook |
Relief
|
Douglas
|
Escape
|
Secter |
Liberation,
Deliverance, Disentangled |
Feng
|
Relief, ReLease
[sic]
|
Shaughnessy |
Untangled
|
Fu Youde |
Release
|
Shchutskii |
Solution
|
Graeme
|
Deliverance,
Relief, Bindings Untied
|
Siu |
Eliminating
Obstacles
|
Hacker
|
Obstruction Removed
|
Sneddon |
Removing Obstacles
|
Hatcher
|
Release
|
Sorrell |
Relief, Escape,
Freedom |
Heyboer
|
Take the Horns
|
Stackhouse |
Solving a Problem,
Untangling
|
Hoefler
|
The Liberation
|
Stein |
Release
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Relief
|
Sterling |
Liberation
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Letting Loose
|
Sung |
Loosening
|
Javary
|
Releasing
|
Toropov |
Release
|
Jou
|
Loosening
|
Walker, Barbara |
Release
|
Judge
|
Liberation
|
Wallace |
Liberation
|
Karcher
|
Loosening,
Deliverance
|
Wei, Henry |
Liberation
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Deliverance
|
West |
Escape
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Release
|
Whincup |
Getting Free
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Releasing,
Liberation
|
Wilhelm |
Deliverance
|
Kunst |
Untie, Loosen
|
Wing |
Liberation
|
Legge
|
Loosing,
Unravelling a Complication
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Loosen, Solution
|
Leichtman
|
Recreation,
Deliverance |
Wu, Yi |
Deliverance |
Liu, Da
|
Liberation
|
Wu Wei |
Abatement of Danger
|
Lynn
|
Release
|
Wu Weifarer |
Release
|
Machovec
|
Liberation |
Young |
Solution
|
Market
|
Clearing the Air
|
Yu, Titus |
Cutting Through
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Liberation
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Loosening |
十翼 Shi Yi |
赦過 She4 Guo4,
Forgiving Excesses
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
40.M, Key Words
Delivery, deliverance, discharge, follow through,
liberation, relief, emancipation
Loosen, disentangle, extricate, forgive, pardon,
allow, let go, free, release, slacken
Explain, clarify, synthesize, reconcile, temper,
transcend, alleviate, dissolve, undo
Release arrows; casting (3rd step of a spell:
tense, aim, release); be done, move on
Begin anew; clean break with past, absolve;
culmination, sublimation; untie knots
Both forgiveness and permission; options opening;
redemption, not salvation (#59)
40.G, From the
Glossary
Jie3 (to)
release, relieve, discharge, let go (of),
dispel, allay, alleviate, dismiss,
loosen,
untie, relax, undo, untangle, liberate, free,
remove, temper, mitigate,
deliver, separate,
open up, break up, disperse, interpret, solve,
dissolve, resolve,
settle, explain, understand,
comprehend, get rid of, be free of, divide; cut
or pull
open, apart (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
solution(s), liberty, freedom, relief,
deliverance,
release, delivery, liberation,
disaggregation, disintegration; The character
refers to
a knot horn, or a little piece of
antler tip that people used to carry around on
their
belts to disentangle ropes and untie
knots. Like the nautical tool called a fid.
Note:
The Xu Gua and Za Gua gloss Jie3 as Huan3,
Letting Go, Loosening, Slackening, Release. The
radical in the character Jie3 is "Horn." This is
derived from a "knot horn," a tip of antler or
horn that was worn at the waist and used
frequently in those days in the untying of
knots. Release then (or forgiveness) is the
untying of the knots that we have got ourselves
into.
|
|
41
損
Sǔn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Decrease
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Reduction
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #12 |
Balkin |
Decrease |
Meyer |
Simplify
|
Barrett
|
Decreasing
|
Needham |
Diminution
|
Blofeld
|
Loss, Reduction
|
Ni |
Decrease, Sacrifice
|
Bonnershaw
|
Dwindling
|
Palmer |
Injured
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Cutting Down
|
Pattee |
Decrease |
Chang
|
Loss
|
Peden |
Reduction
|
Chu
|
Decrease, Loss |
Perrottet |
Decrease
|
Chung Wu
|
Loss
|
Powell |
Decrease |
Clark
|
Decrease
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Contraction
|
Cleary |
Reduction
|
Reifler |
Decrease |
Coates
|
Decreased
Resources, Holding Back
|
Richmond |
Failure of
Expectation
|
Collins
|
Decrease |
Richter |
Decrease
|
Crouch
|
Decrease
|
Riseman |
Decrease |
Damian-Knight
|
Decrease, Poverty,
Taxation |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Diminishing
|
Dening
|
Decrease
|
Rutt |
Diminishing
|
Dhiegh
|
Decrease, To Wound,
Spoil, Disadvantage |
Seabrook |
Efficiency
|
Douglas
|
Decrease |
Secter |
Decrease,
Reduction, Diminished |
Feng
|
Decrease, Sacrifice
|
Shaughnessy |
Decrease
|
Fu Youde |
Loss
|
Shchutskii |
Decrease |
Graeme
|
Decrease,
Diminishing, Making an Offering
|
Siu |
Diminution of
Excesses
|
Hacker
|
Decrease |
Sneddon |
Decrease |
Hatcher
|
Decreasing
|
Sorrell |
Letting Go,
Cleaning Out, Simple |
Heyboer
|
The Empty Cauldron
|
Stackhouse |
Chastisement,
Correction, Denial of Support
|
Hoefler
|
Reduction
|
Stein |
Restraint
(Lessening)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Decreasing
|
Sterling |
Decrease
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Decrease |
Sung |
Lessening
|
Javary
|
Settling
|
Toropov |
Reduction
|
Jou
|
Decrease
|
Walker, Barbara |
Decline, Loss,
Reduction
|
Judge
|
Deficiency
|
Wallace |
Decrease
|
Karcher
|
Diminishing
|
Wei, Henry |
Decrease |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Reduction
|
West |
Decrease
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Decrease
|
Whincup |
Reduction
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Reduction,
Decrease, Decline
|
Wilhelm |
Decrease
|
Kunst |
Decrease |
Wing |
Decline
|
Legge
|
Diminution,
Contributing from one's Own
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Decrease,
Diminishing |
Leichtman
|
Loss, Low Ebb
|
Wu, Yi |
Decrease
|
Liu, Da
|
Decrease |
Wu Wei |
Decrease
|
Lynn
|
Diminution
|
Wu Weifarer |
Decreasing
|
Machovec
|
Selflessness ?
|
Young |
Decrease |
Market
|
Decrease and
Increase |
Yu, Titus |
Taking Away
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Decrease |
|
|
McCarver
|
Decrease |
十翼 Shi Yi |
盈 Ying2, (The
Behavior of) Surplus
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
41.M, Key Words
Diminish; to reduce, economize, forego;
contraction, concentration, conservation
Sacrificing, offering up; dues, service,
subtraction, trying to lose only inessentials
Trimming excesses, plugging leaks, lowering
expectations, doing more with less
To make the most, make do; distill, condense,
concentrate as forms of enrichment
Enrich, make less dilute, keep the good stuff;
building resilience; losing negatives
Extenuation, distraction, depreciation, demands on
resources, use, wear and tear
41.G, From the
Glossary
Sun3
(to) belittle, chastise, cut (back), criticize,
cut down to size, damage, harm,
injure,
decrease, destroy, diminish, dwindle, economize,
lessen, lose, reduce, trim,
spoil, subtract,
weaken, wound (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
concentration, contraction,
decrease,
detriment, diminution, loss, reduction; (to be)
concentrated, contracted,
decreased (by),
diminished, lessened, reduced, taken from,
weakened; detrimen-
tal, disadvantageous
Notes:
The Zhouyi authors play with the notions of
Decrease and Increase in a manner that
foreshadows Laozi. The two are inextricably
interrelated, in ways that seem almost mystical.
A time of Decreasing is an opportunity to
practice Economy, in the good old sense of the
word, before it came to mean conspicuous
consumption, profligate waste and planned
obsolescence. The ability to reassess what we
really need and want, even when learned
involuntarily, is a skill that creates personal
wealth. Gratitiude of course is an important key
here, and the Zhouyi even recommends such a
"sacrifice."
|
|
42
益 Yì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Increase
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Expansion
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #64 |
Balkin |
Increase |
Meyer |
Gain
|
Barrett
|
Increasing
|
Needham |
Addition, Increase
|
Blofeld
|
Gain
|
Ni |
Increase, Benefit |
Bonnershaw
|
Gain
|
Palmer |
Increase |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Increase
|
Pattee |
Increase |
Chang
|
Gratitude
|
Peden |
Increase |
Chu
|
Increase, Gain |
Perrottet |
Increase |
Chung Wu
|
Gain
|
Powell |
Increase |
Clark
|
Increase
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Growth
|
Cleary |
Increase |
Reifler |
Increase |
Coates
|
Increased
Dedication
|
Richmond |
Strength to
Accomplish Challenges
|
Collins
|
Increase |
Richter |
Increase
|
Crouch
|
Increase
|
Riseman |
Increase |
Damian-Knight
|
Increase, Spiritual
& Material Wealth |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Augmenting
|
Dening
|
Increase
|
Rutt |
Enriching
|
Dhiegh
|
Increase, Benefit,
Advantage, Profit |
Seabrook |
Increase
|
Douglas
|
Increase |
Secter |
Increase,
Prospering, Enhanced |
Feng
|
Increase, Blessing
|
Shaughnessy |
Increase
|
Fu Youde |
Gain
|
Shchutskii |
Increase |
Graeme
|
Increase, Receiving
Blessings
|
Siu |
Help from Above
|
Hacker
|
Increase |
Sneddon |
Increase |
Hatcher
|
Increasing
|
Sorrell |
Benefit, Increase,
Expansion |
Heyboer
|
The Bowl of the
Raingod
|
Stackhouse |
Spontaneous
Overflowing
|
Hoefler
|
Multiplication
|
Stein |
Resolution
(Progress) ??
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Increasing
|
Sterling |
Increase |
Huang, Kerson
|
Increase |
Sung |
Addition
|
Javary
|
Intensifying
|
Toropov |
Increase |
Jou
|
Increase
|
Walker, Barbara |
Gain, Benefit
|
Judge
|
Assistance
|
Wallace |
Increase
|
Karcher
|
Augmenting
|
Wei, Henry |
Increase |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Augmentation
|
West |
Increase
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Increase |
Whincup |
Increase |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Increase, Benefit |
Wilhelm |
Increase
|
Kunst |
Increase |
Wing |
Benefit
|
Legge
|
Adding To, Gifts
Received
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Increase, Add |
Leichtman
|
Gain, Enrichment
|
Wu, Yi |
Increase
|
Liu, Da
|
Increase |
Wu Wei |
Gain
|
Lynn
|
Increase
|
Wu Weifarer |
Increasing
|
Machovec
|
Inspiration
|
Young |
Increase |
Market
|
The Harvest
|
Yu, Titus |
Giving To
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Increase |
|
|
McCarver
|
Increase |
十翼 Shi Yi |
衰始 Shuai1 Shi3,
Decline's Beginning
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
42.M, Key Words
Extension, diversification, broadening, advantage,
empowerment; gain, increase
Enrichment, smiling fortune; enhancements,
benefits, gifts, windfalls, gleanings
New access, input, options, choices, alternatives;
learning, accepting, growing
Receiving generously, taking well, using the
gifts, appreciation, blessings to count
Positional advantage, leverage, purchase; to
glean, profit, augment; faring well
Gain also as an increase in sensitivity to signal
strength, amplification, expansion
42.G, From the
Glossary
Yi4
(to) add, advance, augment, benefit, enrich,
expand, fill (up), further, gain,
give, grant,
grow, increase (by), progress, promote, profit,
reinforce, replenish,
restore, strengthen (to)
(s, ed, ing); (a, the) addition, advantage,
augmentation,
benefit, enrichment, expansion,
gain, gift, grant (of), surplus, overflow,
increase,
profit, value; (to be) beneficial,
gainful, profitable, increased, advantageous,
aug-
mented, progressive, restorative, useful;
expansive, rich; additionally, more, all
the
more, expansively, further, increasingly; more
and more
Note:
By extension of the statement in Tuan Zhuan 41,
Yi4 as Increase can be described as Xu1 (The
Behavior of) Lack or Want. It is the action of
Nature abhorring a vacuum. Increase or
Increasing is good enough as a Gua Ming, but the
word Gain has an interesting additional meaning
that is worthy of note: the sense used in signal
gain. It is possible to increase the amount or
rate of input simply by becoming more open or
sensitized. It does not need to be increased at
the supply, broadcasting or donor end of the
transaction. This is analogous to appreciation,
making a thing more valuable simply by valuing
it more, or by putting it to a more valuable
use.
|
|
43
夬 Guài
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Removing Corruption
(18)
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Jue2, Parting
Words, Secret, Revelation
|
Albertson
|
Outburst
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
訣 #42, Resolution,
pron. Guai4
|
Balkin |
Resolution |
Meyer |
Decisive
Action
|
Barrett
|
Deciding
|
Needham |
Decisive
Breakthrough, Eruption |
Blofeld
|
Resolution
|
Ni |
Resolution
|
Bonnershaw
|
Decisiveness
|
Palmer |
New Outcome
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Decisive
|
Pattee |
Resolution |
Chang
|
Rebellion
|
Peden |
Self-Discipline,
Determination
|
Chu
|
Resolution, Removal
|
Perrottet |
Breakthrough
|
Chung Wu
|
Eradication
|
Powell |
Resolution |
Clark
|
Determination
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Insight
|
Cleary |
Decision,
Decisiveness, Parting
|
Reifler |
Breakthrough |
Coates
|
The Elimination of
Opposing Elements
|
Richmond |
A Peak of
Accumulation
|
Collins
|
Breakthrough
|
Richter |
Striding Forward
|
Crouch
|
Dredging
|
Riseman |
Determination
|
Damian-Knight
|
Breakthrough,
Determination |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Resolution, Parting
|
Dening
|
Determination
|
Rutt |
Skipping
|
Dhiegh
|
Breakthrough,
Resolution |
Seabrook |
Resolve
|
Douglas
|
Renewed Advance
|
Secter |
Resolute, Surmount,
Steadfast
|
Feng
|
Decisive,
Over-whelming
|
Shaughnessy |
Resolution
|
Fu Youde |
Resolution
|
Shchutskii |
Going Out
|
Graeme
|
Displacing,
Severance, Eliminating Hesitation
|
Siu |
Removing Corruption
|
Hacker
|
Decisive
|
Sneddon |
Removing Corruption
|
Hatcher
|
Decisiveness
|
Sorrell |
Determination,
Revelation, Breakthrough |
Heyboer
|
The Speaking Staff
|
Stackhouse |
Decisive Moment,
Something Broken
|
Hoefler
|
The Breakthrough |
Stein |
Letting Go
(Gaining)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Eliminating
|
Sterling |
To Move Forward
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Stride
|
Sung |
Decision
|
Javary
|
Bursting
|
Toropov |
Displacing
|
Jou
|
Decision
|
Walker, Barbara |
Resolution
|
Judge
|
Resolution
|
Wallace |
Resolution
|
Karcher
|
Deciding,
Resolution, Parting
|
Wei, Henry |
Removal
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Resolution
|
West |
Breakthrough
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Resoluteness
|
Whincup |
Flight
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Resolute
|
Wilhelm |
Break-through
(Resoluteness)
|
Kunst |
Split, Lickety
Split
|
Wing |
Resolution
|
Legge
|
Resolute Removal,
Determination
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Decision, Cut Off,
Uproot, Certain, Decide
|
Leichtman
|
Firm Resolve,
Determination
|
Wu, Yi |
Resolution
|
Liu, Da
|
Determination
|
Wu Wei |
Overthrow of Evil
|
Lynn
|
Resolution
|
Wu Weifarer |
Breakthrough
|
Machovec
|
Remain Steadfast
|
Young |
Breakthrough |
Market
|
Determination
|
Yu, Titus |
Incisive
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Resolution
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Break-through |
十翼 Shi Yi |
決 Jue2, Decide,
Open Up, Break Through
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
43.M, Key Words
Satiety, surfeit, having enough, finality, giving
notice, parting verdicts and words
Break off, conclude, uproot, expel, purge,
express, denounce, renounce, condemn
Discharge, remove corruption, vent, clean house,
make a clean breast, outpouring
Resolution, resolve, determination, commitment,
single-mindedness, obsession
Inclination to exaggeration, hyperbole,
protesting too much; over the top; unload
Indictment, disclosure, conviction, exposé,
diagnostic; decisiveness, breakthrough
43.G, From the
Glossary
Guai4 (to
be) decisive, resolute, certain, committed,
resolved, decided, serious,
determined; (to)
determine, decide, resolve, commit (to), indict,
execute, cut off,
censure, displace, purge,
uproot, eradicate, divide, part ways, make a
breach (s,
ed, ing); (a, the) disclosure,
resolution, decision (to), decisiveness,
satiety; cer-
tainly, seriously, decisively,
resolutely
Notes:
As with many of the Gua with prominent single
lines, the Gua Xiang, or Hexagram Shape,
contributes much to the core meaning of 43. It
was likely seen as portraying an excess of the
sort of affect that can move one to actions that
are later regretted, indignity perhaps,
hostility, anger, or simply obsession. One may
be about to blow one's top, or maybe go over the
top in a response. The various texts suggest a
calmer, more rational and probably more
effective approach: state the problem clearly,
study its extents and ramifications, and begin
to clarify the solutions. Resolution can be a
good Gua Ming here. It has a set of meanings
that describe great determination or firmness,
but it also has the meanings used in optics to
refer to the detail or sharpness of an image
which returns us to the rational study of the
problem, so that good choices are made, so that
one's decisiveness isn't bound to a bad
decision. Part of this is not being overfull of
oneself. Thus the Da Xiang recommends spreading
pieces of the problem around and sharing the
solution. Maybe let the courts handle it.
|
|
44
姤 Gòu
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Encountering
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Gou3, Bitch, Dog,
A Term of Contempt
|
Albertson
|
Confrontation
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
狗 #8, Meeting
(Reverts to Rec'd Text)
|
Balkin |
Encounter |
Meyer |
Getting
Together
|
Barrett
|
Coupling
|
Needham |
Reaction, Fusion
|
Blofeld
|
Contact, Meeting,
Sexual Intercourse
|
Ni |
Encounter, Meeting
Together
|
Bonnershaw
|
Intercourse
|
Palmer |
To Meet
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Encountering
|
Pattee |
Encountering
|
Chang
|
Meeting and Making
Friends
|
Peden |
Meeting
|
Chu
|
Contact,
Relationships
|
Perrottet |
Concession
|
Chung Wu
|
Rendezvous
|
Powell |
Coming Together |
Clark
|
Attraction
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Alertness
|
Cleary |
Meeting
|
Reifler |
Temptation
|
Coates
|
A Dark Element
Re-enters Surreptitiously
|
Richmond |
Adapting to
Circumstances
|
Collins
|
Meeting Place
|
Richter |
A Match
|
Crouch
|
Locking
|
Riseman |
Tempting Encounter
|
Damian-Knight
|
Coming to Meet |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Welcoming, Coupling
|
Dening
|
A Meeting of
Opposites
|
Rutt |
Locking
|
Dhiegh
|
Coming to Meet,
Confrontation |
Seabrook |
Temptation
|
Douglas
|
Sudden Encounters
|
Secter |
Insinuating,
Clandestine, Calculating
|
Feng
|
Chance Encounter,
Lady Luck
|
Shaughnessy |
To Meet
|
Fu Youde |
Meeting
|
Shchutskii |
Contraposition
|
Graeme
|
C. to Meet,
Coupling, Significant Encounter
|
Siu |
Infiltration by
Inferior Men
|
Hacker
|
Meeting, Subjugated
|
Sneddon |
Encountering
|
Hatcher
|
Dissipation
|
Sorrell |
Intrusions,
Encounter, Undetermining |
Heyboer
|
Heir
|
Stackhouse |
Intercourse,
Copulate, Not for Marriage
|
Hoefler
|
The Meeting
|
Stein |
Coming to Meet
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Encountering
|
Sterling |
Complacency
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Rendezvous
|
Sung |
Meeting
|
Javary
|
Welcoming the Yin
|
Toropov |
Encountering
|
Jou
|
Meeting
|
Walker, Barbara |
Temptation,
Contact, Sexual Meeting
|
Judge
|
Encounter
|
Wallace |
Encountering
|
Karcher
|
Coupling, Welcoming
|
Wei, Henry |
Contact
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Approach of the
Malleable
|
West |
Meeting
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Contact
|
Whincup |
Subjugated
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Meeting,
Magnetizing
|
Wilhelm |
Coming to Meet
|
Kunst |
Mating, Match
|
Wing |
Temptation
|
Legge
|
Insinuation,
Resisting Encroachment
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Pair
|
Leichtman
|
Hypocrisy,
Impulsiveness
|
Wu, Yi |
Meeting
|
Liu, Da
|
Encountering
|
Wu Wei |
Return of the Dark
Force
|
Lynn
|
Encounter
|
Wu Weifarer |
Coupling
|
Machovec
|
Negative Influences
|
Young |
Meeting of
Opposites
|
Market
|
Encroachment
|
Yu, Titus |
The Matriarch
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Temptation
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Meeting |
十翼 Shi Yi |
遇 Yu4, Chance
Encounter, Meeting
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
44.M, Key Words
Interference, extenuation, attenuation,
dissipation, distraction, complication, chaos
Chance encounter, casual relation, affair, fling,
indiscretion, seduction, temptation
Entropy, randomness, undermining influence;
squandering or adulterating order
Mental promiscuity; coincidences taken too
seriously as omens; loss of judgment
Deferring, prioritizing, restraining self,
abstaining; waiting for a meaningful affair
Interposition, insinuation, persuasiveness;
happening upon, accidental rendezvous
44.G, From the
Glossary
Gou4 (to)
couple, pair, connect, mate, copulate, meet
(with), pair (up) with, come
in(to) contact
with, come in(to) conflict with, encounter (s,
ed, ing); (a, the)
(chance) encounter,
(temporary) affair, (ad hoc) coalition;
temptation, seduction,
dissipation
Notes:
As fun as the
symbolism of the temptress or seductress may be,
this Gua really isn't (necessarily) about the
sexes or their battles. Nor is it about
empowered or liberated women, even though women
who may fancy themeselves as such will almost
invariably seize upon this notion. This is just
a metaphor that the authors used. It's about the
good fight against Dissipation or Entropy, which
describes both life and intelligence. Nothing is
more distracting to higher purpose than a sudden
attraction to the opposite sex. The symbolism
was irresistable. The gist of this is advising
resistance to, or restraint against, an
encounter or influence that threatens to
undermine our higher purposes in an untimely
fashion. There may also be cases (as in two of
the lines) where this is not all that untimely
and in fact might really be a beneficial
distraction from excessive concentration. This
is especially true where an unexpected sexual
encounter might contribute much to one's mental
health. Many or most of our modern day readers
seize upon the Tuan's phrase Nu Zhuang, "woman
of/with power," and can see no further than an
apparent affirmation of women's liberation. They
are blinded to the very next line of the text.
In fact, a women moving under her own power
would be written Zhuang Nu, a powerful woman. A
Nu Zhuang, on the other hand, is given the
power: to seduce, dissipate, or undo the higher
order.
|
|
45
萃 Cuì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Gathering Together
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Zu2, All Together,
Group, Community
|
Albertson
|
Congregating
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
卒 #43, Finished, To
End
|
Balkin |
Gathering Together
|
Meyer |
Pulling
Together
|
Barrett
|
Gathering
|
Needham |
Condensation,
Conglomeration
|
Blofeld
|
Gathering Together,
Assembling |
Ni |
Congregation,
Gathering the Essence
|
Bonnershaw
|
Association
|
Palmer |
To Collect
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Gathering Together
|
Pattee |
Gathering Together
|
Chang
|
Economics
|
Peden |
Gathering |
Chu
|
Gathering Together,
Assembling |
Perrottet |
Gathering |
Chung Wu
|
Congregation
|
Powell |
Congregation
|
Clark
|
Gathering
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Gatherer
|
Cleary |
Gathering |
Reifler |
Accord (08)
|
Coates
|
People Coming
Together
|
Richmond |
Out of Gestation ?
|
Collins
|
Uniting Together |
Richter |
Gathering
|
Crouch
|
Assembling
|
Riseman |
In Accord (08)
|
Damian-Knight
|
Gathering Together,
The Group |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Clustering
|
Dening
|
Gathering Together
|
Rutt |
Together
|
Dhiegh
|
Gathering Together,
Massing, Congregate |
Seabrook |
Coming Together
|
Douglas
|
Collecting Together
|
Secter |
Assemble, Planning,
A Large Convening
|
Feng
|
Union, Deep Feeling
|
Shaughnessy |
To Bunch Together
|
Fu Youde |
Assembling
|
Shchutskii |
Reunion
|
Graeme
|
Gathering Together
|
Siu |
Unity (08)
|
Hacker
|
Gathering Together
|
Sneddon |
Gathering Together
|
Hatcher
|
Collectedness
|
Sorrell |
Joining In,
Gathering, Integration |
Heyboer
|
Gathering
|
Stackhouse |
Coming Together,
Bundles of Grass
|
Hoefler
|
The Collection
|
Stein |
Gathering Together
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Bringing Together
|
Sterling |
Reunion
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Illness
|
Sung |
Gathering Into One
|
Javary
|
Crowding
|
Toropov |
Gathering |
Jou
|
Gathering
|
Walker, Barbara |
Assembling,
Gathering
|
Judge
|
Congregation
|
Wallace |
Gathering
|
Karcher
|
Clustering
|
Wei, Henry |
Assembly
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Gathering
|
West |
Assembly
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Gathering
|
Whincup |
Garhering Around
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Gathering,
Assembling
|
Wilhelm |
Gathering Together
(Massing) |
Kunst |
Bunched, Bunch
|
Wing |
Assembling
|
Legge
|
Collecting Together
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Gather Together
|
Leichtman
|
Planning, Harmony
|
Wu, Yi |
Gathering Together
|
Liu, Da
|
Gathering
|
Wu Wei |
Gathering Together,
Joining |
Lynn
|
Gathering
|
Wu Weifarer |
Gathering
|
Machovec
|
Unifying Spirit
|
Young |
Reunion
|
Market
|
The Happy Union
|
Yu, Titus |
Congregating for
the Harvest
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Gathering
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Gathering Together
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
聚 Ju4,
Congregation, Assembly, Collection
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
45.M, Key Words
Gather together, assemble, collect, congregate,
consolidate, concentrate, convene
Banking, shoring up, saving, pooling, collective
strength, convocation, assembly
Safe numbers; reserve, reservoir, contingency
fund, sanctuary from insecurities
Trusting, settling doubts; risk readiness,
insurance, assurance, caching provisions
Confidence, composure, self-possession, integrity,
security, sang froid, aplomb
Pulling it / yourself together; having / holding
it together; comportment, dignity
45.G, From the
Glossary
Cui4 (to)
gather, assemble, unite, collect, bring
together, pull together, bundle,
cluster,
convene, integrate, concentrate (s, ed, ing);
(a, the) gathering, assembly,
assemblage,
congregation, collection, crowd; security,
unification, collectedness,
self-possession,
confidence, assurance, composure, reintegration,
integrity, concentration; bunch, bundle,
cluster, multitude of grasses; (to be) thick,
close-set,
dense; “pulling it together,”
“holding it together,” “having it together”
Note:
This Gua Ming should make clear the distinction
between 45 and 08. Both have Water over the
Earth. The difference is that 45 is contained on
all sides, and its banks, or embankments, or
dams, are constructed for a purpose and require
maintenance. The image of a bank is appropriate
as the Gua texts refer to setting things aside,
making preparations for the unknown, insuring
future outcomes. The character Cui may depict
bundled sheafs of harvested grain. There exists
a common, archetypal image of a bundle of arrows
or sticks having properties of strength and
durability that single arrows or sticks do not.
This is often used as a symbol of the power of
unity and solidarity. It is also known as the
Fasces, an important symbol to the Roman Empire
and to Nazi Germany. Note implied caution.
Congregations, especially those of religious
institutions, will Gather Together for security
and comfort in solidarity. The point may be in
the illusion of "having it all together" or
simply collecting one's wits, banked against the
vagaries of fortune and other scary unknowns.
|
|
46
升 Shēng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Ascending
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Deng1, To Rise,
Mount, Step Up, Commence
|
Albertson
|
Sprouting (3)
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
登 #40, Ascending
|
Balkin |
Ascending |
Meyer |
Promotion
|
Barrett
|
Pushing Upward
|
Needham |
Ascent
|
Blofeld
|
Ascending,
Promotion |
Ni |
Rising
|
Bonnershaw
|
Ambition
|
Palmer |
Rising Up
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Ascending
|
Pattee |
Pushing Upward |
Chang
|
Promotion
|
Peden |
Ascension
|
Chu
|
Rising, Ascending
|
Perrottet |
Striving Upwards
|
Chung Wu
|
Ascension
|
Powell |
Moving Upward
|
Clark
|
Ascending
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Determination
|
Cleary |
Rising
|
Reifler |
Pushing Upward |
Coates
|
Unobstructed Upward
Movement
|
Richmond |
New Growth out of
Maturity
|
Collins
|
Ascending
|
Richter |
Ascending
|
Crouch
|
Climbing
|
Riseman |
Pushing Upward |
Damian-Knight
|
Pushing Upward, The
Beginnings of Ascent
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Ascending
|
Dening
|
Pushing Upward
|
Rutt |
Going Up
|
Dhiegh
|
To Ascend, Promote,
Advance
|
Seabrook |
Effort
|
Douglas
|
Ascending |
Secter |
Striving, Ambition,
Orchestrated
|
Feng
|
Rising Up
|
Shaughnessy |
To Ascend
|
Fu Youde |
Ascending
|
Shchutskii |
Ascent
|
Graeme
|
Pushing Upwards,
Ascending |
Siu |
Advancement
|
Hacker
|
Pushing Upward |
Sneddon |
Ascending |
Hatcher
|
Advancement
|
Sorrell |
Arising, Growth,
Moving Up |
Heyboer
|
Step by Step
|
Stackhouse |
Measure, Advancing
by Graduated Measures
|
Hoefler
|
The Ascent
|
Stein |
Tree of Life
(Reaching)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Growing Upward
|
Sterling |
To Push Upward |
Huang, Kerson
|
Ascendance |
Sung |
Rising, Advancing
|
Javary
|
Slowly Taking Root
|
Toropov |
Pushing Upward |
Jou
|
Ascending
|
Walker, Barbara |
Ascending,
Advancement
|
Judge
|
Advancement
|
Wallace |
Ascending |
Karcher
|
Ascending |
Wei, Henry |
Ascension |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Growth
|
West |
Rising
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Rising
|
Whincup |
Rising
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Ascending,
Advancing, Growing Upward
|
Wilhelm |
Pushing Upward |
Kunst |
Climb, Rise
|
Wing |
Advancement
|
Legge
|
Advancing and
Ascending
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Ascend
|
Leichtman
|
Overnight Success,
Steady Progress (53)
|
Wu, Yi |
Ascending
|
Liu, Da
|
Ascending |
Wu Wei |
Advance
|
Lynn
|
Climbing
|
Wu Weifarer |
Ascending
|
Machovec
|
Onward and Upward
|
Young |
Ascending |
Market
|
Building Up Slowly
|
Yu, Titus |
Ascending |
Marshall, Chris
|
Growth
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Rising and
Advancing
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
上 Shang4, To
Climb; 積 Ji1, To Accumulate
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
46.M, Key Words
Ascend, climb, mount, improve, upgrade; to rise
above, build up, make up, add up
Ambition, boldness, opportunism, preferment,
taking of advantages, surmounting
Developed proficiency, skill, mastery, competence,
training, elevation, graduation
Practice, education, edification; accretion,
assimilation, constitution, construction
Self-betterment, improvement, personal growth
& bests; raising / rising standards
Elevate, promote, overcome; graduated task; paced
efforts, measuring of progress
46.G, From the
Glossary
Sheng1 (to)
advance (on, upon), promote, ascend, climb,
arise, rise up, rise above,
move upward, go up,
step up, improve, mount, lift up, accumulate,
save; issue
forth (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
advance, advancement, promotion, improvement,
ascent,
climb, step, increment (s); a measure
of capacity; [to invest in potential energy]
Notes:
The word Sheng might have started out as a
measure of volume capacity for produce and
grain. As such it would have been tallied in
integers and so it eventually came to refer to
other discrete increments, such as stair steps.
One more step brings us to the meaning of
Climbing or Ascending, with steps being the
measure of our Advancement. The core meaning of
Gua 46 isn't very mysterious. But there is also
an element of boldness in ascending or stepping
up, and here the Zhouyi advises us to face
South, the direction the King faces when giving
commands. Also present is the the notion that
advancement is something earned. Further,
increases in elevation mean the acquistion of
potential energy that can be spent in various
ways like currency. This is a good Gua for the
educational process, or otherwise becoming
increasingly proficient in a skill.
|
|
47
困 Kùn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Oppression
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Emptiness
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #45 |
Balkin |
Oppression |
Meyer |
Feeling
Trapped
|
Barrett
|
Confined
|
Needham |
Enclosure,
Exhaustion
|
Blofeld
|
Adversity,
Weariness
|
Ni |
Beseiged,
Entrapped, Exhausted
|
Bonnershaw
|
Limitation
|
Palmer |
To Surround and
Wear Out
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
In Plight
|
Pattee |
Oppression |
Chang
|
Poverty
|
Peden |
Exhaustion |
Chu
|
Adversity,
Exhaustion
|
Perrottet |
Exhaustion |
Chung Wu
|
Hardship
|
Powell |
Exhaustion
|
Clark
|
Imprisonment
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Realizing ?
|
Cleary |
Exhaustion |
Reifler |
Repression
|
Coates
|
A Time of Adversity
|
Richmond |
Exhaustion of
Activity
|
Collins
|
Oppression |
Richter |
Oppression
|
Crouch
|
Tangled
|
Riseman |
Oppression |
Damian-Knight
|
Oppression,
Exhaustion |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Confining,
Oppressed
|
Dening
|
Being Restricted
|
Rutt |
Beset √
|
Dhiegh
|
Oppression,
Exhaustion, Adverse, Surrounded |
Seabrook |
Oppression
|
Douglas
|
Exhausting
Restriction
|
Secter |
Adversity,
Disaster, Distress
|
Feng
|
Stagnant (12)
|
Shaughnessy |
Entangled
|
Fu Youde |
Adversity
|
Shchutskii |
Exhaustion
|
Graeme
|
Oppression,
Exhaustion, Restriction
|
Siu |
Adversity
|
Hacker
|
Burdened, Exhausted
|
Sneddon |
Oppression |
Hatcher
|
Exhaustion
|
Sorrell |
Depleted, Burnt
Out, Exhausted |
Heyboer
|
Enclosed Tree
|
Stackhouse |
Reaching One's
limit, Hemmed In, Tired
|
Hoefler
|
Distress (28)
|
Stein |
Depletion
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Exhausting
|
Sterling |
Oppression |
Huang, Kerson
|
Trapped
|
Sung |
Repression,
Confinement
|
Javary
|
Getting Through,
Forcing Through
|
Toropov |
Exhaustion |
Jou
|
Oppression
|
Walker, Barbara |
Adversity,
Oppression, Weariness √
|
Judge
|
Adversity
|
Wallace |
Constraint
|
Karcher
|
Confining,
Oppressed
|
Wei, Henry |
Disablement
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Exhaustion
|
West |
Exhaustion
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Exhaustion
|
Whincup |
Burdened
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Exhaustion in
Adversity, Oppression
|
Wilhelm |
Oppression
(Exhaustion) |
Kunst |
Bother, Surround,
Pound
|
Wing |
Adversity
|
Legge
|
Straitened and
Distressed
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Distressed,
Surrounded, Enclosed, Bound
|
Leichtman
|
Reactiveness,
Confusion
|
Wu, Yi |
Besetment
|
Liu, Da
|
Oppression |
Wu Wei |
Oppression
|
Lynn
|
Impasse (39)
|
Wu Weifarer |
Constriction
|
Machovec
|
Out of Darkness
|
Young |
Exhaustion |
Market
|
Adversity
|
Yu, Titus |
Circumscribed
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Oppression
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Oppression |
十翼 Shi Yi |
揜 Yan3, Enclosed;
窮 Qiong2 Exhaustion
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
47.M, Key Words
Surrounded, afflicted, beset, distressed, trapped,
oppressed, cramped, hemmed in
Hard pressed, squeezed; feeling defeated; running
on reserves, vapors and fumes
Victimized, bothered, disheartened, wretched,
depleted, fatigued, weary, used up
Lowest ebbs, dregs, being drained, spent;
futility, pessimism, nihilism, suffering
Depression; using the last ounce, getting the
spirit back, lightening up, enduring
Melancholy, delirium, illusion, despond, swamp gas
visions, wits end, emptiness
47.G, From the
Glossary
Kun4 (a,
the) affliction, oppression, extremity,
distress, exhaustion, entanglement,
fatigue,
anxiety; (to be) distressed, afflicted, beset,
oppressed, surrounded, beaten,
impoverished,
diminished, belabored, bothered, disheartened,
exhausted, fatigued,
tired (out), vexed,
trapped, besieged, surrounded, confined,
entangled, pressured,
constrained, hard
pressed, pinned down, penned in, squeezed,
enclosed, (nearly)
defeated (by, in, with);
extreme; (to) obstruct, distress, exhaust (s,
ed, ing)
Notes:
Exhaustion is probably the best Gua Ming here.
This is the Gua of haunted houses, the spooky
Gua. Nietzche said: "When we are tireed we are
attacked by ideas we conquered long ago." There
is much wallowing and mournful self-indulgence
depicted in the lines, but the advice that runs
throughout the text between the lines is to
lighten up. The language is teasing, and mocking
in a playful way. It uses caricature and parody.
This is also the wordiest of all the Gua, as Gua
58 is the briefest. As Francis Bacon wrote: "The
pencil of the Holy Ghost hath labored more in
describing the afflictions of Job than the
felicities of Solomon."
|
|
48
井 Jǐng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
A Well
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Cistern
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #24 |
Balkin |
The Well |
Meyer |
A
Well
|
Barrett
|
The Well
|
Needham |
Source
|
Blofeld
|
A Well
|
Ni |
Well
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Well
|
Palmer |
The Well |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Well
|
Pattee |
The Well |
Chang
|
Well
|
Peden |
Resources
|
Chu
|
The Well |
Perrottet |
The Well
|
Chung Wu
|
The Well
|
Powell |
The Well |
Clark
|
The Well
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Depth
|
Cleary |
The Well |
Reifler |
The Well |
Coates
|
The Wellspring
|
Richmond |
Bringing Ourt the
Life Within
|
Collins
|
The Well |
Richter |
The Well
|
Crouch
|
The Well
|
Riseman |
The Well |
Damian-Knight
|
The Well |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
The Well
|
Dening
|
The Well-springs of
Life
|
Rutt |
Well
|
Dhiegh
|
The Well, Deep Pit
|
Seabrook |
The Source
|
Douglas
|
The Well |
Secter |
Society, Community,
Cohesion
|
Feng
|
The Well, Mine
|
Shaughnessy |
The Well
|
Fu Youde |
The Well
|
Shchutskii |
The Well |
Graeme
|
The Well
|
Siu |
Potentialities
Fulfilled
|
Hacker
|
A Well
|
Sneddon |
A Well
|
Hatcher
|
The Well
|
Sorrell |
Source, The Well,
Resources |
Heyboer
|
The Well
|
Stackhouse |
Spirit of the
Community, Life-Giving Stream
|
Hoefler
|
The Well |
Stein |
The Well
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Replenishing
|
Sterling |
Well
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Well |
Sung |
The Well
|
Javary
|
Revitalizing
Communication
|
Toropov |
The Well |
Jou
|
Well
|
Walker, Barbara |
Well, Source
|
Judge
|
Basic Need
|
Wallace |
The Well
|
Karcher
|
The Well
|
Wei, Henry |
A Well
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Well
|
West |
The Well
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Well |
Whincup |
The Well |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Well |
Wilhelm |
The Well |
Kunst |
Well
|
Wing |
The Source
|
Legge
|
Moralisings on a
Well, Lessons from a Well
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
The Well |
Leichtman
|
Inner Oneness, The
Essence
|
Wu, Yi |
The Well
|
Liu, Da
|
The Well |
Wu Wei |
The Well |
Lynn
|
The Well
|
Wu Weifarer |
The Well
|
Machovec
|
First Things
|
Young |
The Well |
Market
|
The Deep Well
|
Yu, Titus |
The Well |
Marshall, Chris
|
The Well
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Well
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
勸相 Quan4 Xiang1,
Encouraging Reciprocity
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
48.M, Key Words
Source, plenum, spring, cistern, fountain, tap,
pools; center, hub, nucleus, nexus
Meeting place, commons; common ground, sources and
pools; interdependence
Basic service & maintenance; utility taken for
granted, maintaining links to source
Basic needs, truths, constants; replenishment,
providence; be accessible, available
Resourcefulness, resources at your disposal,
getting to plenty; there to draw upon
Developing character around deeper core;
self-sufficiency, -reliance, -cultivation
48.G, From the
Glossary
Jing3 (a,
the) well, source, wellspring, nucleus, mine,
center of social activity,
constant; (a, the)
well’s; a system of 8 private fields around a
center or common
Note:
The perfect Gua Ming for 48 is simply The Well.
The most obvious of the associations belong
here: it is a Source, of replensishment and
refreshment. It must be cared for and
maintained. It's pretty useless if the rope
isn't long enough or the bucket is broken. But
in the Early Zhou The Well also symbolizes
Common Ground, the Commons, and what we now call
"the tragedy of the commons." It occupied the
central parcel in the allocation of land but was
not itself privately owned. As such, it is what
we have in common, the resources available to us
by virtue of having human nature, animal nature
and life. The Xu Gua says Fan3 Xia4, Back to the
Lowly or Back to Basics. The notion of
encouraging reciprocity, or working together,
suggests an interactive relationship with
providence, as in "The Lord helps those who help
themselves." The Well is a device, but we are
its only moving part.
|
|
49
革 Gé
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Revolution
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Le4, Leather
Restraint, Harness; To Coerce
|
Albertson
|
Overthrowing
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
勒 #46, The Bridle,
To Compel
|
Balkin |
Revolution |
Meyer |
Shedding
the Past
|
Barrett
|
Radical Change
|
Needham |
Change, Revolution
|
Blofeld
|
Revolution,
Leather, Skin |
Ni |
Revolution,
Reformation |
Bonnershaw
|
Change
|
Palmer |
Change
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Reform
|
Pattee |
Revolution |
Chang
|
Revolution
|
Peden |
Revolution |
Chu
|
Change, Revolution
|
Perrottet |
Revolution |
Chung Wu
|
Reform
|
Powell |
Throwing Off
|
Clark
|
Revolution
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Rejection
|
Cleary |
Change, Revolution
|
Reifler |
Revolution |
Coates
|
A Time of
Revolutionary Change
|
Richmond |
Breaking Out of the
Old
|
Collins
|
Rebel
|
Richter |
Revolt
|
Crouch
|
Rawhide
(Revolution)
|
Riseman |
Revolution |
Damian-Knight
|
Revolution |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Skinning,
Revolution
|
Dening
|
Total
Transformation
|
Rutt |
Leather
|
Dhiegh
|
Revolution, Skin,
Molt, Cut Off, To Degrade |
Seabrook |
Fundamental Change
|
Douglas
|
Revolution |
Secter |
Revolution,
Rectify, Sweeping Change |
Feng
|
Revolution, Molten
Goals
|
Shaughnessy |
To Revolt, Leather
|
Fu Youde |
Revolution
|
Shchutskii |
Exchange
|
Graeme
|
Revolution, Change
|
Siu |
Revolutions |
Hacker
|
Revolution |
Sneddon |
Revolution |
Hatcher
|
Seasonal Change
|
Sorrell |
Reform, Change,
Revolution |
Heyboer
|
Skinning,
Revolution
|
Stackhouse |
Revolutionary
Change, Throwing Out
|
Hoefler
|
The Upheaval
|
Stein |
Change and
Transformations
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Abolishing the Old
|
Sterling |
Revolution |
Huang, Kerson
|
Revolution |
Sung |
Change
|
Javary
|
Renewing What has
become Old
|
Toropov |
Shedding Old Skin √
|
Jou
|
Revolution
|
Walker, Barbara |
Revolution,
Uprising, Renovation
|
Judge
|
Revolution
|
Wallace |
Revolution
|
Karcher
|
Skinning
|
Wei, Henry |
Reform
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Revolution
|
West |
Reform
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Revolution |
Whincup |
Revolution |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Revolution, Change
|
Wilhelm |
Revolution
(Molting) |
Kunst |
Rawhide, Change
|
Wing |
Changing
|
Legge
|
Changing, Changes
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Change, Skin
|
Leichtman
|
Adjustment,
Transformation
|
Wu, Yi |
Revolution |
Liu, Da
|
Revolution |
Wu Wei |
Time for a Change
|
Lynn
|
Radical Change
|
Wu Weifarer |
Transforming
|
Machovec
|
Timely Change
|
Young |
Changing
|
Market
|
Profound Changes
|
Yu, Titus |
Skinning the Hide
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Revolution |
|
|
McCarver
|
Revolution |
十翼 Shi Yi |
故去 Qu4 Gu4,
Removing the Old
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
49.M, Key Words
Strip, shed skin or fur, lay bare, molt, cast off,
unveil, disburden; summer clothes
Rawhide, leather, encrustations, shells;
protective coverings, restraints, precedents
Protective membranes dated, outmoded, no longer
needed; calluses & callousness
Obsolescence, anachronism, aging institutions;
things resisting change superseded
Change, renewal, overthrow, overturn, turnaround,
revolution; reform, unburden
Divestment, revisions, re-envisionings,
renovations, metamorphosis, outgrowing
49.G, From the
Glossary
Ge2 (to)
change, alter, transform, degrade, take away,
supersede, set aside, reform,
replace, modify,
amend, renovate, renew, revolve, change seasons,
molt, shed
(skin), have (had) enough, divest,
strip, flay, peel, get rid of, cast off,
eliminate,
revolt, break with past, overthrow;
(a, the) changing (of), revolution, seasonal
change, animal hide, rawhide, skin, leather
(not fur, implies hair removed); of
change
Notes:
While Political Revolution and Culural
Revolution are both central to the meaning of
49, these are still not as fundamental as
Celestial Revolution, the revolving of the great
wheels, the Earth, the Sky and the passing of
the Four Seasons. Most of what exists attempts
to resist the changes brought to us by Time,
since life is negative entropy, and so when
things do not change continuously they must be
changed more discontinuosly. We cling to the old
and outdated as long as we can, and then find
that we must surrender them abruptly in order to
catch up with the time. Also central to the core
of Ge are the images of shedding skin and
molting fur, protective coverings that have
outlasted their usefulness.
|
|
50
鼎 Dǐng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Cauldron
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Cooking Pot
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #56 |
Balkin |
The Cauldron |
Meyer |
Melting
Pot
|
Barrett
|
The Vessel
|
Needham |
Vessel
|
Blofeld
|
A Sacrificial
Vessel (N)
|
Ni |
The Cauldron,
Harmonization, Stability |
Bonnershaw
|
Cauldron
|
Palmer |
The Cooking Pot
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Tripod, Renewal
(24, 49)
|
Pattee |
The Cauldron |
Chang
|
Talent
|
Peden |
The Cauldron |
Chu
|
The Cauldron,
Sacrificial Vessel |
Perrottet |
Sacrifice ?
|
Chung Wu
|
The Cauldron |
Powell |
The Cauldron |
Clark
|
The Cauldron
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Values
|
Cleary |
The Cauldron |
Reifler |
The Cauldron |
Coates
|
Providing
Nourishment to Mankind (27)
|
Richmond |
Integration
|
Collins
|
The Cauldron |
Richter |
The Tripod
|
Crouch
|
Ding
|
Riseman |
The Cauldron |
Damian-Knight
|
The Cauldron |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
The Vessel, Holding
|
Dening
|
The Cauldron |
Rutt |
Tripod Bowl
|
Dhiegh
|
The Cauldron,
Tripod, Censor, Empire |
Seabrook |
Culture (26)
|
Douglas
|
The Cauldron |
Secter |
Civilization
Cultured, Transformation
|
Feng
|
Cauldron, Altar
|
Shaughnessy |
The Cauldron
|
Fu Youde |
The Cauldron
|
Shchutskii |
The Altar
|
Graeme
|
Ting, Cauldron,
Sacrificial Vessel
|
Siu |
Rejuvenation (18)
|
Hacker
|
The Ritual Cauldron
|
Sneddon |
The Cauldron |
Hatcher
|
The Cauldron
|
Sorrell |
Order, Structure,
Security |
Heyboer
|
The Ritual Cauldron
|
Stackhouse |
Law of the Land,
Commemorative Ceremony
|
Hoefler
|
The Cosmic Order ?
|
Stein |
The Cauldron |
Huang, Alfred
|
Establishing the
New
|
Sterling |
Kettle
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Cauldron |
Sung |
The Cauldron |
Javary
|
Transmuting
|
Toropov |
The Cauldron |
Jou
|
Cauldron
|
Walker, Barbara |
Cauldron,
Sacrificial Vessel
|
Judge
|
Cultural Heritage
|
Wallace |
The Cauldron
|
Karcher
|
The Vessel, Holding
|
Wei, Henry |
A Cauldron |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Cauldron
|
West |
The Cooking Pot
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Cauldron |
Whincup |
The Ritual Cauldron
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Cauldron |
Wilhelm |
The Cauldron |
Kunst |
Cauldron |
Wing |
Cosmic Order ?
|
Legge
|
The Cauldron
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
A Sacrificial
Vessel, A Cauldron |
Leichtman
|
Revelation ?,
Divine Intelligence ?
|
Wu, Yi |
The Cauldron |
Liu, Da
|
The Cauldron |
Wu Wei |
The Cauldron |
Lynn
|
The Cauldron
|
Wu Weifarer |
The Cauldron
|
Machovec
|
High Ideas √
|
Young |
The Cauldron |
Market
|
Proper Means and
Ends
|
Yu, Titus |
The Cauldron |
Marshall, Chris
|
The Cauldron |
|
|
McCarver
|
Cauldron |
十翼 Shi Yi |
養賢 Yang3 Xian2,
Nourishing Merit
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
50.M, Key Words
Crucible, tripod, a sacrificial cooking vessel;
consecrated or dedicated offerings
Dedicated change, change by design, science as
art; applied heat and knowledge
Refinement, sublimation, purification, alchemy,
the great work of transformation
Symbol of dynastic foundation & creative
power; nourishment of ability, nobility
Pragmatic utility, specific utility; excellence by
design, instrumentality, formulae
Realizing potential in raw material, social
engineering, creation of higher culture
50.G, From the
Glossary
Ding3 (a,
the) cauldron, sacrificial vessel, tripod,
(ritual) ding vessel, crucible, (consecrated,
dedicated) transformation; [alchemy]; (a, the)
cauldron’s
Note:
The Cauldron is the perfect Gua Ming for 50, but
as with the Well, the Zhouyi's other
technological artifact, the broader connotations
of its use need to be unfolded and incorporated
into the core meaning. The tripod base is
imporatnt as it is the simplest, most stable
foundation that an artifact can have, and the
handles, the practical issue of accessibility,
occupy half of the lines. It would be fair to
say that this Gua is about Cultural Alchemy. It
is not precisely correct to call the vessel a
Sacrificial Cauldron: it's purpose and function
are more closely related to rituals of
Dedication or Consecration than sacrifice. There
are higher purposes being served here, in
feeding the most noble among us, the best among
us, with the best that we have to offer: to
transform us and our culture into something
better than it is today. The Ding is thus closer
in meaning to Crucible or Forge than it is to
Vessel. In fact, it is the Alchemist's "Great
Work": the transformation of mankind. The Tuan
Zhuan uses Xiang4, Imagining, Modeling,
Representation, perhaps feeding with a design in
mind, nourishing to a higher purpose. The Da
Xiang offers Ning2 Ming4, Manifesting or
Realizing Higher Purpose.
|
|
51
震 Zhèn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Exciting Power
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Chen2, Daybreak, A
Herald, Timely
|
Albertson
|
Thunder
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
辰 #25, Thunder, 5th
Chronogram
|
Balkin |
Shock |
Meyer |
Sudden
Jolt
|
Barrett
|
Shock
|
Needham |
Excitation
|
Blofeld
|
Thunder
|
Ni |
The Arousing, Force
of Thunder |
Bonnershaw
|
Thunderclap
|
Palmer |
Shock
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Thunder, Shock
|
Pattee |
The Arousing
|
Chang
|
Thunder
|
Peden |
Shock |
Chu
|
Thunder, Arousing |
Perrottet |
Shock |
Chung Wu
|
Motion
|
Powell |
Thunderclap
|
Clark
|
Shock
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Shock
|
Cleary |
Thunder |
Reifler |
The Thunderclap |
Coates
|
Sudden Change
|
Richmond |
Shaken in his Being
|
Collins
|
The Arousing |
Richter |
Thunder
|
Crouch
|
Thunder
|
Riseman |
The Arousing,
Thunderclap |
Damian-Knight
|
The Arousing,
Shock, Thunder |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Shake, Arousing
|
Dening
|
Shock
|
Rutt |
Thunder
|
Dhiegh
|
The Arousing |
Seabrook |
Shock
|
Douglas
|
Thunder |
Secter |
Provoking, Incite,
Motivate
|
Feng
|
Quaking
|
Shaughnessy |
Thunder
|
Fu Youde |
Thunder
|
Shchutskii |
Lightning
|
Graeme
|
Arousing, Shock,
Energising, Thunder
|
Siu |
Shock
|
Hacker
|
Thunder |
Sneddon |
Exciting Power
|
Hatcher
|
Arousal
|
Sorrell |
Shock, Surprise,
Excitement |
Heyboer
|
Thunderbolt
|
Stackhouse |
Decisive Moment,
Moment of Recognition
|
Hoefler
|
Thunder |
Stein |
Awakening
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Taking Action
|
Sterling |
Arousing Thunder
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Thunder |
Sung |
Startling Movement
|
Javary
|
Rousing (Thunder)
|
Toropov |
Thunder
|
Jou
|
Thunder
|
Walker, Barbara |
Shock, Thunder
|
Judge
|
Crisis Preparedness
|
Wallace |
Thunder, Arousing
|
Karcher
|
Shake, Arousing
|
Wei, Henry |
Quaking
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Shock of Thunder
|
West |
Thunder
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Arousing |
Whincup |
Thunderbolts
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Arousing,
Thunder, Shocking
|
Wilhelm |
The Arousing
(Shock, Thunder)
|
Kunst |
Thunder |
Wing |
Shocking
|
Legge
|
Conduct in a Time
of Movement
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Thunder, Shaking
|
Leichtman
|
Explosiveness, The
Unexpected
|
Wu, Yi |
The Shake
|
Liu, Da
|
Thunder, Shock
|
Wu Wei |
Shock, The Arousing
|
Lynn
|
Quake
|
Wu Weifarer |
Thunder
|
Machovec
|
The Web of Anxiety
|
Young |
Shocking
|
Market
|
Times of Turmoil
|
Yu, Titus |
Shock
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Arousing |
|
|
McCarver
|
Shock |
十翼 Shi Yi |
脩省 Xiu1 Xing3,
Adjustment and Study
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
51.M, Key Words
Stimulus & response, action & reaction,
motive & motion; reaction into response
Shake up, provocation; suddenness, surge, raw
energy, net motive force, arousal
The unexpected, novelty, surprise, startle reflex;
repercussion, resounding, retort
Awakening, quickening, exhilaration, invigoration,
challenge, motivation, starting
Mastery, maturity, experience, getting one’s grip,
composure, attunement, aplomb
Nimbleness, resilience; hunting, capturing &
using ambient energy; taking charge
51.G, From the
Glossary
Zhen4 (a,
the) shock, thunder, shakeup, excitement,
arousal, stimulation, force,
power, energy,
vibration, movement, motion, quake, terror, awe,
unexpected; (to)
shake (up), excite, stimulate,
quicken, rouse, arouse, motivate, move, marshal;
inspire, frighten, shock, startle, scare,
alarm; tremble, vibrate, lift, quiver, dust off
(s, ed, ing); (to be) shaken, shook up,
excited, roused, aroused, stimulated, moved,
motivated, frightened, startled, scared,
alarmed; awe inspiring
Note:
The Chong Gua, or the eight Hexagrams that are
formed by doubled Bagua, do not carry precisely
the same meanings as their constiuent Bagua. The
Bagua depict energies of qualities of energy.
They are simpler, more direct, unconscious, raw.
In the Chong Gua they become self-aware, they
incorporate feedback and learn about themselves,
and this has consequences in the behavior
depicted. Gua 51, then, refers only in small
part to the first shock or peal of thunder, or
to the startled reaction: of even greater
interest here is what happens with the second.
Subsequent maturity, or the learned response, is
a central part of the meaning. The Tuan Zhuan
mentions Zhu3, (Resultant) Mastery or Authority,
and the Xu Gua the Zhang3 Zi3, the Eldest Son,
the voice of experience where depicted elsewhere
in the Yi.
|
|
52
艮 Gěn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Arresting Movement
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Gen1, Root, Base,
Foundation, Beginning
|
Albertson
|
Repose
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
根 #9, Stilling,
Root
|
Balkin |
Keeping Still |
Meyer |
Absolutely
Still
|
Barrett
|
Stilling
|
Needham |
Immobility
|
Blofeld
|
Desisting, Stilling
|
Ni |
Keeping Still
|
Bonnershaw
|
Resting
|
Palmer |
Resting
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Mountain,
Steadiness √
|
Pattee |
Keeping Still |
Chang
|
Mountain
|
Peden |
Stillness
|
Chu
|
Keeping Still,
Mountain |
Perrottet |
Keeping Still |
Chung Wu
|
Stoppage
|
Powell |
Inaction
|
Clark
|
Stillness
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Inaction
|
Cleary |
Mountain, Mountains
|
Reifler |
Keeping Still |
Coates
|
A Time to Remain
Quiet
|
Richmond |
A Wider View
|
Collins
|
Keeping Still |
Richter |
Motionless
|
Crouch
|
Cutting
(Restraining)
|
Riseman |
Keeping Still |
Damian-Knight
|
Keeping Still,
Mountain |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Bound, Stabilizing
|
Dening
|
Living in the
Present
|
Rutt |
Cleaving
|
Dhiegh
|
Keeping Still,
Perverse, Obstinate, Reposing |
Seabrook |
Rest
|
Douglas
|
Stillness
|
Secter |
Introspective
Composure √, Tranquil
|
Feng
|
Rest, Peaked
|
Shaughnessy |
To Make Still
|
Fu Youde |
Keeping Still
|
Shchutskii |
Mountain Chain,
Concentration √
|
Graeme
|
Keeping Still,
Stillness
|
Siu |
Resting
|
Hacker
|
Mountain
|
Sneddon |
Arresting Movement
|
Hatcher
|
Stillness
|
Sorrell |
Stillness,
Tranquility, Stability |
Heyboer
|
Resistance
|
Stackhouse |
Meditation,
Confronting Oneself
|
Hoefler
|
The Silence
|
Stein |
Centering
(Connecting)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Keeping Still
|
Sterling |
Keeping Still,
Mountain |
Huang, Kerson
|
Mountain
|
Sung |
Checking, Stopping
|
Javary
|
Stabilizing
(Mountain)
|
Toropov |
Stillness, the
Mountain
|
Jou
|
Mountain
|
Walker, Barbara |
Stillness,
Mountain, Solitude, Meditation
|
Judge
|
Inaction
|
Wallace |
Mountain, Stilling
|
Karcher
|
Bound, Stabilizing
|
Wei, Henry |
Rest, Obstacle (39)
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Stillness
|
West |
Stillness
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Keeping Still
|
Whincup |
Keep Still
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Mountain, Stillness
|
Wilhelm |
Keeping Still,
Mountain |
Kunst |
Cleave, Resist
|
Wing |
Meditation
|
Legge
|
Resting and
Arresting, Keeping at Rest
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Mountain, Still
|
Leichtman
|
Inner Pulling,
Reflection
|
Wu, Yi |
Stopping
|
Liu, Da
|
Stillness
|
Wu Wei |
Stopping Action,
Thoughts Coming to Rest
|
Lynn
|
Restraint
|
Wu Weifarer |
Keeping Still
|
Machovec
|
Stop, Look, Listen
|
Young |
Keeping Still |
Market
|
Keeping Calm |
Yu, Titus |
Concentrating
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Keeping Still |
|
|
McCarver
|
Keeping Still |
十翼 Shi Yi |
止 Zhi3, To Stop,
Settle Down, Keep Still
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
52.M, Key Words
Check, restrain, resist, confine, delimit, define,
discipline; to hold against change
Straightforward, forthright, honest, present,
steadfast, anchored, rooted, grounded
Concentration, introspection, reflection,
meditation, quietude, self-containment
Prepossession, reserve, balance, stability,
equilibrium, poise; the matter at hand
Touchstone, paragon, terminus; silence, resting,
inertness; presence, self mastery
Pressures building to not be still;
self-examination; backbone, integrity, principle
52.G, From the
Glossary
Gen4 (to)
still, check, limit, restrain, constrain,
prevent, confine, arrest, define,
resist, be
obstinate; keep still, just be, hold steady,
balance, rest, set, settle, quiet,
suspend (s,
ed, ing); (a, the) restraint, confinement,
definition, boundary, setting,
obstacle ahead,
stillness, equilibrium, rest, [inertia];
stiffness; opposition, hos-
tility; (to be)
outspoken, straightforward, candid, blunt,
simple, honest; refractory,
stubborn,
obstinate, perverse
Notes:
The ongoing search for equilibrium is a
pervasive drive in our hierarchy of needs.
Homeostasis keeps us within the range of
circumstances that our vulnerabilities allow us.
It is not incorrect, and maybe not even
anachronistic, to call some of the behavior
depicted herein an early form of Yoga,
meditation, or even Zazen. The concern for the
spine, as analogous to a range of mountains, is
central to the ideas of poise and balance. One
supposes that the more dynamic forms of
Maintaining Balance, such as Aikido and Jujitsu,
would be appropriate here as well. Gravity is
befriended here. Gravitas, a dignified
equilibrium, has its utility as well. It's a
little peculiar that this is called the Youngest
Son, for whom playing, making mistakes and
telling lies seem a better fit. Perhaps we can
infer from this that the young nobility in the
Early Zhou were frequently told to Keep Still
and pay attention.
|
|
53
漸 Jiàn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Gradual Progress,
Growth |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Maturing
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #60 |
Balkin |
Developing
Gradually |
Meyer |
Little
by Little
|
Barrett
|
Gradual Progress
|
Needham |
Slow & Steady
Advance, Development
|
Blofeld
|
Gradual Progress |
Ni |
Gradualness
|
Bonnershaw
|
Unfolding
|
Palmer |
Gradual Development
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Gradual Progress
|
Pattee |
Development |
Chang
|
Growth
|
Peden |
Development |
Chu
|
Gradual
Development, Progress |
Perrottet |
Gradual
Development |
Chung Wu
|
Gradualness
|
Powell |
Gradual Progress |
Clark
|
Steady Development
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Beginnings
|
Cleary |
Gradual Progress |
Reifler |
Procession
|
Coates
|
Gradual,
Progressive Development
|
Richmond |
Persistence
|
Collins
|
Gradual Advance |
Richter |
Gradual Approach
|
Crouch
|
Progressing (Wild
Geese)
|
Riseman |
Development,
Procession |
Damian-Knight
|
Development,
Gradual Progress |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Infiltrating,
Gradual Advance
|
Dening
|
Gradual Development
|
Rutt |
Settling
|
Dhiegh
|
Development,
Gradual Progress |
Seabrook |
Gradual Progress |
Douglas
|
Gradual Advance |
Secter |
Proceeding,
Developing, Evolving
|
Feng
|
Gradually Approach
|
Shaughnessy |
Advancing
|
Fu Youde |
Gradual Progress |
Shchutskii |
Current
|
Graeme
|
Gradual
Development, The Marrying Woman |
Siu |
Growth
|
Hacker
|
Gradual Advance |
Sneddon |
Gradual Progress |
Hatcher
|
Gradual Progress
|
Sorrell |
Gradual Progress,
Developing, Advance |
Heyboer
|
The Waterwheel
|
Stackhouse |
Relentless
Advancement, Progress
|
Hoefler
|
Development
|
Stein |
Development
(Growth)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Developing
Gradually
|
Sterling |
Development |
Huang, Kerson
|
Progress (35)
|
Sung |
Progressive Advance
|
Javary
|
Progressing Step by
Step
|
Toropov |
Gradually
Progressing
|
Jou
|
Gradually
|
Walker, Barbara |
Development,
Progress, Partnership
|
Judge
|
Development
|
Wallace |
Gradual Progress |
Karcher
|
Infiltrating,
Gradually Advancing
|
Wei, Henry |
Gradual Progression
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Gradual Development
|
West |
Gradual Progress |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Gradual Progress |
Whincup |
Gradual Advance
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Gradual
Development, Gradual Progress
|
Wilhelm |
Development
(Gradual Progress) |
Kunst |
Advance, Moisten
|
Wing |
Developing
|
Legge
|
Gradually
Progressing, Gradually Advancing
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Glide, To
Advance
|
Leichtman
|
The Keynote,
Evolution
|
Wu, Yi |
Gradual Development
|
Liu, Da
|
Gradual Development
|
Wu Wei |
Gradual Development
|
Lynn
|
Gradual Advance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Progress
|
Machovec
|
Continued Growth
|
Young |
Gradual Development
|
Market
|
Gradual Advance |
Yu, Titus |
Navigating
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Development |
|
|
McCarver
|
Progressive Advance
|
十翼 Shi Yi |
進 Jin4, Progreess,
Moving Forward
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
53.M, Key Words
Advancing by degrees, steadiness of pace,
thoroughness, reliability, consistency
Constancy, tenacity, endurance; procedures to
follow, proceedings, conventions
Incremental growth, maturation, development; a
longer process, one day at a time
Accommodation, patience, meeting criteria of
place, due process, rites, protocol
Wild goose as symbol for long-term fidelity and
commitment; following the order
Practicality, day to day progress, slowly and
surely, a progressive conservatism
53.G, From the
Glossary
Jian4 (to)
advance gradually, increasingly, advance by
degrees, go little by little,
go bit by bit, go
steadily, make gradual progress, make steady
progress, pace one-
self, progress gradually,
develop into; seep into, soak, saturate (s, ed,
ing); (a, the)
proceedings, formalities,
details, protocol, patient progress, (gradual,
steady) ad-
vance, progress; (to be) next,
slight; gradually, increasingly
Note:
Gradual Progress might be the best Gua Ming
here, although Gradual Development eliminates
some potential confusion of Progress with 35 and
46. It does indeed make progress, going little
by little, towards a worthy and significantly
distant end. Pacing ourselves would be a better
description than exercising patience, although
that is also required. There is a commendability
to the length of one's vision here, to the
far-ness of the horizon, in the distance to
one's ends: deferred gratification is a hopeful
sign of maturity. The image of the slow-growing
tree on the mountain calls to mind the ancient
and gnarled Krumholz trees that live near
timberline. The Ten Wings also use Jin4 to gloss
Jin4, the Gua Ming of Gua 35. But in the Tuan
Zhuan here it is Jin4 Yi3 Zheng4, Advance With
Correctness, implying formalities or
requirements to be fulfilled or realities to be
accommodated.
|
|
54
歸妹 Guī Mèi
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Second Wife
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #29 |
Balkin |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Meyer |
Quiet
Acceptance
|
Barrett
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Needham |
Reaction, Union
|
Blofeld
|
The Marriageable
Maiden |
Ni |
Marriage
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Nubile Woman
|
Palmer |
Marrying the
Younger Sister
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Marrying a Daughter
Off
|
Pattee |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Chang
|
Marriage
|
Peden |
Caution
|
Chu
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Perrottet |
The Marrying Girl
|
Chung Wu
|
Marrying a Maiden
|
Powell |
The Marriageable
Maiden
|
Clark
|
Destiny
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Ambition
|
Cleary |
A Young Woman Going
to Marry
|
Reifler |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Coates
|
An Awkward
Subordinate Relationship
|
Richmond |
Held Back, Breaks
Forth
|
Collins
|
Wise Maiden ?
|
Richter |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Crouch
|
The Marrying
Daughter
|
Riseman |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Damian-Knight
|
Relationships
Governed by Law ?
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Converting the
Maiden
|
Dening
|
Playing a
Subordinate Role
|
Rutt |
Marriage
|
Dhiegh
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Seabrook |
Desire
|
Douglas
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Secter |
Formality,
Convention, Customs (53)
|
Feng
|
Marrying (Little)
Sister
|
Shaughnessy |
Returning Maiden,
The Marrying Maiden |
Fu Youde |
Marrying Maiden |
Shchutskii |
The Bride
|
Graeme
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Siu |
Propriety (53)
|
Hacker
|
A Maiden Marries
|
Sneddon |
Propriety (53) |
Hatcher
|
Little Sister's
Marriage
|
Sorrell |
Impulsive,
Passionate, Flawed |
Heyboer
|
Marrying Maiden
|
Stackhouse |
Girl Moving into a
New Situation
|
Hoefler
|
Propriety
|
Stein |
Living Together
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Marrying Maiden
|
Sterling |
Young Marriagable
Woman
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Marrying Maiden
|
Sung |
Marriage of the
Younger Sister
|
Javary
|
Choosing for
Irrelevant Reasons
|
Toropov |
The Younger Maiden
Marries
|
Jou
|
Marrying Sister
|
Walker, Barbara |
Subordination, The
Marriageable Maiden
|
Judge
|
Elective Affinity
|
Wallace |
Marrying Off the
Maiden
|
Karcher
|
Converting the
Maiden
|
Wei, Henry |
A Maiden's Marriage
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Erroneous
Engagement √
|
West |
The Young Bride
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Marriageable Maiden
|
Whincup |
A Maiden Marries
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Maiden Who
Marries
|
Wilhelm |
The Marrying Maiden
|
Kunst |
Send in Marriage;
Daughter, Young Girl
|
Wing |
Subordinate
|
Legge
|
The Marrying Away
of a Younger Sister
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Marriage of a
Younger Sister
|
Leichtman
|
The Apprentice,
Compliance
|
Wu, Yi |
Marrying Off the
Younger Sister
|
Liu, Da
|
The Marrying Girl |
Wu Wei |
Joyous Movement
|
Lynn
|
Marrying Maid
|
Wu Weifarer |
Marrying Maiden |
Machovec
|
Passive Progress
|
Young |
An Outsider ?
|
Market
|
Being Useful
|
Yu, Titus |
Young Woman Marries
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Maiden |
|
|
McCarver
|
Marrying Maiden |
十翼 Shi Yi |
知敝 Zhi1 Bi4, To
Know the Ephemeral
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
54.M, Key Words
Premature engagement, compromising position,
settling early for less, entrapment
Jumping to conclusions, immediate gratification,
haste, impulsiveness, immaturity
Impatience, eagerness, quick solutions, ephemera,
transience; whim, flush, rush
Fascination, allurement, unenduring enthusiasm,
charm, appeal, desire as a leader
Passing fancy, short sight, seduction, bait;
addiction meaning to give into slavery
Difficulties in right mating, discrimination,
subordinating offer to long term goals
54.G, From the
Glossary
Gui1
(a, the) betrothal, engagement, homecoming,
marriage, new home; return;
(to) belong, (come,
go, take, turn) back; bring home (around,
again), come (back)
home, restore, return,
revert, bring to; send, go (back, home) (to); be
persuaded,
capitulate, give in, (give) in
marriage, marry, gave ... in marriage; become
loyal,
change loyalties, submit, turn over to;
go to new home (s, ed, ing); (to be) res-
tored;
to where ... belongs; where to turn
Mei4 (a,
the) little sister, younger sister, maiden,
virgin, girl, daughter of second
wife, step
sister; young sister’s, little sister’s
Notes:
Undeferred Gratification, Jumping the Gun
and Jumping to Conclusions at least
belong in the core meanings or keywords
collection here, even if they are too
anachronistic for Gua Ming consideration.
Humanity has been doing this for a very long
time - it's a legitimate and ancient archetype.
The image in the metaphor is of a young girl
either marrying ahead of her older sister, or
simple Marrying in Haste in order to get ahead.
The long-term consequences of this haste aren't
seriously taken into account. It is in a
lot of ways the opposite in meaning to Gua 53. A sobering
look ahead at the mischief that such
impulsiveness makes is earnestly prescribed as a
remedy,
but the lines depict other mature approaches as
well.
|
|
55
豐 Fēng
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Prosperity
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Affluence
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #31 |
Balkin |
Abundance |
Meyer |
Crowning
Glory
|
Barrett
|
Abundance
|
Needham |
Lesser Abundance |
Blofeld
|
Abundance |
Ni |
Over-Capacity
|
Bonnershaw
|
Abundance
|
Palmer |
Prosperity
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Enlargement,
Expansion
|
Pattee |
Abundance |
Chang
|
Money and Power
|
Peden |
Abundance
|
Chu
|
Abundance |
Perrottet |
Wealth
|
Chung Wu
|
Abundance |
Powell |
Abundance |
Clark
|
Plenty
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Spirit ?
|
Cleary |
Richness, Abundance
|
Reifler |
Abundance |
Coates
|
The Pinnacle of
Success √
|
Richmond |
Plentiful
Relationship
|
Collins
|
Abundance |
Richter |
Abundance
|
Crouch
|
Feng (Solar
Eclipse)
|
Riseman |
Greatness, Fullness
|
Damian-Knight
|
Abundance |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Abounding
|
Dening
|
Abundance
|
Rutt |
Thick
|
Dhiegh
|
Abundance,
Prolific, Fruitful, Luxuriant |
Seabrook |
Plenty
|
Douglas
|
Abundant Prosperity
|
Secter |
Abundance,
Bountiful, Success |
Feng
|
Abundance, Fire
Works
|
Shaughnessy |
Abundance
|
Fu Youde |
Abundance |
Shchutskii |
Abundance |
Graeme
|
Abundance, Fullness
|
Siu |
Prosperity
|
Hacker
|
Abundance |
Sneddon |
Prosperity
|
Hatcher
|
Abundance
|
Sorrell |
Plenty, Harvest,
Abundance |
Heyboer
|
Drums of Victory
|
Stackhouse |
Prosperity of
Harvest Time, Heaps of Grain
|
Hoefler
|
Abundance |
Stein |
Abundance
(Fullness)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Abundance
|
Sterling |
Abundance |
Huang, Kerson
|
Abundance |
Sung |
Prosperity
|
Javary
|
Overwhelming
|
Toropov |
Abundance |
Jou
|
Prosperity
|
Walker, Barbara |
Abundance, The
Zenith √
|
Judge
|
Prosperity
|
Wallace |
Abundance
|
Karcher
|
Abounding
|
Wei, Henry |
Abundance |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Abundance
|
West |
Abundance
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Abundance |
Whincup |
Abundance |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Abundance |
Wilhelm |
Abundance
(Fullness) |
Kunst |
Ample, Full
|
Wing |
Zenith √
|
Legge
|
Abundant Prosperity
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Abundance, Thick,
Abundant |
Leichtman
|
Maturity, High Tide
|
Wu, Yi |
Abundance
|
Liu, Da
|
Greatness
|
Wu Wei |
Abundance Peaked |
Lynn
|
Abundance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Abundance |
Machovec
|
Using and Abusing ?
|
Young |
Abundance |
Market
|
The Time to Prosper
|
Yu, Titus |
Bountiful
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Abundance |
|
|
McCarver
|
Abundance |
十翼 Shi Yi |
大 Da4, Greatness,
Fullness, Culmination
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
55.M, Key Words
Busyness, hustle, confusion, crowding,
overcommitment; a culmination or zenith
Prosperity, affluence, riches, profusion,
confusion, multiple choices, complexity
Information or sensory overload; immediacy,
urgency; maximum, peak, climax
Call for dispatch, executive decision, selection,
focus, summary or snap judgment
Tunnel vision of daytime stars a.k.a. polarized
light; curtains, tall buildings, maze
Many demands on the attention, awareness narrowly
apportioned, circumscription
55.G, From the
Glossary
Feng1 (a,
the) abundance, prosperity, affluence, riches,
plenty, profusion; (to be)
(so) abundant,
luxurious (-iant), prosperous, bountiful,
prolific, ample, copious,
sumptuous, ripe,
plentiful, full, thick (that), filled,
fulfilled; (to) abound in,
prosper in,
proliferate (s, ed, ing); fully
Note:
This is the sort of surfeit of good fortune that
raises the comment "Be careful what you wish
for." This Gua depicts the (usually short)
period of time spent at the Zenith of
prosperity, amidst an excess of busyness and
confusion, and just before things start settling
down again. Micromanagement is unthinkable - one
barely has time for all of the major Executive
Decisions that need to be made. The images of
polarized light used in the lines refer to the
sort of tunnel vision that is required. There
are hopes of getting out of here, or hopes that
this will pass soon, but the Sovereign in the
Tuan has no choice: this is his element. For
those who have taken entheogens, this time may
be likened to the very peak of the experience,
just before the world begins to resolve again.
|
|
56
旅 Lǚ
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Traveling Stranger
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
The Wayfarer
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #52 |
Balkin |
The Wanderer |
Meyer |
Away
From Home
|
Barrett
|
Traveler
|
Needham |
Wandering
|
Blofeld
|
The Traveler
|
Ni |
Traveling
|
Bonnershaw
|
The Stranger
|
Palmer |
The Traveler
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Traveler
|
Pattee |
The Wanderer |
Chang
|
Immigration
|
Peden |
Wandering
|
Chu
|
The Traveler |
Perrottet |
The Stranger
|
Chung Wu
|
Traveling
|
Powell |
The Wayfarer |
Clark
|
Journeying
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Stimulation
|
Cleary |
Travel
|
Reifler |
The Stranger
|
Coates
|
A Time for
Traveling
|
Richmond |
Search for New
Reality
|
Collins
|
The Wanderer |
Richter |
The Traveler
|
Crouch
|
The Nomad
|
Riseman |
The Stranger
|
Damian-Knight
|
Traveling Business
People
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Sojourning
|
Dening
|
Stranger in a
Strange Land
|
Rutt |
Sojourner
|
Dhiegh
|
The Wandere, To
Lodge, To Travel |
Seabrook |
Strange Situations
|
Douglas
|
The Traveling
Stranger
|
Secter |
Journeyer,
Cautious, Prudent
|
Feng
|
Travel, Just
Passing
|
Shaughnessy |
Traveling
|
Fu Youde |
The Traveler
|
Shchutskii |
Wandering
|
Graeme
|
The Wanderer,
Traveler |
Siu |
The Newcomer
|
Hacker
|
The Traveler |
Sneddon |
Traveling Stranger
|
Hatcher
|
The Wanderer
|
Sorrell |
Traveling,
Transition, Impermanent |
Heyboer
|
Itinerant Troops
|
Stackhouse |
Wandering,
Homeless, Camped Under Trees |
Hoefler
|
The Traveler |
Stein |
The Wanderer |
Huang, Alfred
|
Traveling
|
Sterling |
Traveler
|
Huang, Kerson
|
The Traveler |
Sung |
The Traveler
|
Javary
|
Straying from One's
Element
|
Toropov |
The Traveler Abroad
|
Jou
|
Traveler
|
Walker, Barbara |
Travel
|
Judge
|
Marginality √
|
Wallace |
The Traveler
|
Karcher
|
Sojourning, Quest
|
Wei, Henry |
A Traveler
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Traveler
|
West |
The Wanderer |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
The Wanderer |
Whincup |
The Wanderer |
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
The Traveler / The
Wanderer
|
Wilhelm |
The Wanderer |
Kunst |
Travel, Traveler
|
Wing |
Traveling
|
Legge
|
Traveling Stranger
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
The Traveler
|
Leichtman
|
Experimentation,
Movement
|
Wu, Yi |
Wandering
|
Liu, Da
|
The Exile
|
Wu Wei |
The Stranger, The
Traveler
|
Lynn
|
The Wanderer
|
Wu Weifarer |
The Wanderer |
Machovec
|
Reckless Ambition ?
|
Young |
Wandering
|
Market
|
The Traveler
|
Yu, Titus |
Traveling
|
Marshall, Chris
|
The Wanderer |
|
|
McCarver
|
Wanderer |
十翼 Shi Yi |
小亨 Xiao3 Heng1,
Modest Fulfillment
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
56.M, Key Words
Traveler, stranger, itinerant, peddler, newcomer,
visitor, guest, disciple, pilgrim
Walkabout, vision quest; perpetual novelty,
insecurity; caravanserai, inn, shelter
Portability, light travel, roughing it, going
native; ad hoc life, living without a net
Earning a welcome; tact, wit, modesty,
self-reliance, versatility, a few good tools
Dynamic equilibrium, self-sustaining systems; the
tactics of intrusion, diplomacy
Varieties of people who wander, as a source of
uncertainty, curiosity & suspicion
56.G, From the
Glossary
Lu3 (a, the)
wanderer, traveler, itinerant, guest, vagabond,
stranger, wayfarer,
visitor; wandering; order,
sequence, arrangement; backbone, spine,
strength; (to)
travel, drift, wander, sojourn;
dispose, arrange (to be) temporary, provisional,
ad hoc; wandering, traveling, visiting,
itinerant; a unit of 500 troops
Notes:
The Knight of the Road has many names, across
the spectrum from worthless bum to pilgrim, or
fugitive to circuit judge, or thief to traveling
salesman. We just don't know who this stranger
is, or how much benefit of the doubt he should
get. In ancient Greece, the gods Zeus and Hermes
would disguise themselves as poor itinerants and
go door-to-door testing the tolerance, charity
and character of their people. You never knew if
the stranger in front of you wasn’t in fact one
of the unknown gods. The benefits to the
wanderer here, and what a social treasure this
myth was, should be obvious, but the wanderers,
as the world's most loosely formed guild, need
to keep it up, against destrucive forces within
their own ranks. Gaining right entry into an
unknown place is another of the central themes
here. Further, there is a comparison with 55 to
add an insight: just as 55 can accomplish
little, even with the benefit of having very
much, 56 can do much while having very little.
In fact, anything more than the barest
sufficiency only becomes a burden to carry.
|
|
57
巽 Xùn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Gentle Penetration
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Suan4, Reckon,
Calculate, Assess, Scheme
|
Albertson
|
Yielding
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
筭 #57, Calculations
|
Balkin |
Gentle Influence |
Meyer |
Easy
Going
|
Barrett
|
Subtly Penetratting
|
Needham |
Mild Penetration
|
Blofeld
|
Willing Submission,
Gentleness, Penetration
|
Ni |
Gentle Wind,
Submissiveness
|
Bonnershaw
|
Cold Wind
|
Palmer |
Gentle and Yielding
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
The Yielding
|
Pattee |
Penetrating
|
Chang
|
Wing
|
Peden |
Submission
|
Chu
|
The Penetrating
Wind
|
Perrottet |
Gentle Penetration
|
Chung Wu
|
Complaisance
|
Powell |
Submission
|
Clark
|
Impressionable
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Intuition
|
Cleary |
Wind, Conformity
|
Reifler |
The Penetration of
the Wind
|
Coates
|
The Effect of
Gradual, Penetrating Influence
|
Richmond |
Where is Identity
|
Collins
|
The Gentle |
Richter |
Cowardice
|
Crouch
|
Giving
|
Riseman |
The Penetrating
Wind, The Gentle |
Damian-Knight
|
The Gentle, The
Penetrating, Wind |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Ground, Penetrating
|
Dening
|
Gentle Influence
|
Rutt |
Food Offerings
|
Dhiegh
|
The Gentle |
Seabrook |
Assimilation
|
Douglas
|
Gentle Penetration
|
Secter |
Permeating,
Infiltrating, Subtle
|
Feng
|
Bending
|
Shaughnessy |
Compliance
|
Fu Youde |
Calculation
|
Shchutskii |
Penetration |
Graeme
|
Gradual Influences,
Adapting to One's Env.
|
Siu |
Gentle Penetration
|
Hacker
|
Wind
|
Sneddon |
Gentle Penetration
|
Hatcher
|
Adaptation
|
Sorrell |
Gentle Penetration,
Flexibility, Permeate |
Heyboer
|
The Seal
|
Stackhouse |
Gentle Persuasion
|
Hoefler
|
Pervasion
|
Stein |
The Gentle |
Huang, Alfred
|
Proceeding Humbly
|
Sterling |
Penetrating, Wind |
Huang, Kerson
|
Wind
|
Sung |
Bending to Enter
|
Javary
|
Accepting to be
Shaped by the Situation
|
Toropov |
Wind, Penetration
|
Jou
|
Wind
|
Walker, Barbara |
Gentleness, Breath,
Wind, Spirit
|
Judge
|
Penetrating Clarity
|
Wallace |
Wind, Gently
Proceeding
|
Karcher
|
Gently Penetrating,
Ground, Penetrating
|
Wei, Henry |
Gentle Penetration
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Gentle Wind
|
West |
Gentle Penetration
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Conformity
|
Whincup |
Kneeling in
Submission
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Wind, Gentleness,
Penetration
|
Wilhelm |
The Gentle (The
Penetrating, Wind)
|
Kunst |
Lay Out Offering
|
Wing |
Penetrating
Influence
|
Legge
|
Flexibility and
Penetration
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Wind
|
Leichtman
|
Sensitivity, Subtle
Influences
|
Wu, Yi |
Gentleness
|
Liu, Da
|
Penetration, Wind
|
Wu Wei |
Gently Penetrating
|
Lynn
|
Compliance
|
Wu Weifarer |
Gentleness |
Machovec
|
Search Out Evil
|
Young |
Gentle Penetration
|
Market
|
Persistent
Influence
|
Yu, Titus |
A Waft of Air
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Gentle Wind
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Mildness |
十翼 Shi Yi |
稱 Cheng1,
Evaluating, Assessing, Appraising
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
57.M, Key Words
Penetrate, insinuate, encroach, conform, comply;
gain admittance, entry or access
Nichemanship; occupy, adjust, adopt, adapt,
conform, submit, accommodate self
Fitting in, fitness; subtlety, resilience, shape
shifting; persuasion, sway; reconsider
Finding a path of least resistance; asserting
without aggression, subtle persistence
In-formation, to assess before following through;
learning and teaching processes
Reconnoiter, many-angled approach; rethinking,
thinking twice, second thoughts
57.G, From the
Glossary
Xun4 (to)
penetrate, enter, gain admittance, gain entry,
gain access, reach into,
insinuate, coax,
wheedle, infringe, infiltrate, influence; adapt,
conform, yield (to);
submit, resign,
accommodate; take (place, form, shape); withdraw
(s, ed, ing); (a,
the) entry, access,
penetration, adaptation, encroachment(s),
admittance, adapt-
ability, accommodation,
conformance, versatility, finesse, subtlety,
resilience,
[plasticity]; (to be) submitted to,
put into, adaptive, adapted to, accommodating,
submissive, following, subservient, docile,
humble; versatile, opportunistic; withdraw or
retreat to go around, with no intention of
giving up; also pronounced Sun4
Notes:
In the Gua Ming shown in the table above, only
the Wind aspect of the Bagua Xun has been used.
Green wood would have been just as instructive.
This is the delicate fiber of root that finds
it's way into the crack in the stone below, that
over the years will grow to split the stone
apart. This is an insinuating influence, that
advances by feeling its way along lines of least
resistance. Our understanding, or our minds, can
be said to penetrate the world in this way,
slowly, through trial and error, eventually
getting things figured out. But this is not just
a Bagua here. Xun happens twice. The first
reaching out is tentative or provisional. We get
a feel for something, or formulate an
hypothesis. We write a first draft and pass it
around. We look for the mark's tells. We get
some feedback and adapt our ideas, and then try
again with a little more confidence. This is the
Gua of thinking twice, of the learning process
that adapts as it explores.
|
|
58
兌 Duì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Joy, Pleasure
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Duo2, Take, Seize,
Carry Away, Determine
|
Albertson
|
Pleasure
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
奪 #41, Usurpation
|
Balkin |
Joy |
Meyer |
Opening
|
Barrett
|
Opening
|
Needham |
Serenity (Calm Sea)
|
Blofeld
|
Joy
|
Ni |
Joyousness
|
Bonnershaw
|
Smugness
|
Palmer |
Happiness
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Swamp, The Pleasing
|
Pattee |
The joyous
|
Chang
|
Lake
|
Peden |
Joy
|
Chu
|
Joy
|
Perrottet |
Serenity
|
Chung Wu
|
Joy
|
Powell |
Joy
|
Clark
|
Enjoy
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Aliveness
|
Cleary |
Delight, Joy,
Pleasing
|
Reifler |
Pleasure
|
Coates
|
A Time of Joyous
Collaboration
|
Richmond |
It Comes
|
Collins
|
The Joyous |
Richter |
Joy
|
Crouch
|
Talks
|
Riseman |
Joyousness
|
Damian-Knight
|
The Joyous, Lake |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Open, Expressing
|
Dening
|
Joy in
Communicating
|
Rutt |
Satisfaction
|
Dhiegh
|
The Joyous, To
Exchange, Weigh, Barter |
Seabrook |
Pleasure
|
Douglas
|
Joy
|
Secter |
Pleasure,
Gratification, Precocious
|
Feng
|
Joy, Bliss
|
Shaughnessy |
Joy, Harmony
|
Fu Youde |
Joy
|
Shchutskii |
Joy
|
Graeme
|
The Joyous, Being
Satisfied, The Lake
|
Siu |
Joy
|
Hacker
|
Lake
|
Sneddon |
Joy, Pleasure
|
Hatcher
|
Satisfaction
|
Sorrell |
Self-Confidence,
Encouragement, Pleasure |
Heyboer
|
Opening
|
Stackhouse |
Happiness,
Encouragement
|
Hoefler
|
Joy
|
Stein |
Joy
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Joyful
|
Sterling |
Joyful Lake
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Lake
|
Sung |
Joy
|
Javary
|
Expressing
Heartiness (Mist)
|
Toropov |
The Delighted,
Marshes
|
Jou
|
Lake
|
Walker, Barbara |
Joy, Sea, Lake,
Deeps
|
Judge
|
Vitality
|
Wallace |
Marsh, Joy
|
Karcher
|
Open, Expressing
|
Wei, Henry |
Joy, Satisfaction
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Joyful Exchange
|
West |
Joy
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Enjoyment
|
Whincup |
Stand Straight
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Lake, Joy, Openness
|
Wilhelm |
The Joyous, Lake
|
Kunst |
Happiness. Pleasure
|
Wing |
Encouraging
|
Legge
|
Pleasure,
Complacent Satisfaction
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Lake, Pleasure
|
Leichtman
|
Cheerfulness,
Cooperation
|
Wu, Yi |
Joy
|
Liu, Da
|
Joyousness
|
Wu Wei |
Joyous Pleasure
|
Lynn
|
Joy
|
Wu Weifarer |
Joy
|
Machovec
|
Balance and
Pleasure
|
Young |
Joy
|
Market
|
Enjoying Life
|
Yu, Titus |
Opens Up
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Joy
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Joy |
十翼 Shi Yi |
說 Yue4, Pleasure,
Enjoyment, Persuasion
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
58.M, Key Words
Free, open up, clear out; barter, bargain,
negotiate, weigh, exchange, pay, redeem
Enjoyment, pleasure, happiness, delight, relish,
relief, gratification, self-interest
Harvest, reaping rewards, fruits; compensation,
incentives, persuasion, satisfaction
Hedonics, pursuit of pleasure and happiness as
intrinsically benign and instructive
Encouragement, desire, attraction, welcome; charm,
enchantment, bewitchment
Ananda, eros, cheer, epicurean hedonism, need/want
as driving force in evolution
58.G, From the
Glossary
Dui4 (a,
the) joy, pleasure, happiness, satisfaction,
delight, gratification, rejoicing,
openness,
exchange, mouth, passage, opening, aperture; (to
be) open, free, clear,
acquiescent, accepting,
glad, happy, fond of, responsive, oral; (to)
exchange, pay,
barter, deliver, give an
equivalent, trade, transact, weigh, share; open
a passage
through, open up, clear away,
convert, gratify, rejoice; speak (s, ed, ing);
[consen-
sual behavior, voluntary transactions]
Notes:
Dui is much more than just Joy. The right name
should capture most of our more Pleasurable and
Agreeable feelings: delight, gratitude, love,
happiness, sympathy, eagerness, rapture,
ecstasy, even the sacred forms of sadness. There
is a wisdom in Pleasure and Satisfaction that
can maintain enough sense to stay out of
trouble. The Greeks who founded the
philosophical school of Hedonism knew this well.
Reasonableness does not have to be a stranger to
Pleasure. But they realized that Pleasure and
Happiness were not the thing to pursue. These
were simply what happended, or how it felt, when
we were traveling our proper path, in Chinese,
our Dao. There is another core aspect to the
meaning here: mutual consent, negotiating with
others, or bargaining to optimize the benefits
of exchange to ourselves. Adam Smith had lots to
say aboout how we all come out ahead in this
way. Dui, of course, is also a naughty little
slut who wants to be spanked.
|
|
59
渙 Huàn
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Dispersion |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Breaking Up
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #62 |
Balkin |
Dispersion |
Meyer |
Widespread
|
Barrett
|
Dispersing
|
Needham |
Dissolution
|
Blofeld
|
Scattering,
Disintegration (23), Dispersal
|
Ni |
Dispersion |
Bonnershaw
|
Alienation (12, 38)
|
Palmer |
Scattered
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Breaking Away
|
Pattee |
Dissolving
|
Chang
|
Separation (12)
|
Peden |
Dispersal
|
Chu
|
Dispersion,
Disintegration |
Perrottet |
Dissolution
|
Chung Wu
|
Dispersion
|
Powell |
Dispersal
|
Clark
|
Scattering
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Sexuality ?
|
Cleary |
Dispersal |
Reifler |
Dispersion |
Coates
|
Dissolving
Divisiveness
|
Richmond |
Dissipation of
Energy
|
Collins
|
Flowing
|
Richter |
Flowing
|
Crouch
|
Dispersal
|
Riseman |
Dispersion |
Damian-Knight
|
Dissolution,
Dispersion of Wealth
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Dispersing
|
Dening
|
Obstacles Fade Away
|
Rutt |
Gushing
|
Dhiegh
|
Dispersion,
Dissolution, To Expand, Wide |
Seabrook |
Softening
|
Douglas
|
Dispersion |
Secter |
Dispersion,
Disseminate, Spread Around |
Feng
|
Scattering,
Solution
|
Shaughnessy |
Dispersal
|
Fu Youde |
Flowing
|
Shchutskii |
Breaking Up
|
Graeme
|
Dispersion,
Dissolution, Scattering
|
Siu |
Overcoming
Dissension ?
|
Hacker
|
Flood, Dispersion |
Sneddon |
Dispersion |
Hatcher
|
Scattering
|
Sorrell |
Break Up, Disperse,
Scatter |
Heyboer
|
The Flood
|
Stackhouse |
Being Wary, Looking
Out (for Flooding?)
|
Hoefler
|
Dissolution
|
Stein |
Opening
(Dispersion)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Dispersing
|
Sterling |
Dispersion
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Flowing
|
Sung |
Dispersion
|
Javary
|
Untying (40)
|
Toropov |
Dissipation (44)
|
Jou
|
Dispersion
|
Walker, Barbara |
Dispersal,
Dissolution, Scattering
|
Judge
|
Barrier Dissolution
|
Wallace |
Dispersal
|
Karcher
|
Dispersing |
Wei, Henry |
Dispersion |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Dissolution
|
West |
Dispersion |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Dispersal |
Whincup |
The Flood
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Dispersal |
Wilhelm |
Dispersion
(Dissolution) |
Kunst |
Gush, Splash, Spurt
|
Wing |
Reuniting
|
Legge
|
Dissipation,
Dispersion
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
To Disperse
|
Leichtman
|
Universalism,
Reconnecting
|
Wu, Yi |
Dispersion
|
Liu, Da
|
Dispersion |
Wu Wei |
Dissolve,
Disintegrate, Dissipate
|
Lynn
|
Dispersion
|
Wu Weifarer |
Dispersing
|
Machovec
|
Human Truth
|
Young |
Breaking Up
|
Market
|
Disintegration
|
Yu, Titus |
Diffusion
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Dispersion |
|
|
McCarver |
Dissolution |
十翼 Shi Yi |
散 San4, Scatter,
Disperse, Break Up |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
59.M, Key Words
Distribute, disperse, disseminate, propagate,
dispel, diffuse; to broadcast, as seed
Dissociate, disincorporate, sublimate, dissolve,
dissipate, rarify, diversify, expand
The mystic’s truth, reintegration with a higher
unity, ecstasy, surrender, embrace
Changes of state: melt, dissolve, evaporate,
evanescence; subtlety, metasolutions
Disintegrate, reintegrate, a breakup or breakdown
of structure; reunion, salvation
Transcendence, metamorphosis, sublimation, opening
up, letting go, going to seed
59.G, From the
Glossary
Huan4 (a, the)
diffusion, sublimation, distillation,
evaporation, rarifaction, broad-
cast (as seed);
[change of state]; (to) disperse, scatter,
distribute, disseminate, dis-
pel, break up,
disintegrate, dissolve, clear up, relax,
relieve, melt, vanish, diffuse,
evaporate, flow
in scattered directions, rarify; fade, relent,
give way, succumb
(s, ed, ing); (to be) slack,
broad, swelling, wide, scattered, diffuse,
evanescent,
dispersed, volatile
Note:
Both the Xu Gua and Za Gua use Li2 as a gloss
for 59, even though this is also the Gua Ming
for 30. It is used here strictly in its sense of
coming apart, expanding outward, diversifying.
This Gua tells of a change of state, from lower
to higher, solid to liquid (melting) and liguid
to gas (evaporation), a breaking up of the less
fluid forms. This may be the closest the Zhouyi
comes to describing the Mystic's experience, and
both the Tuan and Da Xiang texts have strong
spiritual overtones. I have used Scattering as
Gua Ming, with deliberate Sufi connotations.
Life really is about going to seed, casting
ourselves into Time's winds: the Sufi's little
stream crosses the desert by surrendering to the
sun and and becoming a cloud. The Zhouyi authors
may not have formulated theories on the latent
heat of fusion or the enthalpy of vaporization,
but they knew what took the heat off.
|
|
60
節 Jié
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Regulation,
Restraining
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
Restriction
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #21 |
Balkin |
Limitation |
Meyer |
Economic
Measures
|
Barrett
|
Measuring
|
Needham |
Restriction,
Regulated
|
Blofeld
|
Restraint
|
Ni |
Self-Restraint
|
Bonnershaw
|
Regulation
|
Palmer |
Limitations |
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Self-Restraint
|
Pattee |
Proportion √
|
Chang
|
Discipline and
Religion
|
Peden |
Limitations
|
Chu
|
Restraint,
Limitations
|
Perrottet |
Measure
|
Chung Wu
|
Regulation
|
Powell |
Restraint
|
Clark
|
Organization
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Acceptance
|
Cleary |
Regulation,
Discipline
|
Reifler |
Restraint
|
Coates
|
The Necessity of
Limitations
|
Richmond |
Scarcity
|
Collins
|
Frugality (41)
|
Richter |
Restraint
|
Crouch
|
Measures
|
Riseman |
Limitation |
Damian-Knight
|
Limitation,
Boundaries to the Field of Action |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Articulating
|
Dening
|
Self-Control
|
Rutt |
Juncture
|
Dhiegh
|
Limitation,
Stopping, Ceasing, A Section |
Seabrook |
Limitation |
Douglas
|
Regulation
|
Secter |
Limitation,
Restriction, Regulations |
Feng
|
Curbing, Lining
|
Shaughnessy |
Moderation
|
Fu Youde |
Restraint
|
Shchutskii |
Limitation |
Graeme
|
Limitation, Gauging
the Times, Openings ?
|
Siu |
Regulations
|
Hacker
|
Restraint,
Regulations
|
Sneddon |
Regulation |
Hatcher
|
Boundaries
|
Sorrell |
Discipline,
Guidelines, Limitations |
Heyboer
|
The Measure
|
Stackhouse |
Temperance,
Moderation, Segments
|
Hoefler
|
The Limitation |
Stein |
Limits
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Restricting
|
Sterling |
Limitation |
Huang, Kerson
|
Frugality (41)
|
Sung |
Restrictive
Regulations
|
Javary
|
Fitting In
|
Toropov |
Limitation |
Jou
|
Limitation
|
Walker, Barbara |
Restraint,
Limitation
|
Judge
|
Limitation
|
Wallace |
Discipline
|
Karcher
|
Articulating
|
Wei, Henry |
Limitation |
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Moderation
|
West |
Limitation
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Restraint (44)
|
Whincup |
Restraint
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Limitation,
Self-Control
|
Wilhelm |
Limitation |
Kunst |
Joint, Moderation
|
Wing |
Limitations
|
Legge
|
Regulating and
Restraining
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Regulations
|
Leichtman
|
Unwritten Rules,
Self-Discipline
|
Wu, Yi |
Restriction
|
Liu, Da
|
Limitation |
Wu Wei |
Setting Limitations
|
Lynn
|
Control
|
Wu Weifarer |
Setting Limits
|
Machovec
|
Rules
|
Young |
Limitations |
Market
|
Limitations |
Yu, Titus |
Balance
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Limitation |
|
|
McCarver
|
Regulation |
十翼 Shi Yi |
制度 Zhi4 Du4,
Defining the Limits/Extents
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
60.M, Key Words
Limitation, abridgment, articulation, definition,
order, discipline, discrimination
Terms, terminus, stipulation, condition,
restraint, constraint, regulation, stricture
Economy, moderation, self-control, measuredness,
budgeting, thrift, allocation
Due proportion, proper balance, ethical measure;
the golden mean or middle way
Systems of moral regulation and division, measured
steps, discretion, specificity
Epicurean hedonism, good taste with rational
choice, caution, intelligent selection
60.G, From the
Glossary
Jie2 (to be)
restrained, constrained, moderate, temperate,
controlled, articulated,
limited, regular,
defined, definite; (a, the) limit, restraint,
constraint, limitation,
regulation, (regular)
division, rule, law, moderation, temperance,
control, discipline, term, boundary, condition,
articulation, article, joint, node, knot,
period,
time, degree, detail, section, segment,
juncture, chapter, abridgement (s); (in due,
duly) proportioned, in proper balance; (to)
regulate, discriminate (s, ed, ing)
Notes:
The character Jie was originally an individual
joint in a stalk of bamboo and carried the idea
of regularity and incremental growth. It
eventually carried the suspicion that
Limitations and Boundaries were the sine qua non
of any kind of viable growth: in baby steps.
Even when we are being enormously ambitious, a
healthy awareness of our Limitations and
Boundaries is the most productive place to
begin. It's the structure that we have to work
with: without it we overestimate ourselves and
underestimate the world, and we fail in our
ambitions. The most useful way to remove our
limitations seems to be to know them first, the
pep-talkers and positive "thinkers"
notwithstanding. The maxim "Know Your Measure"
comes to us from the ancient Greeks. It was
seldom advised for purposes of preventing
growth. We might suspect that our words
proportion and ratio might somehow be connected
to the words proper and rational.
|
|
61
中孚 Zhōng Fú
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Inmost Sincerity
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Zhong1 Fu4,
Recover/Return to the Center
|
Albertson
|
The Truth of the
Mean
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
中復 #61, Central
Return
|
Balkin |
Inner Truth |
Meyer |
Complete
Confidence
|
Barrett
|
Inner Truth
|
Needham |
Truth
|
Blofeld
|
Inward Confidence
and Sincerity
|
Ni |
Faithfulness
|
Bonnershaw
|
Authenticity
|
Palmer |
Inner Confidence
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Sincerity,
Faithfulness
|
Pattee |
Inner Truth |
Chang
|
Faith
|
Peden |
Truth
|
Chu
|
Inner Sincerity,
Truth |
Perrottet |
Confidence
|
Chung Wu
|
Sincerity
|
Powell |
Inner Truth |
Clark
|
Concordance
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Mystery
|
Cleary |
Sincerity/Faithfulness
in the Center
|
Reifler |
Understanding
|
Coates
|
The Power of Truth
|
Richmond |
Awareness of Wider
Reality
|
Collins
|
Inner Security |
Richter |
Inmost Trust
|
Crouch
|
Center Captured
|
Riseman |
Understanding,
Truth
|
Damian-Knight
|
Inner Truth, The
Power of Truth |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Centering Accord
|
Dening
|
The Power of Inner
Truth
|
Rutt |
Trying Captives
|
Dhiegh
|
Targetm Center,
Caring For, Inner Truth |
Seabrook |
Conviction
|
Douglas
|
Inmost Sincerity |
Secter |
Instinctive,
Authentic, Innate √
|
Feng
|
Inner Faith, Love's
Root
|
Shaughnessy |
Central Capture,
Central Sincerity
|
Fu Youde |
Inner Faithful
|
Shchutskii |
Inner Truth |
Graeme
|
Inner Truth,
Connecting, The Guiding Spirit
|
Siu |
Sincerity
|
Hacker
|
Inmost Sincerity,
Allegiance |
Sneddon |
Inmost Sincerity
|
Hatcher
|
The Truth Within
|
Sorrell |
Trusting,
Wholehearted, Centered |
Heyboer
|
Inner Sincerity
|
Stackhouse |
Inner Truth,
Innermost Memories/Intentions
|
Hoefler
|
Insight
|
Stein |
Inner Truth |
Huang, Alfred
|
Innermost Sincerity
|
Sterling |
The Inner Truth |
Huang, Kerson
|
Sincerity
|
Sung |
Central Sincerity
|
Javary
|
Trusting
|
Toropov |
The Truth Within
|
Jou
|
Central Sincerity
|
Walker, Barbara |
Insight, Inner
Truth, Sincerity
|
Judge
|
Essential Quality
|
Wallace |
Central Truth
|
Karcher
|
Connecting to
Center, Centring Accord
|
Wei, Henry |
Inner Sincerity
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Inner Confidence
|
West |
Inner Truth |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Inner Truth
|
Whincup |
Wholeheated
Allegiance
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Alligience to Inner
Truth, Sincerity
|
Wilhelm |
Inner Truth
|
Kunst |
Middle, Hit Target;
Captives
|
Wing |
Insight
|
Legge
|
Inmost Sincerity
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Inner Sincerity |
Leichtman
|
Virtue, Wisdom
|
Wu, Yi |
Inner Sincerity |
Liu, Da
|
Inner Truthfulness
|
Wu Wei |
Emptiness
|
Lynn
|
Inner Trust
|
Wu Weifarer |
Inner Truth |
Machovec
|
Be Yourself
|
Young |
Inner Truth |
Market
|
The Sincere Heart
|
Yu, Titus |
Centering,
Nurtured, Integrity
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Truth |
|
|
McCarver
|
Central Sincerity |
十翼 Shi Yi |
中信 Zhong1 Xin4,
Internal/Core Beliefs
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
61.M, Key Words
Inner, internal, central, core + sureness,
sincerity, confidence, trust, belief, truth
Insight, outlook, understanding, subjectivity,
self-interest, inner nature, meaning
Limited comprehension, internal assumptions,
personal relevance and importance
Relativity, perceptual limits, horizon, the
little picture; trusting a being to be itself
Standpoint, point of view, degree of
comprehension, perspective, communicating
Interpretations, translating differences, frames
of reference; get inside to look out
61.G, From the
Glossary
Zhong1
(a, the) balance, center, concentration, core,
focus, heart, inside, interior,
mean, median,
medium, middle, midpoint, midst (of); midday,
noon; (the) balance
point, stable point, point
closest to all options; bulls eye; (to be)
accurate, central,
balanced, concentric,
concentrated, correct, in balance, inner,
mediated, neutral,
on target, right, tempered,
true (to); average, mediocre, middling; amidst,
among,
between, in, inside, intermediate, into,
in progress; centered in at the core/heart of;
halfway between, midway, in the middle (of);
(in, at) the center/midst of; within;
proper,
equilibrated, to the point; at mid-; (to)
balance, center, concentrate, focus,
mediate,
temper, true, hit the center, attain, accomplish
(s, ed, ing)
Fu2 (a,
the) truth, the true, confidence, trust,
assurance, belief, (good) faith, proof,
conviction, sureness, sincerity, reliance,
surety, certainty, credibility, conviction,
verity, promise, loyalty, verification (s); (to
be) true, sincere, credible, confident,
honest,
trustworthy, truthful, assured, reliable, sure
(to); (to) rely on, believe in,
be sure (of),
verify, ascertain, validate, believe, have
faith, trust, hold (that) (s, ed,
ing); will
surely, certainly, truly (be); can be trusted
to, is certain to, is sure to
Note:
It's a little unfortunate that Truth gets stuck
in our sentences as a noun. Archers, carpenters
and wheelwrights at least get to use True as a
verb, where it means a great deal more. The
Zhouyi uses the phrase Be True a lot, though
only once in this Gua. Significantly, it never
once tries to tell us what truth is. It's fun to
think that it's telling us: "You know what truth
is, or at least you know what is true. You just
need to stop telling those lies." Zhong Fu, as
The Truth Within, or Core Truth, is the opposite
of absolute truth. It is truth at the personal,
local, familial, or relativistic scale. This
leaves great streams that still need to be
crossed. We are not born with an understanding
of what it's like to be a pig or a fish. We
aren't born with knowledge of what it is to be
someone or even anyone else but ourselves, but
the closer we get to the family or the familiar
the better our guesses can be. After a long,
silly detour into delusions of ourselves as tabula rasa,
our better scientists are resuming the search
for a human nature. We can find some of that
portrayed in the Zhouyi's archetypes. Gradually
we expand our understanding of who we are.
|
|
62
小過 Xiǎo Guò
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Small Excesses
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Shao3 Guo4, Same
Meaning as Rec'd Text
|
Albertson
|
The Small Person
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
少過 #28, Small
Surpassing
|
Balkin |
Exceeding Smallness
|
Meyer |
Minor
Accomplishments
|
Barrett
|
Small Exceeding
|
Needham |
Lesser Topheaviness
|
Blofeld
|
The Small Get By
|
Ni |
Minor Excess
|
Bonnershaw
|
Small Excesses
|
Palmer |
Minor Problems
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Minor Mistakes
|
Pattee |
Humble Vigilance √
|
Chang
|
Over the Limit
|
Peden |
Details
|
Chu
|
Outer Preponderance
|
Perrottet |
Power of the Weak
|
Chung Wu
|
Excess of the Small
|
Powell |
The Small Persist
|
Clark
|
Small Details
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Detail
|
Cleary |
Small Excess,
Preponderance of the Small |
Reifler |
Smallness in Excess
|
Coates
|
Leadership in
Difficult Times
|
Richmond |
After Reaching a
Level
|
Collins
|
Small Limitations
|
Richter |
Small Excess
|
Crouch
|
Small Passage
|
Riseman |
Excess of the Small
|
Damian-Knight
|
Preponderance of
the Small |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Small Exceeding
|
Dening
|
Attention to Detail
|
Rutt |
Passing, Minor
|
Dhiegh
|
Preponderance of
the Small |
Seabrook |
Trivial Matters
|
Douglas
|
Small Successes
|
Secter |
Strenuous,
Insufficient, Inability
|
Feng
|
A Little Excessive,
Razor's edge
|
Shaughnessy |
Little Surpassing
|
Fu Youde |
Small Fault
|
Shchutskii |
Overdevelopment of
the Small
|
Graeme
|
Preponderance of
the Small |
Siu |
Small Gains
|
Hacker
|
Small in Excess
|
Sneddon |
Small Excesses
|
Hatcher
|
Smallness in Excess
|
Sorrell |
Details, Caution,
Getting By |
Heyboer
|
Across the Small
Pass
|
Stackhouse |
Small Injuries,
Small Problems
|
Hoefler
|
The Moderate Excess
|
Stein |
Continuing
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Little Exceeding
|
Sterling |
Predominance of
Smallness
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Small Excess
|
Sung |
Excess in Small
Things
|
Javary
|
Lowering One's
Expectations
|
Toropov |
Exceeding in What
Is Small
|
Jou
|
Small Passing
|
Walker, Barbara |
Smallness, Details
|
Judge
|
Conscientiousness
|
Wallace |
The Small
Predominate
|
Karcher
|
Small Exceeding
|
Wei, Henry |
Excessive Smallness
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
The Small in Excess
|
West |
Small Gains
|
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Predominance of the
Small
|
Whincup |
Small Gets By
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Small Superiority,
Small Excess;
|
Wilhelm |
Preponderance of
the Small
|
Kunst |
Small Passing, Pass
|
Wing |
Attention to Detail
√
|
Legge
|
Exceeding in what
is Small
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Small and Beyond
the Ordinary
|
Leichtman
|
Good Works,
Attending to Details
|
Wu, Yi |
Small Passing
|
Liu, Da
|
Slight Excess
|
Wu Wei |
Performing Small
Tasks, Avoidance of Excess
|
Lynn
|
Minor Superiority
|
Wu Weifarer |
Exceedingly Small
|
Machovec
|
Timing ?
|
Young |
Excess Yin
|
Market
|
Moderation
|
Yu, Titus |
Flying Just Above
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Trapped Power
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Small Excess |
十翼 Shi Yi |
下順 Xia4 Shun4,
Lowly Acceptance
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
62.M, Key Words
Laws of averages, averageness, many too many;
mediocrity, anonymity, triviality
Overdevelopment, overpopulation, odds against one
among many; self as a detail
Humility, lowering expectations; settling for
little or less; truth in scale, smallness
Realism, ordinary reality, everyday suchness,
nothing special, place in big picture
Instinctual intelligence in species subject to
predation, vulnerability, heedfulness
Watchfulness, vigilance, care(fulness),
conscientiousness, awareness of finitude
62.G, From the
Glossary
Xiao3
(to be) average, common, diminished,
homogeneous, humble, insignificant,
lesser,
light, little, low(ly, er, est), mean, mediocre,
minor, minute, modest, slight,
ordinary,
small(er, est), petty, tiny, trifling, trivial,
unimportant, young(er, est),
minimal; (a, the)
commonness, homogeneity, littleness, meanness,
mediocrity,
pettiness, smallness; commonly,
ordinarily; in detail; some small, of little, a
little;
for a short (time, while); (to)
diminish, minimize, shrink, belittle; does not
imply
bad or wrong, but sometimes inferiority.
Guo4
(to) go beyond, go past, exceed, surpass,
transcend, miss, stray from, pass
(by, over);
bypass, get by, transgress, trespass, stray,
err, inundate, predominate,
exceed proper
limits (s, ed, ing); (to be) passing, transient,
errant, past, in excess,
extreme, exceptional,
too much (of), excessive, beyond, above, overly,
unusual,
extraordinary; greater/larger than;
(a, the) error, transgression, excess(iveness),
fault (s); will err; to a fault, to extremity,
to excess, to extremes
Notes:
The Tuan Zhuan explains that it's the small that
are in excess here, not that that the excesses
here are small, but this has escaped many of
those who have tried to translate the name Xiao
Guo. Here is a big clue to the core meaning: the
smaller the species in stature, the more of them
get born. The prey have a lot more babies than
the predators. The sad fact is, even if you are
a human being who fancies himself at the top of
the food chain, you are still expendable. There
are all sorts of substitutes available to take
your place. It is up to you to pay attention
accordingly. With you being just one among many,
you may need to settle for less, and show some
respect for natural laws, such as gravity. This
Gua is much closer than 15 to the meaning of
Humility. There is nothing wrong with humiliity
either, it's great stuff. It lets us feel
admiration, wonder and awe.
|
|
63
既濟 Jì Jì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
After Completion
|
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
A State of Climax
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #22 |
Balkin |
After Completion |
Meyer |
Already
Over
|
Barrett
|
Already Across
|
Needham |
Consummation,
Perfect Order
|
Blofeld
|
After Completion |
Ni |
After Crossing the
Water
|
Bonnershaw
|
Done
|
Palmer |
Already Done
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
After Crossing,
Mission Accomplished
|
Pattee |
After Completion |
Chang
|
Politics ?
|
Peden |
Completion |
Chu
|
After Completion |
Perrottet |
After Completion |
Chung Wu
|
Mission
Accomplished
|
Powell |
Climax and After
|
Clark
|
In the Midst ?
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Doubt ?
|
Cleary |
Settled, Already
Accomplished |
Reifler |
Completion |
Coates
|
A Transition from
Old to New
|
Richmond |
Completion |
Collins
|
After Crossing
|
Richter |
Already Crossing
the River
|
Crouch
|
Finished Crossing
|
Riseman |
Completion |
Damian-Knight
|
Completion
|
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Already Fording
|
Dening
|
Mission
Accomplished
|
Rutt |
Already Across
|
Dhiegh
|
After Completion,
Since, Already |
Seabrook |
After Completion |
Douglas
|
Completion Achieved
|
Secter |
Completion,
Accomplished, Peaked |
Feng
|
Already Finished,
Morning After
|
Shaughnessy |
Already Completed
|
Fu Youde |
Fulfillment
|
Shchutskii |
Already at the End
|
Graeme
|
After Completion,
Fording the River
|
Siu |
Tasks Completed
|
Hacker
|
Already Across the
River
|
Sneddon |
Completion
|
Hatcher
|
Already Complete
|
Sorrell |
Climax,
Culmination, Achievement |
Heyboer
|
Already Across
|
Stackhouse |
Attainment of
Order/Harmony, What Next?
|
Hoefler
|
After Completion |
Stein |
Turning the Wheel
(Completions)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Already Fulfilled
|
Sterling |
After Completion
|
Huang, Kerson
|
Fulfillment
|
Sung |
What is Already
Past
|
Javary
|
Everything has to
be Done ?
|
Toropov |
Having Crossed the
Stream
|
Jou
|
Finished
|
Walker, Barbara |
Completion,
Equilibrium
|
Judge
|
Accomplishment
|
Wallace |
After Crossing
|
Karcher
|
Already Fording
|
Wei, Henry |
Successful
Fulfillment
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
After Order
|
West |
Completion |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
After Completion |
Whincup |
Already Across
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
After Completion,
After Crossing the Water
|
Wilhelm |
After Completion |
Kunst |
Already; Cross
Stream
|
Wing |
After the End
|
Legge
|
Successful
Accomplishment
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Already Completed |
Leichtman
|
The Ideal, The
Denouement
|
Wu, Yi |
Completion
|
Liu, Da
|
Completion
|
Wu Wei |
Completion, In
Place, In Order
|
Lynn
|
Ferrying Complete
|
Wu Weifarer |
Already Completed |
Machovec
|
Complacency
|
Young |
Partial ?
Completion
|
Market
|
The Fragile Balance
|
Yu, Titus |
Having Crossed the
River
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Completion |
|
|
McCarver
|
Completion |
十翼 Shi Yi |
定 Ding4,
Resolved, Settled, Arranged |
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
63.M, Key Words
Achieving order or perfection, finalizing,
wrapping up, follow-up, winding down
Final or finishing touches, loose ends; holding
gains against diminishing returns
Completion begins the maintenance, and decay;
safeguarding prior achievements
Epilogue, appendix, anticlimax, segue,
afterthought; issues of past and perfection
Momentum in decay; memory, retrospective,
reminiscence, nostalgia, hindsight
Final steps of the crossing, culmination,
denouement, residuum, losing dynamism
63.G, From the
Glossary
Ji4
(is/are, has/have) after, already, as long as,
at last, entirely, finally, now that,
having,
once, since, upon, when (finished, done), while,
whilst, (to) have done,
attain, complete, be
done with, end, exhaust, finish, get ... done
(s, ed, ing); (to be)
completed, consummated,
de facto, done, finished, past, fixed, certain;
end of
event, particle of perfect tense
Ji4 (to
be) complete, across, done, finished,
accomplished, numerous; stately,
dignified,
beautiful, up to standard; of help, assistance;
across (a, the) stream,
river; (to) complete,
conclude, succeed, finish, fulfill, perfect,
achieve, increase,
accomplish, stop, cease,
ford, cross; (a, the) river, stream; benefit,
assist, aid,
contribute to, help, relieve, save,
overcome an obstacle (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
accomplishment, completion, obstacle overcome
Note:
It's with both tongue-in-cheekiness and irony
that this Gua is placed before the end of the
sequence. It still means that what has consumed
so much of our attention will no longer consume
as much in the same way, but it's time now for
things to start falling apart. It's time to
start maintaining the thing, or start packing
away the memories, or embellishing the tale.
It's time for the anticlimax, or even some
bathos. Lasting perfection is not available to
us. The Tuan Zhuan suggests Dao4 Qiong2, The
Path Peters Out.
|
|
64
未濟
Wèi Jì
|
Gua Ming Authors
Agmuller
|
Before Completion |
MWD - Hatcher |
Same as Received
Text |
Albertson
|
A State of
Transition
|
MWD - Shaughnessy |
Same as Received
Text, #54 |
Balkin |
Before Completion |
Meyer |
Not
Over Yet
|
Barrett
|
Not Yet Across
|
Needham |
Disorder
|
Blofeld
|
Before Completion |
Ni |
Before Crossing the
Water
|
Bonnershaw
|
Unready
|
Palmer |
Not Yet Done
|
Chan Chiu-ming
|
Before Crossing,
Mission to be Accomplished
|
Pattee |
Before Completion |
Chang
|
Timing ?
|
Peden |
Incompletion |
Chu
|
Before Completion |
Perrottet |
Before Completion
|
Chung Wu
|
Mission Yet
Unaccomplished
|
Powell |
Before Climax
|
Clark
|
On the Verge
|
Ra Uru Hu |
Confusion
|
Cleary |
Unsettled,
Unfinished
|
Reifler |
Almost There
|
Coates
|
Nearing Completion
|
Richmond |
Incomplete Change
|
Collins
|
Unfulfillment
|
Richter |
Before Crossing the
River |
Crouch
|
Not Yet Across
|
Riseman |
Before Completion |
Damian-Knight
|
Before Completion |
Ritsema &
Karcher |
Not Yet Fording
|
Dening
|
Nearly Home and Dry
|
Rutt |
Not Yet Across
|
Dhiegh
|
Before Completion,
Not Yet, Yet to Be |
Seabrook |
Before Completion |
Douglas
|
Before Completion |
Secter |
Incompletion,
Unfinished, Optimistic
|
Feng
|
Not Yet Over,
Evening Not Yet Over
|
Shaughnessy |
Not Yet Completed
|
Fu Youde |
Unfulfillment
|
Shchutskii |
Not Yet at the End
|
Graeme
|
Before Completion,
Not Yet Fording |
Siu |
Tasks Yet to be
Completed
|
Hacker
|
Not Yet Across the
River
|
Sneddon |
Before Completion |
Hatcher
|
Not Yet Complete
|
Sorrell |
Second Wind,
Unfinished Business |
Heyboer
|
Not Yet Across |
Stackhouse |
Purity ? of Order
and Harmony
|
Hoefler
|
Prior to Completion
|
Stein |
Turning the Wheel
(Beginnings)
|
Huang, Alfred
|
Not Yet Fulfilled
|
Sterling |
Before Completion |
Huang, Kerson
|
Unfulfillment
|
Sung |
What is Not Yet
Past
|
Javary
|
Everything Needs to
be Done
|
Toropov |
Having Not Yet
Crossed the Stream
|
Jou
|
Unfinished
|
Walker, Barbara |
Incompletion,
Before Ending
|
Judge
|
Transformation
Threshold
|
Wallace |
Before Crossing
|
Karcher
|
Not Yet Fording
|
Wei, Henry |
Incomplete
Fulfillment
|
Kim-Anh Lim
|
Before Order
|
West |
Before Completion |
Koh Kok Kiang
|
Before Completion |
Whincup |
Not Yet Across
|
Kumoyama, Taisen
|
Before Climax,
Unsettled, Uncertainty
|
Wilhelm |
Before Completion |
Kunst |
Not Yet; Cross
stream
|
Wing |
Before the End
|
Legge
|
Accomplishment Not
Yet Realized
|
Wu Jing-Nuan |
Not Yet Completed
|
Leichtman
|
The Actual, Rebirth
|
Wu, Yi |
Non-Completion
|
Liu, Da
|
Before Completion |
Wu Wei |
Not Yet in Order,
Out of Place
|
Lynn
|
Ferrying Incomplete
|
Wu Weifarer |
Not Yet Completed |
Machovec
|
Great Problems,
Great Plans
|
Young |
Before the End
|
Market
|
Success Within
|
Yu, Titus |
Having Not Crossed
the River
|
Marshall, Chris
|
Arrival ?
|
|
|
McCarver
|
Before Completion |
十翼 Shi Yi |
慎辨 Shen4 Bian4,
Prudent Discernment
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
|
720 Cell
64.M, Key Words
Suspense, state of transition, unfinished
business, halfway across, states of change
Uncertainty; sustaining purpose and effort, second
wind, subordination to the goal
Tension between what is and what must be,
elasticity, necessity as a motivation
Dynamic disequilibrium, the energy of
displacement, provisional ends and means
Actualizing potential energy; midcourse maneuvers;
use of stress and momentum
Vigilance, making accidents serve ends; using
uncertainty & insecurity as sources
64.G, From the
Glossary
Wei4
(to be, is, are, has, have) not yet, less than,
still not, yet to (be), as yet (no,
not,
nothing), short/shy of, still (have) (no, not,
short of); not now, now not,
(even) before,
prior to, without, lacking, incomplete; not
(yet) ready (to); never
(a), will never be;
do/did/has/have not; (to) lack, come up/fall
short (in, with, of);
still not be, remain less
than (s, ed, ing); if not yet; negation; no ...
yet, has no ... yet,
not ... yet, has not ...
yet; still / as yet un-; in-, un-; incompletely
Ji4 (to
be) complete, across, done, finished,
accomplished, numerous; stately,
dignified,
beautiful, up to standard; of help, assistance;
across (a, the) stream,
river; (to) complete,
conclude, succeed, finish, fulfill, perfect,
achieve, increase,
accomplish, stop, cease,
ford, cross; (a, the) river, stream; benefit,
assist, aid,
contribute to, help, relieve, save,
overcome an obstacle (s, ed, ing); (a, the)
accomplishment, completion, obstacle overcome
Notes:
Here again we have a statement being made in the
sequence: here we are at the end and still we're
not done yet. It's even left unclear just how
far we still have to go: the words here do not
say "almost across." But this is a wonderfully
dynamic state to be in. If things cannot remain
in this state then they most likely will not:
Natural Law itself pushes us onward. Paying
careful attention is central to the meaning as
well, as both the Tuan and Da Xiang advise. At
least we are built for this: the mind is made to
wake up for novel stimuli, and attention seeks
out the unfamiliar, if only in order to pin
everything down and go back to sleep. It isn't
likely that the meaning is derived from the
concept of the "incorrectness of an odd line in
an even place." More probably it derives from
the Bagua, Fire over Water, Attention and
Intelligence over Risk and Hazard.
|
|
720 Cell
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Introduction
The Yi tells us that a
good Cauldron needs a good handle, that a good
Well needs a long enough rope and a bucket
that doesn't leak. In both cases, these
symbols are most useful when they are
accessible, when they can be grasped, when you
can get a grip, and when you can retrieve what
you need from the ground or the fire. The Gua
Ming or Hexagram Name is the first and most
obvious way to get a grip on the coherent sets
of ideas that each of the Hexagrams
represents. It is therefore to our advantage
to clear up some of the great confusion that
has grown up around them.
It might be useful to
introduce this within an outline of the five
main areas or branches of Yixue or Yi Studies,
with the most time spent on the second, Core
Meanings, of which Gua Ming is a subset. This
is also an opportunity to lay groundwork and
offer some context and concepts for a broader
grasp of the subject.
1) Cumulative Experience. This begins
when someone first tosses the coins and might
lead all the way up to the writing of books on
the subject, and then, if fortune smiles,
rewriting those books with more wisdom later.
This is a body of personal knowledge that can
take many decades to build and consume many
thousands of hours. It is also easy to waste a
great deal of this time in following less than
excellent leads or studying frivolous
approaches. Here are three ideas that may help
in our understanding of this problem:
Bricolage: Construction
or creation from a diverse range of available
things. We build our bodies of knowledge as we
go, with what we find at hand. Unless there is
a set curriculum for the long term, as there
is with some skills or trades, a body of
knowledge is normally a personal thing,
personalized in the layering of newer
experience over older layers. But this is
often like laying a foundation before we know
what the building is going to look like.
Looking back over the process of creation,
with what we know now, we would not likely
have built the thing the same way. It would
have been done more rationally and been better
planned. Many classic examples of bricolage
are found in our cultural and technological
evolution. The odd number of feet in a mile
comes from a thousand double paces of a Roman
army on the march, and yet as irrational as
the number 5280 is now, the United States
refuses to adopt the much easier metric
system. There is too much cultural inertia.
Even the distance between modern railroad
tracks derives from Roman chariot wheels. We
have a ridiculous alphabet, that derived from
a long line of other ridiculous alphabets, but
we won't supplant it with a better system of
phonetic representation. no matter how much
this would add to our literacy. We go on
making spelling a huge challenge, with more
exceptions than rules. The Kabbalists, instead
of investigating the wonders of human
language, are stuck with trying to justify
their own silly alphabet as the mysterious
anatomy of HaShem.
Confirmation
Bias. Favoring information that confirms our
preconceptions or hypotheses. As a body of
knowledge builds it gains in inertia or
resistance to change as well. We will tend to
turn away, often with prejudice, from any new
source of information that offers explicit
hints of a conflict with our beliefs, and we
will reinterpret both our experience and our
memories to confirm what we already think we
know. This is why bodies of knowledge often
evolve in fits and starts: the contradictory
data first needs to build up enough pressure
to overwhelm the standard models. This is
related to the larger idea of apperceptive
mass, the whole of a person's previous
experience that is used in understanding a new
percept or idea. This in turn helps to explain
why the Yi calls it "worthwhile to cross the
great stream,' extolling the virtues of
getting outside of ourselves and our familiar
niches, of getting a new, more global
perspective.
Unlearning. To expunge,
erase, delete, efface, or overwrite something
that we once thought was the answer. This is
much harder than learning, partially because
it is so hard on our egos. We have made an
investment that may need to be accounted as a
loss, and we fear that this means being
accounted a fool. We have wired uncountable
neuronal connections into our wetware. How do
you unwire this? You can only pay greater
attention to something better, and this means
you may first need to recognize or acknowledge
something better. This is from experience. I
wrote my first Yijing book in 1976, and it
took a dozen years to be thankful that it
never got published. Due to rising personal
standards over the next thirty years I had to
rewrite the whole thing three more times.
These weren't simple revisions. Each time
meant many dozens, even hundreds, of instances
where I had to put the stink-eye on some
favorite passage or insight I'd written down
and admit "Boy howdy, did I ever have that one
all wrong." I still have a nice folder full of
orphaned witticisms that have nothing at all
to do with the Yi. This is why I don't feel
entirely unqualified to make this statement:
Most of the kids who are playing in this field
would be well-served by setting aside or even
discarding most of what they think they "know"
about the Yi and starting over, with
beginner's mind, a few guiding principles, a
little logic and critical thinking, a handful
of reputable translations and commentaries and
access to the Chinese text. Maybe one could
think of any years of study invested before
this new start as warmup or practice for a
real run at the problem. This does not mean
that things discarded or set aside now cannot
be later recovered, after an honest
reexamination. But the human mind, after
making even a minor and half-hearted
investment in study, wants to think it's "been
there and done that" and now it's all figured
out and time to get praised for its wisdom,
while the Yi just shakes an imaginary head at
such foolishness. It's hard sometimes to upend
the Cauldron. We feel compelled to defend our
invested opinions even from ourselves. I have
long suspected that the name Changes was
actually an inside joke for the authors.
The book changes as we grow.
What the above three
ideas suggest is a caution and a conservatism
in study that feels utterly alien to a hungry,
young mind. Who wants to start on somebody
else's 'right track' and stay there?
Carefulness is something you learn later, not
when you are starting out and are immortal and
know everything. The best we aging classicists
can do is point to the rock and roll gods who
began with classical music training at
Julliard. This is all about having a good
foundation, built in a meaningful place, and a
good working knowledge of the pre-invented
wheels available to us. This can advance us
more quickly to the creative frontier.
The point of this is not
to discourage branching out in the subject, or
to prune everything down to a single trunk.
The subject of the Yi is still not close to
being fully surrounded. There is still a lot
of room for individual expression and
creativity. But very few of the unique and
original contributions are supported on
foundations built out on the lunatic fringe of
the field. The original thinkers' points of
view are still at their most valuable when
they contribute to our understanding of what
the Yijing is about at its core: clarifying
the human experience in a methodical,
comprehensive and communicable way. A
classical foundation in Yixue uses a
vocabulary that has been developed over
millennia and is shared by most of its serious
students. Out on the fringe new ideas can be
discovered or made, and new words for them
coined, but the one who develops his own
entire vocabulary will usually just wind up
babbling to himself, or at best found a
short-lived school that is soon forgotten.
Many people have had
success writing books on the Yijing for the
mass market and yet have needed to exercise no
judgement whatsoever on the quality of their
input materials. They will still be
well-praised on the back cover. And others
have reached their Autumn years with a great
body of cumulative experience that for reasons
of peer pressure and peer review has been
limited to sources in the academic world. At
most the academics have been allowed one point
of dissent from the body of consensual
understanding, which of course would be the
thesis they are tasked to defend. Ironically,
it's at these two extremes, and not the middle
way, where the social acceptance lies. Pity
the fool who writes a critical book with
multiple original ideas for intelligent
readers.
The bottom line is this:
respect your brain, if not the tradition:
garbage in, garbage out. The recommendation:
start or restart the studies with
well-respected books in the field, and with
carefully done translations of the original
text instead of knockoffs and gimmick books
written for mass-market, new age beginners.
Get a good grounding in the original before
studying the commentaries, or else read the
commentaries with a much more critical eye.
They will at best provide only a slice of a
text's overall meaning, like a blind man's
description of the elephant.
2) Core Meanings.
Imagine a large, extremely complex piece of
terrain that you want to divide into 64
parcels or homesites according to their nature
or characteristics. The landscape has
something for every taste or type: cliff to
flat, inundated to desert, old-growth forest
to mined-out wasteland, tropical to arctic.
You can't really use a rigid grid, although
many might try, and you can't really draw
clear, sharp lines between the between the
parcels because ecotones, like analogies,
usually have fuzzy edges. Let's call this
terrain "The Human Experience." You will do
this mapping using a number of survey stakes
for each of the tracts. This point looks like
a 13, tap, tap, tap, even though somebody else
on the crew has hammered in a 37 stake too
close by. That one can be sorted out later.
Let's do a few passes first and see where this
wants to take us, in Aboriginal terms, to see
what this land wants to dream.
This process evolves
over a long period of time and you see the
patterns start to emerge, even though the
patterns still have their fuzzy parts, and too
many bozos are just running around setting
stakes according to channeled and psychic
advice instead of studying the land. If you
can ignore this last bunch, which means using
your judgment and suspecting that not
everybody's "truth" is equally valid, then you
can at least start drawing conclusions about
the core descriptions of each parcel, those areas
where there are the fewest ambiguities,
trespasses and boundary disputes.
From there, to there, to there, is all
unquestionably 13. Each of the 64 zones of the
Human Experience has a number of identifiers,
key words, in Chinese and from other languages
all around the world, buzz words, cultural
memes, even music jingles and artwork.
Ultimately you cannot pick just one or two of
the stakes for a comprehensive description:
those stakes define points and lines, not the
field. The full collection of
these concentrated and least-ambiguous
descriptors, those with the least overlap, the
entire suitcase full, is what we will be
calling the Core Meaning. The grip or handle
on that suitcase is the Gua Ming. It is
selected from the amongst larger collection.
It wants to be taken from very close to the
center, for good balance. It also wants to
imply as much as it can of the rest of the
contents. Above all, it does not want to be
mistaken for the handle of another suitcase.
A Gestalt is an
organized whole that is perceived as more than
the sum of its parts. When a collection of
associations and points of reference reaches a
critical mass it will seem to take on a life
of its own, an emergent dimension of wholeness
that exceeds the parts in its content. It is
no longer a set of discrete points in a field:
it becomes a field containing a set of
discrete points. We are now able to set our
own stakes, and where these are set between
two known points, we can have a higher degree
of confidence in them. We can start to tell
stories that connect the dots. Creativity is
engaged. The word Core comes from the word
heart. When we get to the heart of the matter
we see it come to life. Core Meanings are
deceptively simple but they are also
multidimensional gestalts that require a great
deal of time and patience to ponder and
understand. The gestalts contain the words of
the text, the meanings and implications
intended by the authors, the gleanings to be
had by examining the dimensions of meaning and
construction that were actually used by the
authors, a large number of cultural references
and historical allusions, a number of insights
to be had from wordplay and the etymologies of
Chinese words, and a number of different
levels of depth. Many of these components are
things that some author somewhere has praised
at the "key to it all," but I think they work
best in combination, just as the gestalt is
more than the sum of its parts.
Ramified meanings, as
distinct from Core Meanings, are much more
elaborated, numerous and complex. They come
from several sources: the Wing commentaries,
newer dimensions like "correctness" and even
yin-yang theory, invented by later scholars,
redactions good and bad, translations good and
bad, commentaries good and bad, and one's own
personal body of experience gleaned from
feedback in divination. The biggest problems
with ramified meanings are low signal-to-noise
ratio and their heavy reliance on pure
imagination out at the far periphery of a
text's usefulness in divining our world. The
text meanings really get stretched in the
process of answering some questions, and these
stretched meanings can be far from central or
germane. They're just too flabby. All of that
is in addition to there just being a whole lot
of utter crap in print out there. It's in the
search for a core meaning that we can hold
forth the criteria we need to judge the
difference between the good and the useless:
otherwise what do we use to weigh the value of
what we pick up, besides whether or not it's
something we want to hear?
To use another analogy
(which we do a lot of in this field), think of
Core Meanings as our stem cells and the
ramified meanings as the hundreds of kinds of
differentiated cells that we have in our
bodies. Note that when life goes to propagate
an organism it does not build one by starting
with large numbers of pre-differentiated
cells. One single cell is enough every time to
make the entire organism. There is a great
economy in that process. Similarly, when you
have the core meaning of a text you don't have
to drag a massive amount of baggage to the
reading. The core meaning is your swiss army
knife. That they are easier to use, however,
does not make them easier to find, and
impatience is the big problem here, the
inability to sit still and let the Yi speak
and its meanings form slowly. Most students
take the opposite approach and when the deeper
meanings don't jump out at them right away,
off they go chasing this or that Xiangshu
dimension or calendar correspondence or
new-and-improved method of interpretation.
They do more to avoid the meaning than seek
it. And they do this without any real criteria
to weigh the value of what they find. People
have been talking nonsense about the Yi for so
long that folks now expect it not to make any
sense, as if it's supposed to sound
mysterious, cryptic and unintelligible. Modern
scholarship has only made this problem worse
with its twitching captives and grunting
hamsters.
There are three main
alternatives in selecting a Gua Ming to
represent the Core Meaning or gestalt. The
first is to simply use the Chinese term and
allow it to have all of the associations that
our cumulative experience affords it. Learn to
pronounce it properly, though, or suffer some
embarrassment later. The second choice is to
translate the name literally, using the most
comprehensive and informative glosses
available. The third is to translate it
according to the central theme of the Gua, or
to translate what it means instead of what it
says. Take 15, Qian, for instance, frequently
named Modesty. The word is used throughout the
text in contexts best translated with the word
Modesty. But in these contexts the Zhouyi is
being highly critical of the pretentious,
disingenuous self-effacement that is Modesty
as commonly misunderstood, Modesty that seeks
to make everything equally mediocre and
unworthy. In fact, this Gua is recommending
Authenticity, to understand and appreciate
things exactly as they are, even if if this
means calling attention to some truly great
thing that you have done. Authenticity is
marginal as a literal gloss for Qian, just as
Modesty is marginal as a name for 15's deeper
meaning. It becomes a question of personal
taste. My own choice was to be as literal as I
could but insist that the deeper meaning come
through, particularly since I still had the
ability to translate the word literally in
rendering the remainder of the text.
A large number of the
Gua can be named easily and perfectly in
English, notably: Following, Biting Through,
Returning, Decreasing, Increasing, The Well,
The Cauldron and Gradual Progress. Ironically,
this can be a real problem. These names may
need to have their envelopes stretched quite a
bit in order to accommodate the broad range of
meanings that they are intended to encompass.
We need to recover the diversity within that
simplicity. Sometimes we really need to climb
inside theses words and spend some time
walking around in them to see where they take
us. It might be helpful, for example, to read
a couple of articles on how to build and
maintain a Well, while looking closely for any
metaphorical or analogical connections that
might present themselves. This is second best
to physically climbing down into a well during
a drought and cleaning it out. Then
you will really understand the first two
lines.
Many people never get
beyond what the given Gua Ming alone tells
them. If it is suggestive of something bad or
negative, then this Gua is bad or negative and
you don't want to draw it in a reading. It may
not even matter to them what the text says
after this. But as long as someone is locked
into thinking of any Gua as inherently
positive or negative they will never
understand the Yijing. The Yi itself tries to
explain this in a number of places: Gua 12 is
an opportunity to be rid of inferior
influences; Gua 41 is a chance to learn the
skills of economy, thrift and gratitude that
will make you truly rich when the times turn
around, if not before; Gua 39 is a chance to
look sideways from linear thinking and
goal-seeking behavior, to seize upon what we
might have missed; Gua 05 learns to live in
the moment and maximize the meantime. And so
on. Aleister Crowley put it this way: "Imagine
listening to a Beethoven concerto with the
presupposition that C is a bad note and F is a
good one. You would clearly miss the music."
Good hexagrams vs bad hexagrams is shallow
thinking that completely misses the
multi-dimensional richness of understanding
that the Yi has to offer. One way to get out
of the habit is to start asking the question
"What is the upside of this?" when we think we
have a "bad" reading, and just as importantly,
"What is the downside of this?" when we think
we have a "good" one. The same goes for the
lines. It helps a lot to think of every line
as representing a choice of attitudes, not a
literal prediction, but a recommended posture
that is often implied by the depiction of an
inferior posture. So if the character in the
line is in trouble and getting his nose cut
off, we try to remember that our question is
about where we are going: we should use this
information and simply decide not to go to a
place like that where they are apt to cut off
your nose.
Finally, it should be
noted that having the core meaning might not
be in the least bit useful in understanding a
particular reading in the context of divining.
The response that is being sought in the
divination process might just as easily be
found in a particularly bad translation or
commentary, or in an entrenched
misunderstanding in our personal body of
knowledge, or in some private association we
have to some random word in the text, or in
reading the wrong page, or even in the page
number. Having the core meaning might increase
the odds of discovery somewhat in the
divination context, but it's more to the point
that its study increases the understanding
itself, or the odds thereof. It is not the
end: merely the most fruitful place to begin. In the
context of divination it may help
to think of the Core Meaning as the base or
headquarters of an organized search, or the
center of an organized search pattern. The
answer to a question might ultimately be found
out on the Easternmost fringe of the Ramified
Meanings, but starting in the center will in
the long run give better results that
consistently starting somewhere on the
Westernmost fringe.
3) Zhouyi Yili. The term Yili, Yi +
Li, is perhaps best translated as Meaning and
Principle. Zhouyi Yili is the study of the
Zhouyi text for its meaning and utility, or
for its psychological, behavioral and ethical
advice. It's relevance to Gua Ming and Core
Meanings is obvious. This is often contrasted
with another branch, Xiangshu, Image and
Number (see below), that looks instead at the
Yi's mathematical and geometrical structures.
In short, Yili asks what the Zhouyi or its
authors were trying to tell us: what meanings
they were intending to convey. We run
instantly afoul here of several of the popular
waves of contemporary philosophy, notably,
post-modernism, post-structuralism and
deconstructionism: "Communication is imperfect
and unreliable, even a myth. We can never know
what the authors were intending to tell us.
Cultural differences render everything
mutually unintelligible. We must avoid that
slippery slope and all fuzzy logic and dismiss
the unreliable. With the authors and their
so-called intentions now out of the picture,
the only meaning we have left to us is in what
the words do to us and what we make of that,
as solipsists." Fortunately, students of Yixue
are steeped in a tradition that goes back
three-thousand years and across this span we
can see three-thousand years of wreckage of
fads and fashions such as these, strewn behind
the words of the text and their intended
meanings, even when some of these fads hang on
and hold majority and "official" support for
centuries. There may be more slip-ups and
pratfalls in using the slippery slope
fallacies than there are on the slick slopes
themselves. Humor me and assume this for now:
the authors intended the text to have meanings
and those meanings can be at least partially
recovered, even in distant times and cultures.
If language wasn't adequate to share meanings,
then we would not have human culture. That
there is no such thing as perfect, objective
meaning doesn't mean there is no such thing as
meaning, or that some meaning cannot be
shared.
However meaningful, the
texts of the Zhouyi are not made to any kind
of point. They are not like instructions for
baking a cake. They were intended to serve as
responses to a nearly infinite variety of
questions that had not been asked yet.
Obviously there was a lot of ambiguity and
ambivalence that had to be built into the
text. Any meaning there was would need to be
of the plastic or stretchable kind. I have
elsewhere made the distinction between
vertical and horizontal ambiguity. In the
former is the flexibility to reframe and jump
to new points of view and levels of
abstraction, the latter is simply the
potential to be self-contradictory. The Yi's
great strength is in the former. It does,
however, play with the latter in one important
respect: the situations depicted in the Gua
and the Lines always represent as much of a
choice as they do a prediction, omen or
oracle. As stated above, there is no good or
bad per se.
If a scene depicted in a text illustrates dire
happenstance or consequences, even if no
alternative is discussed, then the advice may
be still be taken as a warning to avoid such a
scene, or plan a better way out. A
particularly harsh or frightful "prediction"
does no more than say: Look how bad this could
get if you're really stupid. You can avoid
this by not being stupid, and what a sublime
success that would be! On the other hand, the
promise of a promising outcome is also a
picture of what you have to lose here if you
manage to screw up the time. The Yi's answer,
in the end, is always: Do this, or don't, but
look at the options. Aside from this use, the
Yi's ambiguity is made for reframing our
perceptions and perspectives.
The human mind,
and specifically, our associative cortex, is
truly astounding in its ability to make some
kind of sense and meaning out of just about
anything. This does not, of course, mean that
this sense and meaning have any connection to
reality, even internally. But evolution seems
to have constructed our minds around the
ability to make connections and associations.
When we draw forms and information from
dimensionless fields, such as a whiteout, a
ganzfeld, or white noise, we call the talent
Apophenia. When we draw forms and information
from mere or simple suggestions of form, as
with tea leaves, entrails and clouds, we call
the talent Pareidolia. The Yi is located just
a short way up this scale from pareidolia: the
images and stimuli it uses have considerably
more original order than clouds, at least
after the decades of study required for the
images to make any sense. Skeptics may well
level charges of ambiguity and pareidolia at
the divinatory arts, but this need not be a
call to some kind of defense. I suspect that
these charges should be embraced as a partial
description of how the divinatory process
works. It makes use of the human mind in a
manner consistent with some of its basic
cognitive processes. Apophenia and
Pareidolia can make use of an active interface
between the suggestion of form and meaning and
elements of the sub-conscious just waiting for
a little illumination.
Metaphor has had a lot of
critics over the centuries. Scientists,
engineers and philosophers like to look down
their noses at it: It's a liberal art, a mere
humanity, something for fuzzy-minded poets.
It's imprecise and playful. Not only that,
it's a cultural artifact, and one that comes
late into human culture. In fact, many of the
Yixue scholars in academia might assert that
this literary device was still culturally
unavailable to the authors of the Zhouyi.
Instead, they had a kind of concrete, naive
realism. The images that they used were merely
substitutes for seeing actual omens in real
life, to be interpreted according to the
simple superstitions of the day. Perhaps if
they looked a little beyond their noses they
could also fail to see metaphor in the Book of
Odes or Poetry, a contemporary of the Zhouyi.
To use a metaphor here: this is just horse
shit. Cognitive neuroscience has been very
busy, for some decades now, destroying the
smug pretensions of metaphor's critics and
finding metaphor at the very heart of the
great bulk of human ideation,
conceptualization and language, even up to and
including that last bastion of Platonic
perfection, mathematics. Conceptual metaphors,
constructed largely of sense memories or
sensorimotor schemas, are the building blocks
of much of our thought. And to make things
extra sloppy and poetical, when we recall some
sensory datum to use in our lofty world of
ideas, we are dragging the contents of our
emotional recall along with it. Up a notch in
scale, we create the larger structures of our
thought by comparing analogies, crossing
domains to other fields, in search of
consilience. Joseph Needham's disdain for
correlative thought as a barrier to science
ultimately falls apart, even though his
examples of its failures are well-chosen.
There is more to argument from analogy and
correlative thought than science would like to
admit. We get our idea of force from
kinesthetic receptors in our muscles, of
particles from our vision and touch. And where
we lack the sense to make sense of things, as
with reconciling the particle-wave paradox, or
imagining dark matter and energy, or seeing
time being space turned sideways, or getting
our heads around spooky-action-at-a-distance,
we just seem to flounder and start licking
ourselves like frustrated cats.
One of the theses here
is that the pictures painted by the words of
the Zhouyi text are intended as metaphors for
broader cognitive and behavioral patterns in
the human repertoire. We can use the word
metaphor here as a synecdoche for the whole
range of comparative literary devices: sign,
symbol, euphemism, archetype, metaphor,
simile, caricature, synecdoche, analogy,
parable, model, allegory, up to and including
whole correlative systems of thought. A word
on archetypes is in order here, since Carl
Jung's thought has been so much abused in this
field of Yixue (let's not get started on
synchronicity). Jung described these
archetypal images as inherited, and therefore
encoded within our genetics, shared by the
species as a whole, and originally
unconscious, or originating in some sort of
collective or shared unconscious. It is
embarrassing how many people in our field jump
in a single hop from collective unconscious to
universal consciousness and see the archetypes
"out there" as some sort of Platonic ideals
floating around in a more perfect world.
Closer, I suspect, to what Jung meant (and to
some degree stated) is that we are genetically
predisposed or have inherited predilections to
sort our experiences according to specific
social roles and behavioral categories that
relate to getting our specific (Maslovian)
needs met. The roles are the social types
vital to our survival in the tribe: mothers,
fathers, siblings, elders, allies, heroes,
bullies, cowards, alphas, sycophants, infants,
etc; and the categories are behavioral types:
treachery, alliance, xenophobia, seduction,
dominance, flattery, obligation, commiseration,
submission, grooming, etc. As our
lives progress we will flesh these
predilections out with our cumulative
experience into coherent models. The mechanism
is still unknown, but it is assumed that this
must be simple enough to encode genetically
and in no way confuse the orangutans, chimps,
bonobos and gorillas that seem to be born with
them.
These archetypal models
are at least as numerous and complex in humans
as those that we see in the behaviors of
"unschooled" primate societies. There is
clearly much more to primate social
organization than the culture of the tribe.
This collection lives primarily in the old
primate brain that we all still share. There
are slight differences between species, as
with gestures and facial expressions, but in
general there is enough common ground even
here for a basic mutual understanding. Those
who have spent significant periods of time
"across the great stream," as the Yi exhorts
us to do, know that humans across the globe
have much common ground, despite our cultural
differences. Now, just as cognitive
neuroscience is exploding our snooty ideas
about metaphor being inferior to the purer
forms of conceptualization, evolutionary
psychology is "deconstructing" many of our
recently cherished notions of the human mind
as a tabula
rasa and human culture as primarily
or fundamentally relativistic. We are
beginning to inquire again into the structure
of human nature, and to ask what parts of our
behavior still underlie the diversity of our
cultures. The pendulum is returning with some
cogent force. Cultural variation on innate or
native themes still represents most of the
data to be sorted here, but even this is no
longer the polemic of nurture over nature that
has occupied us of late. We are better
prepared to see blends and interactions of the
two.
If we can hope that the
Core Meanings refer to more universal or
archetypal roles and behaviors, then we can
start looking for broader applicability as a
sign that our comprehension is nearing the
core. The Yi's images are often concrete and
specific, using the nouns in our everyday
life. Given the range of questions to be asked
of these "answers," we can only assume that
these are symbolic and metaphorical, and only
on occasion to be taken literally. References
to women, for example, and the damage they can
do, are frequently symbolic of larger
processes in life. For example, the
distractions from our higher purposes and
commitments, that seem to come upon us at the
least convenient times, to undermine all of
our better values and leave us dissipated,
have no better symbol that that of an
unexpected encounter with a hot seductress.
Gua 44 is about these distractions, the threat
of dissipation in general, and the need to
exercise some restraint. Sometimes this can
can refer to a real woman. But it can also be
a bribe, or greener grass somewhere. To take
the metaphor literally, and then compound the
error by thinking this Gua is all about
women's liberation, is to miss the core
completely. A gestalt is quite different from
having a definitive explanation of what the
line means. It does not stand around the
outside of the meaning, it occupies it from
within. It represents an outlook on life, with
as many variations are there are paths to be
traveled. We cannot do that by seeing the
images as concrete things before us.
The above brings us to
the question: What proportion of the metaphors
(etc) used by the Zhouyi's authors were
specific to the culture they lived in, and how
many pointed to more universal human
archetypal roles and behaviors? A clue might
be found in the book's three-thousand years of
continuous popularity, to which we can now add
a couple of centuries of leaps into widely
different cultures and significant popularity
even there. There is a resonance in this
popularity that reaches far beyond early Zhou
culture. Further, for those of us who can
imagine the authors trying to share meanings,
and not simply to appear profound and obscure,
we can imagine them wanting to offer something
that we could recognize. To the extent that
they were trying to communicate, they would
have been looking for universals and common
ground. And to the extent that these authors
knew that their composition was itself
evolving over the span of a couple of
centuries, they may have been looking for
images that sustained their relevance in the
face of local cultural changes. That is, they
may have wanted to minimize cultural
relativity in favor of human universals. Now,
obviously, the images are culturally nuanced,
and not lightly either. The meanings of the
Zhouyi's images absolutely require a study of
their culture of origin, and preferably of the
earlier versions of the language as well. But
this hypothesis at least opens a door for
psychology, neuroscience, sociology, economics
and anthropology to have a peek inside.
Finally, there is an unevenness to the actual
length of Zhouyi texts, which will vary from
two characters to a couple of dozen. I have
elsewhere asked if this might be due to
centuries of attrition, prior to the book's
canonization. It could be that any chunks of
texts that were dropped over the years were
simply not universal enough, that they were
too culturally relativistic and had become
less relevant, leaving the more universally
relevant images behind.
It has been fashionable
for many decades now (at least since
Shchutskii in the 1920's) to point out that
the Zhouyi texts were written in two or more
layers, with an assumption that these layers
were set down at different times by different
people. The first is referred to as a
divination text or mantic formula (the various
prognostications and exhortations) and their
predecessors may be found in OBI's or Shang
Dynasty oracle bone inscriptions. The second
was referred to by Waley (1933) as "omen or
peasant interpretation texts," which texts are
the metaphors we refer to here. I have called
this whole hypothesis into question (Vol. I,
pp 6-8) and suggested at least holding an
opposing view open: that the texts were
written across the same span of time, by the
same group of people, but drawing upon
elements of vocabulary from a couple of
separate sources. This alternative, even if it
fails to be upheld, has an additional
advantage: it asks us to examine the entire
Gua or Line text as an integrated, continuous,
seamless whole, knitted together, with a
comprehensive gestalt or core meaning that
accounts for every single word of the text. It
asks us to try refusing to see the texts as
disjointed conglomerates of independent
statements. Even if this only turns out to be
an exercise in pareidolia and creative
stitchery, it has turned out a lot of
rewarding results in my own studies. There is
a converse of this as well: if our grasp of
the Core Meaning fails to enable us to stitch
every word in the text together as a unified
whole, then we have a sign that we still have
work to do on our gestalt, that our puzzle is
still missing pieces. All of the words, every
single word, should make sense. And multiple
statements made within a line should not
appear to be disjointed or separate
utterances. If the phrase "No Blame" follows a
metaphor, it will be clear why those words
were used. If a minor word or particle doesn't
seem to fit then you don't have the core
meaning. You can't just do like Rutt and
others and ignore the particles when they
don't fit in with your big idea. Old Chinese
grammar is more fluid and flexible than ours,
but it is real and every word of the text
serves a purpose.
Contrary to the rules observed
by modernist scholars, and the ironically
named "context criticism," it is a legitimate
exercise to use the context of the Yi to
understand the Yi, the context of the word to
understand the word, and the concordances of
the words as they are used throughout the text
to understand their often varying meanings
throughout the text.
Each of the Yi's 384 Yao
Ci or Line Texts has a Core Meaning or gestalt
as well, but although they have a nomenclature
(e. g. 01.1 zhi
24 or 01.1>24) nobody has ever tried to
name them. We can make good use of a
reciprocal relationship between these and
those of the Gua in developing both. Perhaps a
majority of readers seem to lose sight of the
overall meaning of the Gua the minute they
start reading the Lines, forgetting that the
Lines depict specific facets or expressions of
the Gua's overarching meaning. A lot of
confusion in the lines can be cleared up
simply by getting out of this habit. For our
purposes here, this can be made to work in
reverse: we can take what we understand of the
Line Texts and uses this to stretch our
understanding of the Gua. Here again we have a
converse to use: If our Core Meaning for a Gua
does not help to explain a Line, or if a Line
text does not seem like a natural expression
of the overall Gua theme, then the we still
have work to be done in comprehending that
theme.
Finally, there is another
fashionable claim in circulation that the
Zhouyi was originally intended strictly as a
divination manual, but a couple of centuries
into its existence it began to be used as a
more philosophical text. It is left to the
reader to conclude that the Zhouyi somehow
changed or at least broadened its intended and
original purpose some time after its
completion or some time after its authors had
died. A lot of readers seem to buy that, since
it keeps getting repeated. It is never pointed
out the the authors may have had other things
in mind beyond simple divination and it just
took the readers a few short centuries to
figure this out. That's easier to swallow than
them changing their original intentions two
centuries into the future. Obviously, serving
the King and his court with a new and
simplified way of divining was the Yi's raison
d'être. But that alone fails to explain the
broader ethical and psychological
applicability of the work. The authors were
also trying to teach future Kings.
4) Xiangshu. The Image and Number
school, that contrasts so readily with Yili
above, looks to the elements of structure of
the diagrams for either a separate layer of
meaning from
, or an explanation of how the words of the
text originally came about. I have used the
terms Dimensions and Algorithms for these
structural elements. Those that can be
considered most germane to Yixue are scoped in
my Book of
Changes, Vol. 2, The Dimensions, and
can be grouped into three categories: 1)
Zhouyi dimensions, or those that the original
authors appear to have had access to, 2) Wing
dimensions, or those introduced in the Yi's
Ten Wings, and 3) Han Yiweishu dimensions, or
those which were introduced in the large body
of Han apocryphal writings on the Yi. This
last field is practically unlimited and is
subject to analysis as far reaching as that of
binary mathematics itself. But our concern
here is with the relevance of the Dimensions
to the Core Meanings of the Gua and ultimately
to the Gua Ming that have to summarize these.
The question is: Which dimensions help to
define the Core Meanings of the Gua? Of those
that I have surveyed there is only a limited
number and nearly all of them belong in the
first category of Zhouyi dimensions. Volume II
has more detail on most of these.
One aspect of the Yi's
Dimensions is never pointed out, even for
those that were used by the original authors:
not one of them seems to have been used with
any sort of rigid or unflagging consistency.
The authors had some structure to begin with
and a number of Dimensions as tools to create
with, tools that helped them to find useful
words and metaphors to shape the larger ideas.
They seemed to have used these tools when
convenient and not use them when inconvenient.
This of course makes it difficult to prove
their use, and it takes some punch out of
arguments that dimensions invented later were
not used, simply because they lack statistical
significance. More fuzzy edges. Absence
of evidence is not evidence of absence.
Gua Xiang, or the
Hexagram Image, sometimes called Gua Xing, or
Hexagram Shape, is the purest and most
obvious, but as a dimension of the Core
Meaning it is only found in some of the Gua.
Simply put, this is where the shape of a Gua
suggests the main idea: 27 as an open mouth,
50 as a Cauldron, 01 as a Mountain that is too
tall and narrow for its own long-term good, 62
as a bird in flight.
Yao Wei, or Line
Position. Gua with a solitary solid or broken
line can often be interpreted using
traditional associations with the position
that the line is found in. Singletons in Line
5, for example, might speak of leadership
qualities, or at least add the subject of
leadership qualities to the Core Meaning. The
utility of this dimension is fairly limited to
a few Gua, but it may have planted the seed
for the Han Yiweishu dimension of Governing
and Constituting Lines. Governing and
Constituting Lines, however, seems to be no
more than one man's idea of which lines stood
out the most to him: they have no mystical
powers.
Ban Xiang, or the
Half-Images. The relationship between the two
Bagua as they are situated in the Lower and
Upper (or Zhen and Hui) positions is one of
the more important, even though there is a
school (or university) of thought that claims
the Bagua were unknown to the Zhouyi authors.
This dimension is well-explored in the Da
Xiang, a part of the Wings, which derives
ethical advice and meaning for each of the Gua
based on its constituent Bagua in the two
positions. I consider this text to be on a par
with the Zhouyi itself when it comes to being
meaningful. In looking at the Da Xiang from
within the core Meaning, the relationship
between the interacting Ba Gua in upper and
lower places can be felt viscerally and
topologically and the ethical or behavioral
advice that follows will appear to be a
logical conclusion. Conversely, until this
text seems to follow logically from the Bagua
configuration, the gestalt is still missing
input.
Qian Gua, or the Inverse
Pairs, also known as Fu Gua, Dian Gua, etc.
While the full sequence of the Hou Tian, Later
Heaven, Wen Wang Xu, or King Wen Sequence is
not any more significant or meaningful than
any exercise in pareidolia, the thirty-two
pairs within this sequence did contribute to
the development of Gua meaning, some in very
meaningful ways. Twenty-eight of these pairs
are the inverse of each other. By name the
most obvious pair is 41-42,
Decreasing-Increasing. Others are reasonably
clear: 37-38, Family Members and Estrangement,
for example. The pair 19-20 is actually
mentioned in the Zhouyi text by the Lunar
months they represent (see below). The pair
63-64 is significant in several of the
structural dimensions. And some pairs simply
await the student's exercise in comparison to
reveal their mysteries: 43-44, Decisiveness or
Resolution and Dissipation for example.
Pang Tong Gua, or the
Opposite Pairs, also known as Bian Gua, etc.
Four pairs within the received sequence are
symmetrical and thus are the inverse of
themselves, and so they are paired in the
sequence with their Opposites. Here too their
Core Meanings help to mutually derive from
each other as complementary opposites: 01-02
as Heaven and Earth, 29-30 as Water and Fire
are the most obvious examples, but 61-62 as
self-importance and unimportance has much to
offer for a little digging. We'll leave 27-28
as an exercise.
Chong Gua, or the
Doubled Bagua. The eight Bagua or Trigrams
each have Gua where they are doubled and even
share their names. However, the meanings of
the Gua are more complex, and learning in what
way they are more complex makes a very
interesting study or exercise. In short, this
Gua is usually a learning or growing
experience, over time. The characteristic
energy of the Bagua becomes self-aware and
changes by way of a feedback process.
Shi Er Di Zhi or the
Twelve earthly Branches. Although most of the
Calendar associations to the Gua were derived
much later, Twelve of the Gua were associated
with the 12 Months of the Year from a very
early date, and the time of year that each
represents makes a significant contribution
towards understanding many of these Gua. The
relationship of 19-20, mentioned above, is
found in the text itself. 24 is explicitly
associated with the Winter Solstice.
Of all of the Wing
dimensions, the only one that I find remotely
significant for the Gua Ming is that of
Correctness, that a Yang line belongs in an
odd place, and here only in a couple of Gua,
notably 63 & 64. But even this may be
begging a question since the origin of
Correctness as a dimension may actually have
derived from the meanings of 63 & 64.
There is certainly no statistical evidence in
the text that a line has a better auspice for
being in the "correct" place.
5) Yixue Commentary Tradition. The
long Zhouyi commentary tradition begins in
theory in 671 BCE with the first Zuozhuan
reading and would encompass all pre-Qin
divination accounts, all external cultural
references, and finally the Shi Yi or Ten
Wings that were incorporated with the Zhouyi
in 136 BCE as the Yijing Canon. The Yijing
commentary tradition begins subsequent to
this, but might be thought to include any Han
apocrypha that was written just prior to
canonization. It is considered an error by
many to divide things like this because the
Ten Wings are usually thought to be an
integral part of the Yi. They are neither
integral nor fundamental. In a great many ways
the bulk of the Wing observations are
misleading and distracting. The Xici Zhuan or
Da Zhuan invents a whole metaphysical
philosophy that is projected back onto the
original text, obscuring its earlier meanings.
This includes the ideas of Yin and Yang. The
Zhouyi observes many interesting oppositions,
reciprocities and complementarities, but Yin
and Yang are foreign to it. The Tuan Zhuan and
Xiao Xiang frequently stumble in their
interpretations, using artificial dimensions
that simply do not work to elucidate the
meanings. They do hit the mark on enough
occasions to make them worthy of serious
study, but this study is most useful in
conjunction with a set of critical reasoning
skills. That said, however, the Tuan Zhuan
provides alternative Chinese glosses or terms
or for most of the Gua and these, in nearly
all cases, have played crucial roles in
shaping our understanding of the Gua Ming. In
a few instances, most notably Gua 30, they
have added insights that completely
transformed our understanding.
The Da Xiang simply
reiterates the Gua Ming and so it does not
contribute much to the vocabulary. The ethical
lessons here are not often succinct enough to
serve as key words in shaping our Core
Meanings either. But understanding how the
Bagua fit together to generate the ethical
lessons here adds a great deal of insight to
the Core Meaning's gestalt, and this is in all
64 cases.
The Xu Gua, or recital
on the Hexagram Sequence, adds an occasional
new gloss for the Gua Ming, or a key word for
the Core Meaning, but this is hit and miss,
and tends to be more reliable when transiting
between the inverse or opposite pairs, not the
random sequence between those pairs. It
doesn't always fail here though: pareidolia is
a very useful talent in the process of
discovery. The Za Gua has roughly the same
utility as the Xu Gua, providing the
occasional useful gloss or key word.
The Chinese-language
body of commentary is immense. There are
several thousands of volumes and tracts listed
in the Yixue Bibliography below, especially in
the Sike Quanshu. But one thing becomes clear
in reading the scholars in the Yi's original
language: While becoming truly proficient in
understanding the Yi will require reading the
text in the original (or as much of it as we
can reconstruct), this is not a guarantee of
understanding. The language is necessary but
not sufficient for any real expertise. Over
the last few centuries, translations into
other world languages have added a great deal
of insight into the text and into the Core
Meanings of the Gua. This is for two main
reasons: a) to the extent that the Yi is
describing human universals in social roles
and behaviors, we are broadening and enriching
our perspective on the images and metaphors,
giving us new and perhaps long-lost ways to
look at the original text, and b) since there
are fewer Chinese words to go around (less
than a tenth of the vocabulary of English),
they must of necessity be richer in
connotation and more complex in alternative
and ambiguous meanings, but poorer in
specificity: global languages with broader
vocabularies can articulate and detail the
nuances of meaning better than the original
Chinese can. In short, the optimum study of
the Yi, even the pure study of its original
texts, is multilingual.
The following has a more
general relevance than just to the commentary
tradition: Polysemy, the coexistence of many
possible meanings for a particular word, is a
predominant characteristic of Old Chinese.
Western linguists want to exclude homonyms
from this and, in this effort, try to narrow
the definition of polysemy to a network of
meanings with a common source, root meanings
and shared history. This does not always work
for Chinese, where even the most skillful
pareidolia and speculative etymology cannot
connect the dots between many of the meanings
which share the same character. Elsewhere I
have ranted about the academics' willful
ignorance of this feature of the language,
wherein they will insist that only attested
meanings from outside the text of the Zhouyi
can be used in translating the Zhouyi, and
that using the internal context of the Zhouyi
is off limits in understanding the words used
therein.
However, looking at some
of the polysemous variations on a Chinese word
can have interesting applications in fleshing
out core meanings. Take, for instance, Lí, Gua
Ming 30, to stand out, diverge, or with
special relevance to this Gua, to radiate. The
word made from the Latin words for "stand out"
is Exist. One of the polysemous variations of
Lí is a "bright bird,"
especially an Oriole. Anyone who has ever
looked out onto a stark winter landscape, into
a bush with no leaves or color, and seen a
bright bird like this perched there, now has a
permanent memory of what standing out is all
about. It's also what fire does. Lí also has
associations to a net, probably for catching
either birds or fish. The potential
contribution of this to 30's Core Meaning
might be a bit more obscure, but you can argue
a case for the interconnectedness or
interdependence of the net's structure. Maybe
more relevant is that the Zhou Chinese had an
association of webs or nets (wǎng, see Gua
34.3) with wits, subtlety, cleverness, or a
knack for deception. This is perfectly
consistent with the word Míng, one of Gua 30's
Chinese Key Words, as brightness or
intelligence.
|
|
720 Cell
Appendix:
The Gua Ming as a Dimension of
the Zhouyi
The
following is excerpted from The Book
of Changes: Word By Word,
Volume 2, pp. 8-11. This is another
take from another time, with some
repetition and some additional
analogies.
It may require a
number of analogies to appreciate the
differences between defining a simple
term and charting the full range of
meanings and connotations of a
Hexagram’s Name. Ming, the Chinese word
for Name, also means reputation. Old
Chinese is already much more of a
connotative than a denotative or
definitive language. Its smaller
vocabulary is only due to its words
embodying a greater range of
connections, perceptions and
applications. The set of Gua Names is
like this but much more so (so some of
the principles given here may also be
helpful in better understanding other
examples of the Yijing’s important words
and concepts). Each name is meant to
cover one part in sixty-four of the
human experience. The (fictitious) image
was offered earlier of a large set of
jars to contain the Zhouyi authors’
working notes. Needham, Crowley and
others have already suggested the filing
system metaphor. The notion that these
names are operationally defined
abstracts, which was brought up earlier
in revisiting the discredited
Lacouperie/Conrady lexical theory, is
not a new idea here either. Helmut
Wilhem calls the purpose of this “to
establish collectively valid images.”
(Heaven, Earth & Man, p. 201) and
writes:
It is an interesting phenomenon that
many of these conceptual names of
hexagrams are so-called hapax
legomena; they do not occur
in the earlier literature at places
other than these names, and a number
of them have never been used in the
later literature except in passages
directly derivative from these
hexagrams. What we observe here is
apparently an attempt to create and
formulate concepts for specific
purposes, if not to define them. We
stand witness here to the first
manifestation of a new stage in the
self-realization of the human mind in
which the faculty of judgment is first
exercised and leads to abstractions
distinct from images ... . It would be
a fallacy ... to reduce these concepts
to their image antecedents and to deny
the authors of these early texts the
faculty of abstraction that is
reflected in these terms ... . p. 200
Once conceived, the term then took on
a life of its own, feeding on and
being fed by those regions of the
human mind that are given to
abstractions ... . In the course of
this development, the origin
of the term has become more and more
meaningless and eventually entirely
forgotten. [p. 204] [I have underlined
origin for the benefit of the modern
context critics and etymologists who
seem so reluctant to observe this
process and insist upon using “Piglet”
as a translation for Dun and “Elephant
Dance” for Yu, though these make no
sense at all].
Another analogy might
view these Gua Ming terms as
‘gravitational centers’ within the
imagination, attracting meanings to
themselves in proportion both to their
own mass and a potential new meaning’s
proximity, and forming a system out of
chaotic clouds much as our own solar
system formed. Particles too distant, or
with too much mass or inertia of their
own, would escape this attraction. These
particles array or cluster themselves
into an open set of Key Words, wherein
‘A’ is seldom equal to ‘B.’ These are
correspondence sets, not equivalence
sets. The weak spot in this analogy is
that there is frequently no single,
perfect word or association which
occupies the exact center, or the whole
periphery, of the meaning. Often the
most useful name is one which bridges
the broadest gaps between the meanings.
Or: think of staking
out a new territory. No single stake
will cover the range (unless that range
be too small to graze or farm). And the
more stakes one sets, the fewer are the
subsequent boundary disputes. The
neighbors’ versions of the boundaries
are given equal weight when one goes to
the higher order. Such ‘definition’ of a
wide range of meanings by connotative
Key Words is common to all languages
with a closed or finite number of
vocabulary elements. Here the analogy’s
weak spots are that stakes are as often
placed at landmarks within the terrain
and that these terms are often not
defined entirely by circumscription or
definition: they also take on meanings
according to their abilities to combine
and interrelate, or to be permuted or
extrapolated from. And they are often
defined by references points far outside
of their own domain, by their position
in an overall pattern. The boundaries
here define starting points, or places
to return to. Their intent is not the
compression of meaning but rather its
expansion into the remaining dimensions:
to open the mind, not to fill it up. The
words are meant to be stimuli, not
merely responses. They describe, they do
not determine. They are names for
perspectives, but what is viewed from
these perspectives remains a moving
pageant and hopefully a surprise.
Wang Bi (226-249) of
the Yi Li school (long before it was
named Yi Li) was concerned with the
process of getting to the core meanings
of the names through the ever-growing
clusters of words, a process known as
Zheng Ming or Rectification of Names.
Shaughnessy (1983) translates Wang’s
Zhouyi lueli on the subject of Sao
Xiang (Sweeping Out the Images) at some
length and this warrants inclusion here:
Images are that which express ideas
and language is that which illuminates
images. There is nothing like images
for understanding ideas and nothing
like language for understanding
images. Because language is born of
images, it is possible to follow
language in order to see the images.
And because images are born of ideas,
it is possible to follow images in
order to see the ideas. Ideas are
understood through images, images made
clear through language.
Therefore, since
language is what is used to explicate
images, when you have gotten the
image, forget the language; since
images are what is used to fix ideas,
when you have gotten the idea, forget
the image. ... If the meaning is
‘strength,’ what need is there for
‘horse?’ If the category is
‘obedience,’ what need is there for
‘cow?’ If the line corresponds to
‘obedience,’ what need is there for
Kun to be ‘cow;’ and if the line
corresponds with ‘strength,’ what need
is there for Qian then to be ‘horse?’
And yet, there are
those who establish Qian as ‘horse.’
If correlating the text with the
hexagram, there is ‘horse’ but no
Qian, then artificial theories
propagate and it is difficult to draw
lines. If the ‘internal form’ is
insufficient, they follow it with the
‘hexagram change.’ And if the changed
text is insufficient, they push it
further with the ‘five phases.’ Once
the source has been lost, the
cleverness becomes ever more
intricate. If such cleverness is
allowed to go unchecked, there is no
place to get the meaning, and this is
all because of concentrating on the
image while forgetting the idea.
Forget the images and seek the ideas;
the meaning will then be apparent. [p.
5.]
This approach has its
strengths in terms of finding the center
of the territory, or the gravitational
center of a cluster of meanings. But it
has two problems as well: 1) If one is
premature in dismissing the words and
the images one runs the risk of being
stuck with a wrong or peripheral idea as
a core meaning. Wang Bi himself can
often be found in this predicament. And,
2) To confine oneself to the center
misses the whole point of being in the
center. Focus, in the Yijing, is not the
same thing as narrow mindedness or
tunnel vision. Concentration shares an
etymological root with concentric: a
plurality which shares a center, much as
nested sets do. The center (zhong) has
its greatest value in its being the
locus which is nearest to all of the
options. This makes right and left more
handy, not things to be avoided. To be
stuck in the center is to forgo a
richness and diversity: thereby does
one’s path become a rut. Or imagine a
gem with only one facet. Only a mobius
strip does this and these useless things
go nowhere. On a gem the facets face
apart, and no two face the same
direction. Yet most face also inward
towards a core.
The Yijing is meant
to teach wisdom, and there is much more
to the getting of wisdom than the
getting of the lingo, but this is where
to start in a book. And so it is a good
thing to look for the center in the
midst of a cluster of words. Two other
images may help, and both of these are
related to probability laws: In certain
athletic competitions where individual
performances are rated by a number of
judges, the high and low scores are
often eliminated before an average of
the remaining scores is taken.
Prejudice, or premature judgment, is one
of the reasons for this. In collecting
the Key Words for this edition and
editing them to a manageable number, it
served a purpose to eliminate a great
number of peripheral ideas, especially
those where aspects or other meanings
are shared by other terms. Deferred
gratification, for instance, is a theme
common to many a Gua. But this does not
mean that peripheral ideas do not belong
within the territory. The Key Word study
is meant to help one to get the mind
around the entire center. But expansion
from here is still necessary. Second
image: In the learning of archery, in
the truing of one’s aim, one might first
shoot a whole quiver full of arrows and
only then assess the pattern. Not all
shots are equidistant. Usually it will
be the approximate center of the pattern
which locates the center of one’s aim.
This will probably not be the arrow
found in the neighbor’s yard or cow (the
rooster was something different). The
next step is to fine tune the stance,
and the follow through, and the point of
focus, moving this point of aim
eventually towards the center of the
target. This process is also zhong,
depicting a bullseye and meaning both
true and center.
As described earlier
in the hypothetical history, the known
range of a term’s meanings (semantic
field) both grows and shrinks over time,
and it does so according to both
deductive and inductive logic, both
theoretical and empirical input. This
process is much like life - now
divergent and diastolic, now convergent
and systolic. The word meanings are
grown first and then pruned back, added
to whenever one gets a bright idea or
deleted from whenever an idea fails to
pass its tests against big Substance.
“Turning and returning is the Dao.” In
the broader context of Yixue, the
Yijing’s vocabulary elements are far
less fixed than its various structural
elements. To the extent that the Yi is a
language, its thesaurus is a
loose-leafed notebook rather than a
scripture. Yixue is an evolving
tradition.
The range of the Xiao
Gua (Small Symbol) meanings is fairly
well scoped in the Glossary and in Xiao
Gua. Perhaps the best place to begin to
learn the Gua Ming is in the Glossary.
All of the Gua Names, or at least all of
their components, may be found here. The
Key Words section in the Translation is
a little more adventurous, liberal and
anachronistic. In Xiao Gua, under the Ba
Gua, Glosses From the Text, the Zhouyi
and Wing texts have been combed for
Chinese glosses and synonyms to the
Trigram meanings. The bulk of these came
from the Chong (Repeated Trigram) Gua,
discussed later. But in all of the more
complex Gua the same thing can be done
as an exercise: the text of every Gua
(with its Wing commentaries) offers at
least a few of these glosses and
synonyms. This exercise will prove
especially valuable in cases where the
Gua Ming is used only once, in the Gua
Ci, or is not repeated in the Yao Ci in
a variety of contexts (this happens at
Gua 02, 09, 11, 14, 26, 61, 63 &
64). Normally the Gua Ming is introduced
as a word (or a word combination) which
stands alone out of context. It is only
at Gua 10, 12, 13 & 52 where a Name
makes its entry embedded in textual
syntax. In Old Chinese, having syntax
and a context to work with is almost as
useful as having a dictionary.
Dichotomy, in a
couple of its many forms, was used by
the Zhouyi authors to help define a Gua
Ming against, or in contrast with, that
of a structurally resonant partner. The
structures used here were most often the
dimensions of Inverse Hexagrams (Qian
Gua) and Opposite Hexagrams (Pang Tong
Gua) elaborated upon later. Some of
these are obvious. Among the many
Inverse pairs, look at: 41, Sun,
Decreasing and 42, Yi, Increasing; or
51, Zhen, as motion and 52, Gen, as
rest; or 57, Xun, as mental and 58, Dui,
as emotional. Among the Opposite pairs,
look at 01, Qian, Creating and 02, Kun,
Accepting (this is the courage to change
what I can, along with the serenity to
accept the rest); or 11, Tai, as
interactive and 12, Pi as alienated; or
29, Kan, as water and 30, Li, as fire;
or 51, Zhen, as force and 57, Xun, as
finesse; or 52, Gen, as satiety and 58,
Dui as need. Note here that, in the
above examples, 51, Zhen; 52, Gen; 57,
Xun and 58, Dui were all paired and
contrasted along two different
dimensional axes.
The polarities that
are exhibited on the face of the
hexagram names themselves are by no
means the end of this. The mere presence
of a dimension can often assist the
understanding. Take, for example, the
Opposite pair of 61, Zhong Fu, The Truth
Within and 62, Xiao Guo, Smallness in
Excess. The first concerns how big and
important we feel when we are contained
inside of ourselves, the second concerns
how small and insignificant we feel when
we are alone in the outer world. This
calls to mind a dichotomy in a Leonard
Cohen song: “We are so small between the
stars, so large against the sky ... .”
The juxtaposition and contraposition of
ideas is important throughout the
Yijing, but this has a higher order and
purpose too: in the internal resolution
of paradox as a path to wisdom.
|
|
|
Bibliography
All source texts are listed here: http://www.hermetica.info/YixueBib.htm
|